Islam vs. Science, Are Muslim beliefs compatible with critical inquiry?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Science101
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 27
  • Views Views 5K
Status
Not open for further replies.
;D :hmm: Sorry for deviating from the original topic (I blame Guyabano :mad:) :( :-[ :hiding:


Nah, I'm not violent, neither out for revenenge. My name is not NoName-Something. :D

But before you put the blame on me, at least, have the decency to go back in the thread, and check, where 'BIll Gates' was mentionned first, so you will notice the relation and why he got named first.
 
The problem is that in a lot of the developing Islamic countries (Pakistan for instance), the people are ritual worshippers of Islam. They sit at home and pray all day and do nothing to impact society. Then we have the radicals who have to oppress and make a big deal about the smallest of things in the name of Islam.

If we look at the Jews, we see that a lot of them are educated and we find them running a lot of the media and educational institutions. As Muslims, we have to understand that a proper education is key to advancing our Ummah and progressing the societies around us whether it be in the USA, UK, Pakistan, Afghanistan, or wherever. The Muslims who are well educated and have knowledge are the ones who will gain respect and will be listened to. Not the extremist nutjobs who rampage the streets saying "Convert to Islam or die!"

Gaining knowledge and propogating Islam intellectually was what made Islam spread so fast back then and it should be the case today. That, in my opinion, is the best way to worship Allah. I pray that Allah gives the Muslim generations of today the complusion to become educated people and advance the societies of the world just as the Quran instructs.

:w:
 
I get off topic myself. No harm done Z.Al-Rashid (and mayam11). Besides, PureAmbrosia is here so there's no telling what will happen next! Hee Hee.. :giggling:

I woke up earlier than usual before work to answer any replies so I was in my morning-mood, anyway. Was getting worried that this thread would digress into science bashing. And not to get off topic again, but I did google the question and from what I found Bill Gates is Agnostic. If that is true then he believes in a higher power. Although, like many, including me, organized religion cannot accurately describe the way we view God/Allah so we do not belong to any single group. Many scientists seem to be that way although there are some very regular church going scientists so that is not the rule.

Maybe this is also a good time to mention that I have no formal college education or a "degree". I'm a self-learner that has been learning from home courses, books, electronic and science kits, discussions with scientists and educators, and the free internet tutorials are the greatest thing that has happened to education in my lifetime. When I was young there were no science classes in school at the level I wanted to learn at, so I had no choice but to find books at the library to keep me busy and talk my parents into buying science supplies they could afford. Resources for kids that want to know more than they normally learn in school is also important.

When I talk about science education I'm not normally thinking expensive colleges that many cannot afford. I'm thinking about the kind of education anyone who enjoys science can obtain off the internet. Of course, going to college has advantages, but that is not necessary to become a respected man or woman of science. Besides, many graduate from expensive colleges with a fancy degree but never make anything of it. So what is primarily required is love for science and dedication.

There are many things that require no college degree. From the looks of things there are now opportunities for Muslims who know how to reconcile modern science and religion. Are no college degrees in that. And this Muslim oriented Health and Science forum is one of the greatest places I can think of work through, don't need an expensive laboratory. Can collaborate with others right here. Might not be much money in reconciling science and religion but people will remember you. Especially if your work then helps begin another Islamic golden age of science.

Like NYCmuslim pointed out, it's a worthy thing to do in a religious sense. I would say it's like being a prophet. Might even find that scientists will follow you but I doubt that many would fully convert to Islam. I would expect that some would incorporate some of your religious views into their agnostic religious views and doing just that is an accomplishment to be very proud of.

And as NYCmuslim also pointed out there is a point where worship becomes damaging to both Islam and the one that becomes too immersed in ritual. I believe it because I have seen it happen to people from other religions. Finding a better balance makes one a peacemaker like Muhammad. Hopefully someone here will take on that honorable calling.

I have to also add that there seems to be enough recognition of Muslim math and science in Western history books and it's been on TV too. Might be better just to bring that golden age back again. Then it will seem like it never really ended.

And hopefully maryam11 can find something to add to the thread. They seem to like the topic, it's moving in the right direction, and I don't want to leave anyone out. All Muslims in this forum have great value to this discussion.

If we focus on a solution then I think we will find one that works. Of course, I can't call myself a Muslim, just someone who sees the good in Islam. I'm happy to leave the glory to Muslims who can do a better job than I can with the religious aspects of this. And if this thread leads to something good in the future then that would be an accomplishment for me to be very proud of.
 
Last edited:
oh shocking ! You're even right. After some research on the web, I found out that Bill Gates is an Atheist, who doesn't believe in the existence of a higher being.
OH DRAMA !! Since Bill Gates earns 225 US Dollar per second, it means that most muslims here on the net having WINDOWS as OS support him, an Atheist.

Now let's see, where are the Atheist Bashers?

he also has Asperger's syndrome but that is a story for another day... I hated to fail to meet the expectations of science.. whatever they may have been?..

Now.. I don't know that anyone is an Atheist basher/hater per se.. what it is, .. is that atheists (in general) push the envelope when it comes to expressing or rather not expressing deference to sanctities, thus rendering themselves vulnerable to attacks... I can't assimilate to an atheist what it means to offend since we are not really speaking of something tangible.. but I like to use the example of (mothers) as most decent people don't tolerate ill spoken of their moms and rightfully so.. so now we should exercise the art of transference and with any hope, relate at best, understand in least.. why some lose their temper...

Anyhow, it is Ramadan and I don't wish to wrangle over nonesense... besides that I lost someone dear to me yesterday and I am just so imsad
it all seems to trivial at this point...

so science et al. enjoy your triumphs!

peace!
 
Thanks alcurad! That is very encouraging.

After studying Islam and current world events, including what has been said in this thread, it seems like everything is in place. Only need the right words in the right places. Perhaps that should be what we focus on next.

The parts of the Muslim world that could use this the most is now coming online. I would imagine that many will be looking for solutions. Maybe we should prepare something for them that will also be interesting reading for non-Muslims. Can start off with a brief "science in the Quran" that does not attempt to prove that it was from Allah since that leads to debate and would have scientists requesting empirical scientific evidence so they can test that hypothesis in their laboratory. But it would still be acceptable to describe what is there. Writing something that scientists would find well written, concerning a religious topic, would help show how to separate science from religion. For example, we would never say "Allah said" since we would then have to come up with a test or experiment to prove that Allah said it, which would be impossible unless we could have Allah go to all the laboratories for scientists to see and test. So scientists would stop reading what we wrote after seeing that because it says something we cannot prove. But we can say "According to the Quran" or similar phrase. We then only have to prove that the Quran says what we say it does, which is easy! I know a few non-Muslim scientists (some teachers) who will review it for us to make sure it is "scientific".

Anyway, before I ramble on all night about it, I will just ask what you and others think we could do to help start the next golden age of Islamic science.
 
And I'm sorry to hear about your loss PurestAmbrosia. Just stay strong so they can remain in your heart.

I will, as always, be dreaming of peace, too...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Back
Top