It annoys them??.....when a popstar wears a hijab

there are many french videos - media discussions related to this article in youtube .. but i didnt find english translated/sub titled
 
Does she still sing? Presumably her own music is now haram to her - which is a little bizarre?
 
she no longer sings, and what is a little bizarre?
 
شَادِنُ;1554416 said:
what is a little bizarre?
Click to expand...
To be not allowed to listen to your own music - that's bizarre.

Am I right in thinking that there are a number of Islamic US rappers who do still sing?
 
Independent said:
To be not allowed to listen to your own music - that's bizarre.
Click to expand...
Yes you failed to elucidate why that is bizarre? Many non-Muslim singers and actors refuse to see their work for completely different reasons all together, it has nothing to do with her being Muslim. I have written poetry and prose since I was a kid and don't like to read them after I'd written them!


Independent said:
Am I right in thinking that there are a number of Islamic US rappers who do still sing?
Click to expand...

I don't know, I don't like listening to rap or people sing in general. There are people who do nasheeds/chants however and even those I don't generally have an ear for. Perhaps someone else can answer that one for you.


best,
 
شَادِنُ;1554421 said:

Yes you failed to elucidate why that is bizarre? Many non-Muslim singers and actors refuse to see their work for completely different reasons all together, it has nothing to do with her being Muslim. I have written poetry and prose since I was a kid and don't like to read them after I'd written them!

best,
Click to expand...

Sister, how do you improve your skills if you dont go back and read them? I am just curious.:hmm:
 
Allah<3 said:
Sister, how do you improve your skills if you dont go back and read them? I am just curious.:hmm:
Click to expand...

After I am completely done including editing I don't want to read it again, I get really sick of it. It is like listening to the same song over and over, say the barney song, albeit an annoying one but just as an example if you keep hearing it and hearing it, will absolutely drive you nuts.
Sob7an Allah the only book i can read and listen to repeatedly is the Noble Quran.. in fact it is the only thing in the world that gives me comfort!
 
Independent said:
Does she still sing? Presumably her own music is now haram to her - which is a little bizarre?
Click to expand...
I was wondering the same thing.

I had assumed that singing/rapping in itself was NOT haram - only the use of certain instruments is (Oh, I should have read those many threads on music in Islam more carefully ...)

Would she still be permitted to rap? A good pro-Palestine rap might be nice, for example. Or one on wearing hijab.
 
she said in so many words that she was unhappy in her old life and tried several times to commit suicide before she converted. What's wrong with someone wanting to give up an old chapter in their life and starting a new one?
Which is by the way what the French are trying to force her to do go back to work that is and take off her hijab so she won't be a 'bad role model' for kids and when that didn't work they questioned her state of mind.
They're some of the nastiest bigots I have encountered. Militant secularism!
 
شَادِنُ;1554444 said:
she said in so many words that she was unhappy in her old life and tried several times to commit suicide before she converted. What's wrong with someone wanting to give up an old chapter in their life and starting a new one?
Click to expand...
Nothing wrong at all. She sounds like a much more grounded and fulfilled person than she was before.

I was just wondering if she was still PERMITTED to rap - if she chose to continue using her voice for singing now she has converted to Islam.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top