Muhammad the Last Prophet: Animated Film

Al-Mu'minah said:
I guess you learn new things everyday- Islam is a learnining process Alhamdulilaah. I wonder though, what eveidence do people use, for the spider web covering the cave. I have never come across it in the Sunnah ever!
Click to expand...
i've heard this too-that a spider web covered the opeing of the cave and a dove's nest was present so the kuffar thought it was undisturbed. But i read that this hadith is weak..
 
Marya1 said:
i've heard this too-that a spider web covered the opeing of the cave and a dove's nest was present so the kuffar thought it was undisturbed. But i read that this hadith is weak..
Click to expand...

on the other hand, imam anwar-al-awlaki stated a sound narration about the spider webs. In accordance with the fact that Allah can use everything and anything as his soldier....

:salamext:
 
hmm-really? i read it was weak (spider web and dove hadith) in history of islam (darussalam publications)
sometimes a hadith may be weak because of its chain of narration while its contents may be OK. especially if confirmed by a sahih hadith...
 
Marya1 said:
hmm-really? i read it was weak (spider web and dove hadith) in history of islam (darussalam publications)
sometimes a hadith may be weak because of its chain of narration while its contents may be OK. especially if confirmed by a sahih hadith...
Click to expand...

Allahu Allam, you read it weak, i "heard" it to be strong from imam anwar-al-awlaki, i think your source is better seeing as its on paper lol ! no seriously, till i can confirm it best ignored. Even tho imam anwar-al-awlaki is an extremely trustworthy imam :)

:salamext:
 
lol... i was about to watch this then my mum came in and started sayin how she thinks its soooo inappropriate that they've done this to our beloved Rasullulah, Habibullah saws !

and you guys made it sound so educational aswell :(
i guess i wont be watchin it... i'll let my nieces tho seein as they watch everythin else lol

:salamext:
 
Abd'Majid said:
lol... i was about to watch this then my mum came in and started sayin how she thinks its soooo inappropriate that they've done this to our beloved Rasullulah, Habibullah saws !
Click to expand...
No disrespect to your mother, but has she seen the film? I mean, I haven't, so I can't really judge either way...
 
Muezzin said:
No disrespect to your mother, but has she seen the film? I mean, I haven't, so I can't really judge either way...
Click to expand...

naa, she goes its impossible to portray the beauty, its impossible to make the movie wivout putting in at least some form of presence of the sahabi's who we love and respect too much to dishonor by the idea which todays man may come up with of such people (implying that society has become so corrupt that they cant even imagine just how beautiful and blessed the sahabi's where).
and due to the stressing of picture making being so wrong it jus gets her more vexxed...

her points are clear... make sence... may Allah bless her :)

:salamext:
 
Abd'Majid said:
naa, she goes its impossible to portray the beauty, its impossible to make the movie wivout putting in at least some form of presence of the sahabi's who we love and respect too much to dishonor by the idea which todays man may come up with of such people (implying that society has become so corrupt that they cant even imagine just how beautiful and blessed the sahabi's where).
and due to the stressing of picture making being so wrong it jus gets her more vexxed...
Click to expand...
Ahh. I see. Those are good points.

her points are clear... make sence... may Allah bless her :)

:salamext:
Click to expand...
Ameen. May Allah bless all our parents.
 
Abd'Majid said:
lol... i was about to watch this then my mum came in and started sayin how she thinks its soooo inappropriate that they've done this to our beloved Rasullulah, Habibullah saws !

and you guys made it sound so educational aswell :(
i guess i wont be watchin it... i'll let my nieces tho seein as they watch everythin else lol

:salamext:
Click to expand...

:sl:

Actully bro I disagree, firstly the shahba arn't even shown and secondly I havn't come across any evidence saying that it's not permissable to show a representive on screen of the sahaba we must remember even though we love and respect them they're men just like us.
 
islam-truth said:
:sl:

Actully bro I disagree, firstly the shahba arn't even shown and secondly I havn't come across any evidence saying that it's not permissable to show a representive on screen of the sahaba we must remember even though we love and respect them they're men just like us.
Click to expand...

im not saying its haram bro, i have no right or Ilm to say such a thing. Im just saying out of my own understanding (which could be the wrong type waAllahu Allam) i think its best avoided, i like the imagination i have of those beautiful people in my mind :)

:wasalamex


Sincere apologies to all i may have offended, i feel kinda bad for stating all this now..
 
Abd'Majid said:
im not saying its haram bro, i have no right or Ilm to say such a thing. Im just saying out of my own understanding (which could be the wrong type waAllahu Allam) i think its best avoided, i like the imagination i have of those beautiful people in my mind :)

:wasalamex


Sincere apologies to all i may have offended, i feel kinda bad for stating all this now..
Click to expand...

:sl:

I understand sorry for the misunderstanding.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top