Moonlight in the Quran

[- Qatada -]

It would be interesting if muslims started treating the Bible the same.:rollseyes
Anyway, I copied the verses from a site with anti-islamic tendencies, so it's rather obvious that they would pick verses that fit their desires.:-\

True. :thumbs_up



Peace.

 

[Whatsthepoint]

If he didn't agree, then that's upto him. He is a human and he is fallible.
Regards.

Its a matter of language. How can he not agree? Is it that incomprehnsible? And how could he have made a mistake with a verse of such importance?

 

[Whatsthepoint]

True. :thumbs_up

That doesn't mean they got the general idea wrong though.

 

[chacha_jalebi]

without disrespect to qari mullah he has got quite a lot of stuff wrong, i.e he has beliefs like the sufis doo

and whats points, its just a simple twisting of words, the thing is the arabic language has a much wider vocabulary then english, it cant handle the translations

 

[- Qatada -]

Its a matter of language. How can he not agree? Is it that incomprehnsible? And how could he have made a mistake with a verse of such importance?

Maybe he wasn't a scientist? He died at 1605 CE. It doesn't mean he has to have all the knowledge of astronomy etc.

That doesn't mean they got the general idea wrong though.

You yourself quoted the Qur'an mentioning that the moon reflects light in one verse, in another that it gives light. There is no confusion. We concluded that we use both verses to conclude that yes it does give light, but it does so through reflecting it off the sun.



I think there shouldn't be anymore confusion after that.




Regards.

 

[chacha_jalebi]

seeing as everything has been answered and refuted there isnt much more to debate

so:threadclo