Milad-un-Nabi...

  • Thread starter Thread starter *~Sofia~*
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 73
  • Views Views 14K
Status
Not open for further replies.
In The Name of Allah, The Most Gracious, The Most Merciful​
:salamext:

many people think that only Salafi prohibit Milad-un-Nabi. actually, the mainstream Ulema are against this practice.
These are from different Ulema:
http://www.askimam.org/fatwa/fatwa.php?askid=1dc9141b6cdbe7a8f8cb855714202b88
http://www.central-mosque.com/fiqh/Fatwah-Milad.htm
http://islamtoday.com/show_detail_section.cfm?q_id=290&main_cat_id=13

another problem is that a simple innovation leads to further sins. for example in one country women sign naats or nasheeds about our Beloved Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) on TV.

wasalam
-SI-
 
Al Habeshi said:
Can you narrate please the virtues and beauties that the prophet peace be upon him ascribed to this day?



If I do believe that the song was sang on that day, which I dont think it was but Allah knows best, then plesae plesae think about it, any chance that they could be singing because the prophet arrived and not to do with his bday?




But we are supposed to send salam on the Prophet more than 5 times a day brother!

Furthermore to specifically outline a time without reason except that you think there's a virtue or something to it then that's not wrong as the prophte would have told us.




Wa Aleykum salam bro,

The verse doesn't just talk about his birth:

And peace on him on the day he was born, and on the day he dies, and on the day he is raised to life​

According to that logic, are we going to send salaams when yahyaa died, let's have a dhikr circle?

What about when he is raised up, we are going to stand on the day of Judgement when we are raised up and have a celebration?



I dont know what translation you are using, but this single verse has put me off reading the rest, reason being that I have never ever ever seen verse 33 or the verse of Yahyaa say 'SEND' subhanAllah, furthremore it doesnt say died.

:enough!: :enough!:
Click to expand...

Point 1: Read my post before his

Point 2: All these things happened on the same day, it can't be just luck. Allah (swt) made all these things happen on one blessed day. They did sing and with drums if you read Sahih al Bukhari

Point 3: We are supposed to send salaam on the Holy Prophet (saw) regurlaly and it is a great nafl. It should be done more than five times a day but we aren't capable of that so Mawlid is a good oppurtunity

Point 4: Allah (swt) is sending salaam on the day he was born, died and ressurected. As in the Quran it says peace be upon the day he was born. The Quran is Allahs speech so it means his is sending peace by saying peace be upon him the day he was born.

If you look into it at depth then you will understand Insh'allah.

I hope I have relieved your doubts. If you don't want to celebrate it then don't, as it is not neccessary but to say it is wrong is a lack of knowledge.
 
I haven't read all the replies but we should look at the prophet (saw) and the tabi3een and see what they did- Is there any proof to say that they celebrated the prophet's (saw) birthday?

We should "refrain from that which is harmless from fear of falling into that which is harmful", for bid3ah is a great evil

:w:
 
siFilam said:
In The Name of Allah, The Most Gracious, The Most Merciful​
:salamext:

many people think that only Salafi prohibit Milad-un-Nabi. actually, the mainstream Ulema are against this practice.
These are from different Ulema:
http://www.askimam.org/fatwa/fatwa.php?askid=1dc9141b6cdbe7a8f8cb855714202b88
http://www.central-mosque.com/fiqh/Fatwah-Milad.htm
http://islamtoday.com/show_detail_section.cfm?q_id=290&main_cat_id=13

another problem is that a simple innovation leads to further sins. for example in one country women sign naats or nasheeds about our Beloved Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) on TV.

wasalam
-SI-
Click to expand...

Either Salafis or deobandis prevent it as you can see from the Urls.

The Grand Muft of Saudi Arabia is of course a salafi and the first url looks deobandi to me.

I totally agree with the point the sunni alaam says in the second url.
 
I cant remember the exact hadith but its something like this: =#
"Whoever invents a lie against Muhammad (saw) let him take his place in the fire"
 
Rose_Ice said:
I cant remember the exact hadith but its something like this: =#
"Whoever invents a lie against Muhammad (saw) let him take his place in the fire"
Click to expand...

I know that hadith but if you look at the full hadith and in its proper context you will understand.

I have explained that hadith in that article.
 
Articles supporting Mawlid

* The Religious and Legal status of the Birthday of the Holy Prophet (saw) In light of the Qur’an and Sunnah By Ghazalah Hassan Qadri ([http://www.minhajsisters.com/home/articles/index.minhaj?dir=&id=56 Part One]) ([http://www.minhajsisters.com/home/articles/index.minhaj?dir=&id=55 Part Two]) ([http://www.minhajsisters.com/home/articles/index.minhaj?dir=&id=54 Part Three])
*[http://www.islamonline.net/servlet/...h-Ask_Scholar/FatwaE/FatwaE&cid=1119503543944 Al-Azhar Fatwa on validity of Mawlid]
*[http://islamicsupremecouncil.org/bin/site/wrappers/spirituality-mohammads_bday.html Mawlid an-Nabi: The Celebration of Prophet Muhammad's (s) Birthday By Professor [[Sulayman Nyang]], Ph.D. ]
*[http://www.abc.se/~m9783/n/tufm_e.html Rebuttal to Mufti Taqi Usmani's Fatwa by Shaikh GF Haddad]
*[http://web.mac.com/jawziyyah/iWeb/The Jawziyyah Institute/With The Shaykh_files/Mawlid.pdf Shaikh Abdullah bin Bayyah's Fatwa on the Mawlid]
*[http://www.livingislam.org/n/mwld-qrd_e.html Shaikh Yusuf Al-Qaradawi's Fatwa]
*[http://www.**************/resources/Questions/QA00000507.aspx Should we celebrate Mawlid? by Dr. `Isa al-Mani` al-Humairi]
*[http://www.mawlid.ca/Topics_questions_on_mawlid.htm Ten Proofs from Qur'an and Sunnah that Celebrating Mawlid is accepted in Shariah ]
*[http://www.************/seasonsjournal/seasons6/2-4Final_Mawlid.pdf The Blessed Mawlid by [[Imam Zaid Shakir]]]
*[http://www.wimnet.org/articles/eid-e-milaad.htm The Celebration of Eid-e-Milaad-un-Nabi by PROF. SHAH FARIDUL HAQUE]
*[http://www.daruliftaa.com/question.asp?txt_QuestionID=q-20524212 Why do Some Sunni Ulema - like the Deobandis - Prohibit the Mawlid? by Shaikh Muhammad ibn Adam al-Kawthari]
 
We should "refrain from that which is harmless from fear of falling into that which is harmful", for bid3ah is a great evil
Click to expand...

:salamext:

Allaahu Aalim, this thread is falling into sectarian discussions. I vote it should be closed.
 
Mushahida said:
Point 1: Read my post before his
Click to expand...

Your post doesnt have the prophet peace be upon him mentioning virtues, not like, fasting on this night will be the same as such and such, or this day is as good as 4 months or anything.

Mushahida said:
The holy Prophet (saw) was born on 12th rabi-ul-awwal and on a monday.

It is reported in Sahih Bukhari that the Holy prophet (saw) arrived in Madinah at 12th Rabi-ul-Awwal and on a monday.
And the people in Madinah sang on this day.

The Holy prophet (saw) had the first revelation sent down to him on a monday.

The Holy Prophet (saw) died on a monday and 12th rabi-ul-awwal and this is a mercy for the Holy Prophet(saw) as he became close to his Lord.

So 12th Rabi-ul-awwal and the day Monday has a huge signifiance so there are many reasons to celebrate this day.
Click to expand...

He according to you was born on Monday 12, according to Bukhari I have not seen the hadith, he got to Madinah on monday 12, and he died, though I dont know if thats a good thing. So two things which one according to you happend on the monday 12, the other I have yet to see bukhari mention it.

Yet out of all this the Prophet never clearly told us to have special meetings on Monday the 12?

Mushahida said:
Point 2: All these things happened on the same day, it can't be just luck. Allah (swt) made all these things happen on one blessed day. They did sing and with drums if you read Sahih al Bukhari
Click to expand...

About two things happend, not hundreds. And I cant find it, please aid me in the search.

Mushahida said:
Point 3: We are supposed to send salaam on the Holy Prophet (saw) regurlaly and it is a great nafl. It should be done more than five times a day but we aren't capable of that so Mawlid is a good oppurtunity
Click to expand...

The prophet said establish prayers, in the prayer we send salams on him, the prophet also made dhikr and taught advise people to pray nafl, but instead of that, we rather do something the prophet never advised us, and if it is claimed he did, then even if he did he stressed more the prayer, so we say 'We are not capable let us just set a side a day and instead of struggling to pray extra prayers which the prophet did and reccomended we rather should sit and single out a day which the prophet didnt do or reccomend'

Mushahida said:
Point 4: Allah (swt) is sending salaam on the day he was born, died and ressurected. As in the Quran it says peace be upon the day he was born. The Quran is Allahs speech so it means his is sending peace by saying peace be upon him the day he was born.
Click to expand...

What translation were you using bro? Cos that had a command, it said 'Send' anyhow thers a difference between Allah sending salams and Allah telling us, i dont think any of us can send salam upon anyone on judgement day.

Mushahida said:
If you look into it at depth then you will understand Insh'allah.

I hope I have relieved your doubts. If you don't want to celebrate it then don't, as it is not neccessary but to say it is wrong is a lack of knowledge.
Click to expand...

Please be patient with me. :)
 
Al Habeshi said:
Your post doesnt have the prophet peace be upon him mentioning virtues, not like, fasting on this night will be the same as such and such, or this day is as good as 4 months or anything.



He according to you was born on Monday 12, according to Bukhari I have not seen the hadith, he got to Madinah on monday 12, and he died, though I dont know if thats a good thing. So two things which one according to you happend on the monday 12, the other I have yet to see bukhari mention it.

Yet out of all this the Prophet never clearly told us to have special meetings on Monday the 12?



About two things happend, not hundreds. And I cant find it, please aid me in the search.



The prophet said establish prayers, in the prayer we send salams on him, the prophet also made dhikr and taught advise people to pray nafl, but instead of that, we rather do something the prophet never advised us, and if it is claimed he did, then even if he did he stressed more the prayer, so we say 'We are not capable let us just set a side a day and instead of struggling to pray extra prayers which the prophet did and reccomended we rather should sit and single out a day which the prophet didnt do or reccomend'



What translation were you using bro? Cos that had a command, it said 'Send' anyhow thers a difference between Allah sending salams and Allah telling us, i dont think any of us can send salam upon anyone on judgement day.



Please be patient with me. :)
Click to expand...

Three great, enormous things happened on this day.

Point I was trying to make: Allah does not command send but is sending so if Allah (swt) is sending then why don't you.

I can't find the hadith at the moment for the sake of an internet forum but I have read it in Sahih al Bukhari and Inah'allah if you read the whole of Bukhari shareef one day then you will see it.

I have given answers to all these things in the long posts before anyway.

I am posting this for your ease.
 
:salamext:


Akhi i dont think theres any authentic narration which states that the Prophet sal Allaahu alayhi waSalam was born on 12th of Rabbi ul Awwal, however there is an authentic hadith which states that he fasted on a Monday.

The reason why its accepted that he was born on 12th is the view of Ibn Isshaaq, and he states it in his famous Seerah. And the reason why many muslims accept that view is because of his authority, yet he hasn't mentioned no narration or sanad [chain of narration] to support that. And Allaah knows best.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Back
Top