Is doing good deeds for the sake of rewards from Allah, selfish?

Is doing good deeds for the sake of rewards from Allah, selfish?

This is a typical social darwinist (kafir) mindset. Given that doing good deeds benefits other people, why do they have a problem with this? Which of the two is benefitting people in need?


1) Doing good deeds

2) Not doing good deeds


The truth is, these evil social darwinists are simply looking for excuses for not doing any good deeds, and not helping fellow human beings in need.

Quite the contrary; they want to dominate and harm them...

Nowadays, this Satanic mindset is pretty common in the West where fanatical and immoral atheists are taking over these societies.

:wa:
 
Last edited:
:sl:
is a good deed which is done for the sake of getting rewards in this world accepted by Allah as a good deed?
There are two things to consider. One is mau'ood (promised) and the other is maqsood (target). The worldly benefits of doing good deeds are promised. Whether we do them for worldly benefit or not, we get the promised benefit in this world. So why waste our time for something which is already promised? (I am not saying the ruling here. I don't know whether it is haram, makrooh, mubah, mustahab, sunnah, wajib or fardh).
Seeking the pleasure of Allah with good deeds is the maqsood (target). If we focus on the target, we get the promised things by themselves. After all we don't want to be like those about whom Allah says:

"Ye received your good things in the life of the world, and ye took your pleasure out of them: but today shall ye be recompensed with a Penalty of humiliation: for that ye were arrogant on earth without just cause, and that ye (ever) transgressed." [46:20]​
 
:sl:

Reward lies in worshipping Allah, because he is the only diety worthy of worship. It all depends on the ikhlaas of the person. The highest level of ikhlass is that, as Uthmaan menthioned, to worship Allah solely because he is worthy of our worship. There is nothing wrong with hoping for rewards from Allah azza wa jal, but when deeds are carried out with this intention, the ikhlaas is of a lower level, but it is not wrong, because the person knows that it is only Allah that I am carrying out this action for, and from him is my reward. Same with doing good deeds with the intention of protection from the adhaab of Jahannam, there is Ikhlaas in this too, albeit less that when good deeds are done for Allah alone.

And Allah knows best!
 
Last edited:
:wasalamex

How often has Allah mentioned good deeds alongside rewards, paradise, mercy and forgiveness in al-Qur'aan? Too many times to count, so is worship without reward? Certainly not.

Uthmān;1294416 said:
:salamext:

The primary reason should be in order to worship Allah because he is worthy of our worship. Other reasons are secondary.

See this video from 03:45:

 
Last edited:
:wasalamex

Is worship without reward?

How often has Allah mentioned good deeds alongside with rewards, paradise, forgiveness, mercy and elevation in rank in al-Qur'aan?
:salamext:

True. But I know that the conditions for an act of worship to be accepted are that:

1. It is done with the intention of pleasing Allah
2. It is in comformity with the Qur'an and Sunnah

If the conditions are met, then there will be reward. But I wasn't sure whether doing the deed for the sake of the reward itself was acceptable?
 
Yes, it is just as al Fudayl ibn Iyaad said: "Verily, if an action was done sincerely for the sake of Allah but was not correct, it will not be accepted by Allah. And if the action was correct but not done sincerely it will not be accepted until the act is sincere and correct. For it to be sincere, it has to be done for the sake of Allah and, in order for it to be correct, it has to agree to the sunnah."

Uthmān;1294756 said:
:salamext:

True. But I know that the conditions for an act of worship to be accepted are that:

1. It is done with the intention of pleasing Allah
2. It is in comformity with the Qur'an and Sunnah

If the conditions are met, then there will be reward. But I wasn't sure whether doing the deed for the sake of the reward itself was acceptable?
 
The prophet -s.a.a.w.- said "Deeds are by their intentions, and to every person whatever it is that he intended. So if someone makes Hijra (immigration) for God and his prophet, then his Hijra is for God and his prophet, and whomever makes Hijra for a worldly target or a woman to marry, then his Hijra is for that which he made it for."

The prophet -s.a.a.w.- also told of the three great people; A scholar, A mujahid warrior who died a martyr, and a rich philanthropist, who all went to Hellfire. When they were asked what they did in their lives and they counted the great actions, they were told they are LYING, and they did those things to BE CALLED great scholar, brave warrior, and generous charitable benefactor.

It is the established belief of Sunnah that good deeds has to be for Allah's sake, in order for us to receive a reward for it. Selfish reasons or hidden agendas nullify the reward, and worst of all is Riyaa', lower shirk, which is doing deeds to show others you are good.

Feeling good about a deed though is not a nullifier of good deeds for there is no evidence of that, and it goes naturally with every person whoever disciplined his soul and self to love and rejoice with goodness. Also evidence shows that having the intention of helping others or benefiting mankind or any of God's creatures or Islam, is also worthy of God's reward, like the man who felt sorry for the dog and gave it water when he saw it thirsty and therefore the prophet said his sins were forgiven.

However we must learn to ALWAYS have God in our hearts when we think of doing good deeds, or the intention of helping and benefiting others and Islam.
 
As far as i know we can do good deeds seeking worldly pleasure or goods, seeking good things in this dunya is not a bad thing but as a muslim we should keep our objectives straight which is to strive for aakhirah, thats our greatest victory as allah azzawajal says in the quran.

but yet we dont know what is good for us in dunya, so we should always ask for afia... in eveything


salaam alaikum
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top