is nasheed becoming too modernised?? e. 786

  • Thread starter Thread starter Helena
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 58
  • Views Views 7K

are nasheeds becoming too mordenised??

  • Total voters
    0
:confused: :confused:
helena said:
:sl:

so wot everybody thinks out there? r they using haalal music in there song as in islam beauty of the voice and drums r accepted in islam. Y include music?? Alhamdulilah i enjoy the words of 786 but the music puts me off!!
:w:
Click to expand...
sista listen yh thier intention was to have music in the nasheeds
dont take me in rong but yh i think dey have got beautiful nasheeds
and another thing is dat 786 dont mean bismillah:hmm:
 
Re: Nasheeds!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Nawal89 said:
It depends. I feel the nasheeds today dont do any good. They are full of music which is not allowed. Plus look at the people that sing it. Its just for money. I'm not saying you cant listen to it, just how i feel.
Click to expand...

salam
i agree, why can't people just say the word instead of singing it? why add instrumental with the singing? i don't like nasheeds becasue it is no good and that is my opinion
wasalam
 
Re: Nasheeds!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Salam.
In my opinion, the whole nasheed industry has gone into a stage where it is just an alternative to hip hop and rap music. Its funny that this thread came up, because I asked a few of my teachers from Madinah and they had the opinion that these so-called nasheeds were no different to the music of the kuffar and therefore, we should not listen to them.
Wassalam.
 
Assalamualykum,
Some interesting points have been highlighted and discussed in this thread.
Could we please have a list of the Nasheeds and Nasheed artists that are OK to listen to
Jazakallah Khair
 
Re: Nasheeds!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ghurabaa2000 said:
sori to be so serious guys, but the nasheeds with music in them today are not allowed, because music according to the salaf is completely haram, through evidence from the prophet(pbuh). Ibn Hamz is the only scholar of the salaf who allows it however Ibn taymmaih, iman nawahi, ibn al-qayyam and many others say that his opinion is very weak. however i am a very big fan of nasheeds with out any music or just the drum because their narrations which allow this and even reccomend it in certain cases. it allows us to get away from the filth of western music and bollywood. however just remember nothing can beat the the words of Allah...(listen to Ibrarhm-al jibreen) if any one wants evidence just let me know, the only reason why i didnt post it is coz it needs long explanation
Click to expand...

So, Ibn Hazm's opinion is not acceptable?
 
salam
on the top of the page, near the number of pages go to thread tools and then add a thread sis
wasalam
 
hmmm...yeah they have started to add music.....and well its sad coz they never used to before so puts me off listening.....but subhanallah there are some who have no music and inshallah they will continue that way.....Allah has blessed all with beautiful voices so wht need is there for music???
 
Re: Nasheeds!!!!!!!!!!!!!

azim said:
Without being a party pooper...theres been loads of threads like this and they all end up wth heated debates about whether or not it's halal and ususally are quite counter-productive. :P
Click to expand...
That statement also describes rock stars.

:p
 
Re: Nasheeds!!!!!!!!!!!!!

mizan_aliashraf said:
Salam.
In my opinion, the whole nasheed industry has gone into a stage where it is just an alternative to hip hop and rap music. Its funny that this thread came up, because I asked a few of my teachers from Madinah and they had the opinion that these so-called nasheeds were no different to the music of the kuffar and therefore, we should not listen to them.
Wassalam.
Click to expand...

So your teachers from Madinah actually listened to these so called nasheeds and then made that fatwa?

I wonder if it's okay to listen to it once, then. ;D
 
Re: Nasheeds!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Takumi said:
So your teachers from Madinah actually listened to these so called nasheeds and then made that fatwa?

I wonder if it's okay to listen to it once, then. ;D
Click to expand...
lol. It's kind of like one of these 'dodgy molvis' saying 'Hey, don't smoke pot. It tastes nothing like a water pipe'

From shisha to hashish :p

(note: dodgy molvis do not represent the entirety of the hardworking scholar community, they're just the weirdo slackers)
 
Last edited:
Re: Nasheeds!!!!!!!!!!!!!

:sl:
isnt it really odd..how sum peepz say music OUTRIGHT is haram (i studied in an islamic school..and all i ever heard was music is haraam tv is haraam..)
then there'z other 'scholars' who say that there'z nothing wrong with music...
:confused:...
i mean it all gets a bit confusin for those who have jus recently embraced islam..
well..whle we're on the topic..can anyone put up a ruling regarding music..where the evidence is absolutely solid..with no weakness..
so then my mind is at ease..:)
jazakallahukhair..
:w:
 
Yes i believe that nasheeds are becoming way tooo modernized

Whats that guys name...

Yusuf Islam is he on the sunnah???

Does'nt he make up nasheeds???

SaLaMz
 
Re: Nasheeds!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Rasulullah [Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam] states, ‘A group of my Ummah will drink wine calling it by other than its real name. merry will be made for them through the playing of musical instruments and by the singing of females. Allah will cleave the earth under them and turn them into apes and swines.’

Like i said earlier majority of the salaf said music is haram e.g Abu Hanifa, Imam Malik, Shafi'i, Ahmed bin hanbal, Ibn Taymiyyah, Ibn Kathir, so many more
 
Re: Nasheeds!!!!!!!!!!!!!

well, i very very rarely listen 2 nasheeds buh i dont think there is anythg bad in listeing to themm..they r islamic..n dont even have music
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top