MAC Eyeliner.

  • Thread starter Thread starter _Y168
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 18
  • Views Views 5K
Y

_Y168

Elite Member
Messages
441
Reaction score
28
Gender
Female
Religion
Islam
Assalaamu 'Alaikum,

If an eyeliner (MAC) has Carmine (i.e. Cochineal / E120) inside it then are you allowed to use it, because technically you aren't putting it inside your mouth. Is it just like using a hand sanitizer that has alcohol inside it?

Jazaakumullaahu Khayran.
 
The thing is, I prefer MAC products over other brands, because they work best on me. I noticed on my latest eyeliner that it has Carmine inside it and I was baffled whether you can use it or not because of the Haraam ingredient.

The reasoning behind the lipstick being Haraam makes sense because of the possible contact with the mouth.

If anyone does find out a definite answer, then please do let me know. Jazak Allahu Khayran!
 
Good luck with your search sis-- I do feel like I suggested strongly my preference I understand what it is like to have a favorite product.. in shaa Allah you get the answer your seek.

:w:
 
Aaaawh! إن شاء الله. Jazakillahu Khayran! :D

Also, do you know Make Up brushes, have you heard about most of them being made by animal hair?
 
Last edited:
محبة الحرمين;1549834 said:
Aaaawh! إن شاء الله. Jazakillahu Khayran! :D

Also, do you know Make Up brushes, have you heard about most of them being made by animal hair?
Click to expand...

Well lol.. this might not please to hear about me, but I actually like fur and animal hair lols.. but there's a company that makes really nice synthetic brushes they don't shed which is my peeve with the animal ones and also are very reasonably priced and get really good ratings:

http://www.amazon.com/Ecotools-Bamb...qid=1351472969&sr=8-5&keywords=makeup+brushes

called ecotools ..

:w:
 
Oh, Lol! And we have those brushes! Eco tools are Awesome! But, we also have many other brushes, and its difficult knowing which ones that you can use and which ones that you can't.
 
the thing about brushes is that you have to clean them after every use and I don't think most people do that which causes them all sorts of skin issues. I don't tend to use brushes because I don't really wear makeup just tinted moisturizer with spf in the winter though I try a tanner because I am sadly very pale and ghastly but that can look funny if you don't do it right.. I think for most people sunblock will do if they don't have skin issues and skin issues can be avoided just by paying attention to habits, such as using brushes without disinfecting them with every use.
 
Hmm y don't u go to Islam Q n A post ur ques there ? :) someone mite help

I don't use makeup much so Duno I only use the hasmi surma or a gel liner. :s
 
Erm, do you need an account for that?

And sis شَاذِنْ, if the brushes are made out of Animal Hairs, then isn't it Najis? I personally don't use anything on my face, but was asking for eye shadow brushes?
 
Why us it najas? You know that during the time of the prophet pbuh they used animal fur and leather for bedding and carpeting and pillows the stuff you'd spend a fortune on now a days - that's what the animals are there for I am using my phone now but there's a verse in suret ya seen about our dominion over the animals. Not that we should abuse that privilege but it's certainly one of the blessings of Allah swt that we can ride them, eat them and use them for clothing, even their bones were used as writing parchment!
They need to be cleaned properly though I think back in the day they left the skin to dry out in the sun.
Now we've solutions and things with which to clean them!

And Allah swt knows best!
 
I normally use Avon products as it is a jewish company and doesn't use alcohol or pig. For a few years i used syrian make up but now that i am ut of syria i will have to get stuff made elsewhere, so avon is wht i will most likely go for.

I am unsure abour carmine. I read that insects werent haram but don't remember where i read that. if that's true, then carmine would not be haram. it's best you ask on islam QA as a scholar will let you know whether insects are haram or not.

Animal hairs and hides from halal animals are halal but what about haram animals such as fox? I m unsure if their fur is allowed.

There are a couple of hadith about animal hide that i remember. One states that every hide/skin that has been treated (in the sun, etc) is clean. كل اباغ ضبغ فقد طهر
Another states that we shouldn't take the hide of a dead animal. الا تنفعوا من الميت بإباغ
I think what these hadith mean that if animal is slaughtered, it's hide can be taken and treated which makes it pure to use. But if an animal has died by itself then it's hide shouldn't be taken for use. Since animals should only be killed for food or self defence, that would mean that in most cases we won't be able to use the skins/hide of wild animals or haram animals. And Allah knows best.

Note: i am unsure of the wording of the second hadith as I memorized it a few years ago.
 
Last edited:
I should've made it specific: I heard that 'Pig hairs...' are used in most Make Up brushes. Not sure if it is true tho.
 
Last edited:
محبة الحرمين;1549934 said:
I should've made it specific: I heard that 'Pig hairs...' are used in most Make Up brushes. Not sure if it is true tho.
Click to expand...

I think boar bristles are only used in brushes because they're very coarse I don't think they can make a face brush out of that it would be abrasive but Allah swt knows best, if you know what the brush is made of you can always switch to another brand...
 
The thing is, how would you know if the brush is made up of Pig hair, as they do not specify it in any way. Personally, I use Eco Tools, but a sister was enquiring to me about her brushes. (Bobby Brown... E.t.c.)
 
she can just call the company, that's what I do with food or any questionable products.
For instance I wrote customer service to the wisconsin cheese company wanting to know if they use pig rennet and they told me that they synthesize it using bacteria. They can't withhold information from you -- all you gotta do is ask.
 
i think make-up brushes are made of human hair. I read it in a magazine or brochure.
 
شَادِنُ;1549939 said:
They can't withhold information from you -- all you gotta do is ask.
Click to expand...
I'll let her know. :ia:. Jazaakillaahu Khayran. :)

WRITER said:
i think make-up brushes are made of human hair. I read it in a magazine or brochure.
Click to expand...
Woah! That's the first. Please share the article sis.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top