Lool Funny incident

Life_Is_Short said:
Actually, none of us did until you presented the explanation and the title "lool funny incident" certainly didn't help.
Click to expand...

Well the title is just a title, hope you understand now. But why are you protective over christianity anyways? is not like I did something bad. You should never jump to conclusion just because of the title.
 
Mohamed_Sadiq said:
Well the title is just a title, hope you understand now. But why are you protective over christianity anyways? is not like I did something bad. You should never jump to conclusion just because of the title.
Click to expand...

In what way am i being protective over christianity?

You're explaining an incident in writing, not face to face. If you can't be asked to explain yourself fully the first time round at least don't blame others for "jumping to conclusion".

Mohamed_Sadiq said:
Today I was doing voluntary work in my local library and i was sorting out where to put certain books for different sections and I got kicked out of the library for putting all the Bibles in the Fiction Section, Lool it was mad!;D:raging:;D
Now I won't get no good reference from this voluntary job but I don't care;D
Click to expand...

^Did you expect us to congratulate you after reading that?
 
Last edited:
aadil77 said:
Big difference mate, moving the location of a book doesn't quite compare to insulting the most important prophet in islam - by drawing him as a terrorist or an animal, the op had certain reasoning and intentions behind what he did, he proved it to the point that the library apoligised to him. So even the library acknowledged it wasn't an issue of lack of respect.
Click to expand...

This is all very subjective, really. I have no doubt that the community on Rapture Ready would get very offended if you were to deliberately move the Bible to the fiction section to make a cheap point. Just as much perhaps as some Muslims might feel when they see Mohammed being mocked.
 
Do you have to touch another religion's holy book to prove something to the muslims? That's not a nice thing to do. I'm not judging you, I know your intention wasn't bad, but I'm judging the deed.There have been enough well-known incidents that show the attitude of non-muslims to muslims.
 
**muslimah** said:
:sl:
Sister, mistakes happen.
Click to expand...

:sl:

Agreed


and I am certain each of us has done far worse. Let us not condemn the thread starter for an understandable act. We may disagree with the action, but let us each stick only to why we disagree with the action and not judge nor condemn the intent.

The thread starter has an excellent reputation and has often shown signs of piety and high eeman Let us cease from trying to judge and condemn his intent.
 
Lol, I thought it was funny until I realized it was an experiment. It's pointless to gauge their reactions though - just like their actions against muslims.
 
im not judging you, but if u keep on doing stupid things like that, people are not always going to act so soft and cool about it. imagine if they turned around and started abusing our prophet (saw)? believe me i saw it happen before. i don't really know whether this little stunt helped anything or helped muslims in anyway. it was just something a child would do
 
Alhamdulilah I am happy that i did that experiment and it helped a lot and also it helped others, if you think what i did was wrong then you have a soft heart, sometime you have to toughen up and do something that can put you into a tricky situation. Alhamudlilah everything went OK!

If i had the oppurtunity to do it again i would loved to do it. Its just an adventure and this adventure was a covert-experiment that went good. If u don't agree with the experiment then thats ur opinion and your more than welcome to give ur opinion as it is good to learn of other people's ideas.
 
Mohamed_Sadiq said:
Alhamdulilah I am happy that i did that experiment and it helped a lot and also it helped others, if you think what i did was wrong then you have a soft heart, sometime you have to toughen up and do something that can put you into a tricky situation. Alhamudlilah everything went OK!

If i had the oppurtunity to do it again i would loved to do it. Its just an adventure and this adventure was a covert-experiment that went good. If u don't agree with the experiment then thats ur opinion and your more than welcome to give ur opinion as it is good to learn of other people's ideas.
Click to expand...

Allah has already told us what is in their hearts. You do not need to be conducting experiments to know this. Your duty is to give dawah. Allah will give each soul what he earned. It's not our job to see who is thinking what.
 
Scents of Jannah said:
Allah has already told us what is in their hearts. You do not need to be conducting experiments to know this. Your duty is to give dawah. Allah will give each soul what he earned. It's not our job to see who is thinking what.
Click to expand...


My experiment was not to see whats inside their hearts but to show the naive and lost muslims that they should watch out from these people. As all their kindness is just fake and how they want you to lose your religion. Basically my experiment was a wake up call for the lost muslims so that they dont follow them around like dogs. Hope you understand.
 
Well you said it yourself that you wanted to see how they would react if a muslim did it. Anyway, whatever your reason brother, it isn't in any way benefiting you or others. InshaAllah, you can benefit lost muslims by calling them to the deen, then they will realize other things too. Do you understand?
 
Scents of Jannah said:
Well you said it yourself that you wanted to see how they would react if a muslim did it. Anyway, whatever your reason brother, it isn't in any way benefiting you or others. InshaAllah, you can benefit lost muslims by calling them to the deen, then they will realize other things too. Do you understand?
Click to expand...

Afcourse there are many ways you can help a lost muslim and my experiment was one of it. Also afcourse i wanted to see their reaction so that i can prove it to those naive lost muslims that think these people are their brothers, subahanallah. Why don't you give out ur ideas, on how to show these lost naive muslims that these kuffars are not angels because there are muslims that think that these kuffars are the best.
 
brother i just want to advise you for sake of Allah not to keep making these mistakes. its for your own good,

do you know the beauty of the believer is to be humble and kind to muslims and even non muslims. we must

be gentle and be careful of not making jokes or pulling funny stunts like that in future. you don't know who

you are going to end up hurting. it is totally haraam for us to take the piss out of other religions so this is a

sin thats why i told you to repent for it because it is not the character of a muslim. now Allah has given us

iman Alhamdulilah if we laugh at others, Allah could take it away. we should never be so proud and to

over confident in ourselves. why are you acting like they harmed you or something? i didnt get any

indication of that in your post. yes i might be soft but no kaffir has drove me out of my home yet :)

Alhamduliah.
 
cat eyes said:
brother i just want to advise you for sake of Allah not to keep making these mistakes. its for your own good,

do you know the beauty of the believer is to be humble and kind to muslims and even non muslims. we must

be gentle and be careful of not making jokes or pulling funny stunts like that in future. you don't know who

you are going to end up hurting. it is totally haraam for us to take the piss out of other religions so this is a

sin thats why i told you to repent for it because it is not the character of a muslim. now Allah has given us

iman Alhamdulilah if we laugh at others, Allah could take it away. we should never be so proud and to

over confident in ourselves. why are you acting like they harmed you or something? i didnt get any

indication of that in your post. yes i might be soft but no kaffir has drove me out of my home yet :)

Alhamduliah.
Click to expand...

Jazakallah sister for your concerns, i know you seem upset with my action (experiment) and also as i was aware of my actions, i did not hurt any1, ok maybe i broke those naive lost muslims heart by showing them what their so called friends are but no other harm was done. Lol.
Sometimes you have to do something to remind others of their purpose of life and not to get distracted by the kuffars. Also afcourse these Kuffars did something to me but also to all my Muslims sisters and brothers in the world.

Insha allah everything wil be khair, and thanks for your opinion.
 
Mohamed_Sadiq said:
Afcourse there are many ways you can help a lost muslim and my experiment was one of it. Also afcourse i wanted to see their reaction so that i can prove it to those naive lost muslims that think these people are their brothers, subahanallah. Why don't you give out ur ideas, on how to show these lost naive muslims that these kuffars are not angels because there are muslims that think that these kuffars are the best.
Click to expand...

:sl:

Good point.

Each person has different skills in how to do Da'wah. What works for me may not work for you and vice versa.

For myself I have never been able to use pointing out the wrongs of others as a means to guide to what is right. It always ends up doing no more than showing that somebody is bad, but it does nothing to show Islam is right. If I could show that every non-Muslim on earth is evil, it would in no way show that Islam is good it would simply raise the thought that all people including Muslims are evil and for my self it would back fire and drive a person to atheism before it pointed them towards Islam.

If I tried to use that method as a means to teach naive Muslims not to follow the Kaffirs, I would run into similar problems. Or worse I would find myself teaching them to stereotype people and see no hope or need to spread Islam to the Kaffir.

Also if I tried it I fear it could raise admiration of the Kaffir as it would show the Kaffir will protect their Bible. My trying that would most likely result in the naive finding an attraction for Christianity. I could end up accidentally encouraging a weak Muslim to become an apostate.

For myself the best approach is to simply show the truth about Islam and let that truth be the defense against any kaffir.

But, what I find to work for me does not mean it will work for somebody else.
 
Let me get this right.
You (a) did something which you thought might (b) provoke Christians to react angrily, so you could (c) then demonstrate their reactions to those Muslims which you believe are too positive towards Christians (people you believe to be bad Muslims on account of giving Christians too much respect), hoping that (d) it would turn those Muslims away from their Christian friends?

Am I the only one who thinks this is very strange? :uuh:

It doesn't sound like Da'wah to me at all. It's more like manipulating a situation to create a negative reaction, which can then be used to cause a rift and tension and discord between two groups of people who should really learn to live in peace and harmony with each other! :hmm:
 
Honestly, I laughed when I read the first post. It shouldnt be a big deal and I dont consider it as a mistake. So stop complaining and repeating the same points again and again. Thread should be closed now.
 
I will just say that the experiment was not sucessful. I agree with Dagless, on the first page, that when something has been done once it can be overlooked, but when something is done repeatedly then people stop overlooking it and start punishing the actions. The fact that this happened once before and the perpetrator went unpunished, but the second time the perpetrator was punished, does not demonstrate that Muslims are being treated differently. It only demonstrates that the library is not going to continue to allow individuals to victimize them. If a non-muslim went in and volunteered, and in a month from now did the same thing, I would bet money the individual would also be fired and given a bad recommendation. (And I am not a betting woman.)

Relocating the Bibles does not offend me in any way, but if I worked in the library I would be upset by the fact that is wastes my time and money to locate the Bibles and re-shelve them back in their original location. The harm comes through wasting my valuable time at work (and money) if I am employed there.

I just wanted to add that I am not saying this to be critical of Mohamed_Sadiq. I think he had good intentions, despite the fact that is really was a poor experiment.
 
Last edited:

Similar Threads

Back
Top