Islam teaches violence?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Assalamualykum everyone. I am brand new to these forums, as I questions regarding the Islam and I require help. Hopefully I can increase my knowledge and become closer to Allah by joining these forums. I am a brother from Canada, and from my personal experience it is very hard coming up as a Muslim here. There are so many bad influences every single day that I need to over-come and Alhamdulillah so far I am okay. Also, in Canada, there is a LOT of atheists and Christians especially in my school (I am 15 years old). Whenever I read anything online or hear things about Islam in real-life, I always, always hear things about Islam teaching violence. I always see these posts about ISIS saying dua'a and then killing people and all this non-sense. I refuse to believe it, because I know it's not true. On the Internet I read people quoting the Quran verses and they attack Islam viciously naudhubillah saying that we're a death cult and things. Well, I don't know how to answer or rebut these people. I am unknowledged and I see guidance on how to deal with this. I would also appreciate if you can help me understand that indeed Islam does not teach violence. JazakAllah.

:wasalam: akhi,

I advise you to read Surah At-Tawbah, start to finish,

http://quran.com/9

Islam Prescribes Violence as a Last Resort, and even then it offers the Enemies of Islam the chance to gain protection, and even goes so far as to escort them to a place of Security if they desire Peace (ie. At-Tawbah : Ayah 6)

Islam however doesn't teach the Muslims to be Cowards, or "Turn the Cheek" when you are attacked.

Allah ta'ala says,

Surah Baqarah : Ayah 216
-------------------------
"Fighting is prescribed for you, and ye dislike it. But it is possible that ye dislike a thing which is good for you, and that ye love a thing which is bad for you. But Allah knoweth, and ye know not."


:jz:
 
Thar article is written by modernists who attempt to pull the wool over the eyes of people who don't have knowledge of the deen.




The article quotes qaradawi here and there, who himself belongs to the modernist brigade,




Assalaamu alaikum brother Abu Musab,


Thank you for sharing the fruits of your knowledge.


However, I have read of Classical scholars who have disagreed with one another. I have also read that excellent manners were considered by these scholars as a fundamental requirement for a person to be considered a true scholar.


I question whether it is of the highest degree of politeness to label a person with whom one disagrees, in (what seems to me to be) a dismissive or derogatory manner.


It is true that Dr. Jamal Badawi, the author of the quoted article is not an official scholar of Islam. He used to be a University professor of Business Administration in Canada. However, I have met him, and I have had the pleasure of knowing some of his family, and I know him to be a very sincere and devout Muslim. He has excellent manners, is kind with his intimates, and has been very active in nurturing the Muslim Community in Nova Scotia (a Canadian province). And he has read widely, keeps good company, and struggles to understand Allah's Will, and teach to others what he believes may be of benefit for them, for the Ummah in general, and for all persons Allah has Created.


He is also (as I understand it. Certainly, he has met with him on repeated occasions) a personal friend of Sheikh Al-Qaradawi, who is a scholar of great knowledge and depth, and also a very polite and sincere believer, in my opinion.


By all means, disagree with other's opinions. And bring forth your arguments and proofs for us all to know and understand. A sincere effort to understand Allah's Will is incumbent on us all. But I would suggest that you honour those who precede us in age and experience, as well as scholarly knowledge.


Because, as the Classical scholars used to say : I may be incorrect, and my opponent may be correct, and really, only Allah truly Knows.


May Allah, the Source of all knowledge and harmony, have Mercy on us, and Guide us to that which Pleases Him most.
 
From what I can gather - apostates are not be killed, unless they are also guilty of treason - in which case it is totally justified. Even today, in the so called age of enlightenment - treason is still a crime that is punishable by death - in non Muslim lands. So really, there is no issue here.

Scimi
 
Last edited:
Assalam alaykum


This subject isn't difficult and can be answered insha'Allah. Islam is a way of life, which we should follow by following what Allah has commanded us to, by following the sunnah of prophet muhammed(saw) and the salaf.

During the life of the prophet (peace be upon him) muslims were faced with such troubles and oppressions, that violence was the only answer to stop the oppression. We are only allowed to use it in certain circumstances, so yes the qu'ran has verses which mentions fighting and battles but there are certain conditions to this and if you don't obey these conditions you are a trangressor.

But peace should always be the first answer and fighting the last resort. In my opinion islam is not a religion of peace nor of war but it is the religion of justice and equality. A way of life pleasing the creator Azza wa jal.
 
Last edited:
The world is not a peaceful place. If you are peaceful you will be enslaved or wiped out. Is there any country without an army? Even the so called peaceful Buddhists go on rampages and kill Muslims. The big countries have nukes to threaten each other with and one day WW3 will be upon us. So don't worry if people say Islam is a death cult. They are the pot calling the kettle black, the hypocrites.

BTW those guys that were "beheaded" by ISIS or IS or what ever. Seem to have a better complexion after their head is cut off. What a fake outfit.
 
Last edited:
The world is not a peaceful place. If you are peaceful you will be enslaved or wiped out. Is there any country without an army? Even the so called peaceful Buddhists go on rampages and kill Muslims. The big countries have nukes to threaten each other with and one day WW3 will be upon us. So don't worry if people say Islam is a death cult. They are the pot calling the kettle black, the hypocrites.

Being peaceful doesn't mean not fight if oppressed by other people, but not aggressive and will not fight if not attacked by other people first. All religions are peaceful, but unfortunately not all believers are peaceful.

BTW those guys that were "beheaded" by ISIS or IS or what ever. Seem to have a better complexion after their head is cut off. What a fake outfit.

This is one thing that makes me can't support IS, they always execute their prisoners of war, and easy to kill those who disagree with them, even if those who disagree are other Muslims.

This month Hizbut Tahrir report that IS executed one HT senior member in Syria, Mustafa Khayal (Abu Bakar), just because he criticized IS.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4hasdo2enZs#t=277

May Allah gives Mustafa Khayal a beautiful place in Jannah.
 
Assalamualykum everyone. I am brand new to these forums, as I questions regarding the Islam and I require help. Hopefully I can increase my knowledge and become closer to Allah by joining these forums. I am a brother from Canada, and from my personal experience it is very hard coming up as a Muslim here. There are so many bad influences every single day that I need to over-come and Alhamdulillah so far I am okay. Also, in Canada, there is a LOT of atheists and Christians especially in my school (I am 15 years old). Whenever I read anything online or hear things about Islam in real-life, I always, always hear things about Islam teaching violence. I always see these posts about ISIS saying dua'a and then killing people and all this non-sense. I refuse to believe it, because I know it's not true. On the Internet I read people quoting the Quran verses and they attack Islam viciously naudhubillah saying that we're a death cult and things. Well, I don't know how to answer or rebut these people. I am unknowledged and I see guidance on how to deal with this. I would also appreciate if you can help me understand that indeed Islam does not teach violence. JazakAllah.

wa alaikum assalaam wa rahmatullah.

As you know that Muhammad salla Allaho alaihi wa sallam was the final Prophet of Islam, He was the first to act upon the Holy Quraan. You must know about His response to the enemies. He salla Allaho alaihi wa sallam did preaching in secret for 3 years when he used to invite to the Faith of Oneness of God Allah only close friends and relatives. After 3 years He started preaching openly. He only told the idolaters to worship only one God Allah and that mankind is responsible for their Faith and deeds, that there is life after death in which every person shall be accounted and rewarded or punished according to his/her Faith and deeds. He advised them NOT to kill their innocent newborn daughters. He also advised not to attack eachother tribes killing them and kidnapping their girls. In short the Arab people were in terrible darkness attacking each other and burying alive their own newborn daughters, and they used to worship their hand-made idols. The Prophet salla Allaho alaihi wa sallam invited them to the light of Islam but they became His enemies. They started beating and torturing the new Muslims. For 12 and a-half years the Prophet salla Allaho alaihi wa sallam and His companions were patient. The idolaters killed some of the Muslim slaves. The first Muslim woman was a slave of Abu Jahal, she got killed by Abu Jahl and became the first martyr of this Ummah. Finally they made plans to kill Muhammad salla Allaho alaihi wa sallam just because He preached Islam. By that time people had accepted Islam in Madinah, they invited the Prophet salla Allaho alaihi wa sallam and His companions to Madinah. This is called Hijrah. Even they had to make hijrah i.e. leave Makkah to Madinah in secret because the idolators/unbelievers didn't let them go to Madinah.


While making hijrah The Muslims had to leave their shops, businesses, wealth etc. and went to Madinah empty-handed. The unbelievers in Makkah and in the surrounding Arabia became very jealous with the progress of Islam. So they started attacking the Muslims in Madinah. It was only then (after more than 13 years of Islam) that Allah gave permission to the Prophet salla Allaho alaihi wa sallam and His companions to respond to the enemies and then Allah gave them Help so they won and became successful.


You can find from the history that the battles of Badar, Uhud and the battle of Trench were all fought near Madinah which is a manifest proof that the kaafirs had attacked the Muslims in their own state Madina. Then who is violent???

In the present world, you can see again that Muslims are attacked and are killed in their own countries, cities, streets and homes. Can you tell me any non Muslim country which is attacked by Muslims and where the Muslims are killing the helpless non- Muslims??? I believe we cannot find a non Muslim country attacked by Muslims but the opposite is true. Then who is violent? And Who are the real killers? The answer is very clear.

But I advise you just to practice Islam, making 5 prayers daily, helping needy, fasting in Ramadhan and remain patient. Don't get involved in arguments with the unjust unbelievers. They themselves know that they are unjust and violent but due to power they lie forcefully. So be patient and pray to Allah to send Help to the oppressed Muslims. That will be great!!!
 
If you have the chance, make friends with Muslims from countries other than the Middle-East.

Why would you recommend avoiding the Middle East, when the Middle East is the home and cradle of Islam? When the Middle East is the source of Islamic jurisprudence, as taught at Al-Azhar University in Egypt, which it is my understanding is the most prestigious institution of Islamic instruction in the world.
 
Why would you recommend avoiding the Middle East, when the Middle East is the home and cradle of Islam? When the Middle East is the source of Islamic jurisprudence, as taught at Al-Azhar University in Egypt, which it is my understanding is the most prestigious institution of Islamic instruction in the world.

!. Don't search the Islamic way of life in the Middle East now. You can find true Islam in the Quraan and Sunnah Books only. You cannot find the Islamic Law and perfect Islam in any country now. If there was true Islam in practice in the world now, the whole world would be full of safety, peace and free justice for all.

2. You are giving us the example of the Middle East for the BLACK AND FALSE accusation of violence on Islam. Don't you see that the violence in the Muslim countries is due to the non-Muslim countries that are using their made weapons for massacres on the innocent Muslim women, children and men. I understand that the Muslims left following the Quraan and Sunnah (the way of their Prophet), so due to the Anger of Allah they lost the Help of Allah. The result is that the Muslims are killed by the weapons of the non- Muslims.
 
Possibly, Jonathan. But I don't think so somehow. Because islam is predominantly a religion of peace. However, it has really been allowed to remain peaceful with provocation by certain quarters.

For example, the minority Jews totally dominating the Middle East, and recent senseless provocation by the cartoons episode, and many other instances where islam is attacked without reason and thought. People will react.

Some of the quotes you refereed to above has their roots to explain. It is not your everyday licence to behave in that way. But say, if you were oppressed and wronged... then what?

It's like if we're to learn martial arts, does that mean we should go around looking for a fight? Or should we never back down from a challenge? Or does it mean that if we need to defend ourselves, we use the knowledge?

Like what Christianity teaches, (as opposed to the lessons from the Torah - eye for an eye) the 'elevated' message of the Bible is to turn the other cheek (to forgive) is very much in keeping with islam. To forgive and be patient.

:peace:
 
Greetings,

I have deleted off-topic posts and will be closing the thread.

Johnathan, I hope you will note that misquoting Islamic texts or judging Islam by UNIslamic actions of a minority is just as incorrect as people doing the same to your own faith. Please refrain from this in future.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Back
Top