'Muslim duty' - poll for Muslims only, please

  • Thread starter Thread starter glo
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 44
  • Views Views 8K

Do you agree with Muhammad Abdul Bari's statements on the Islamic duty?

  • Total voters
    0
  • Poll closed .
wilber said:
Well, isn't the US doing "them a favour in the next life by sending them to heaven"?
Click to expand...
Actually it's true...although I'm not 100% sure if a Muslim civilian casuality automatically goes to heaven. However, this is only one point of view...of many, and I never meant to imply that this was the only way of looking at things. It's not a sick remark by any standard I know of, unless you understood it as a lack of sympathy for the victims and their families, in which case... you misunderstood.
 
Skywalker said:
Actually it's true...although I'm not 100% sure if a Muslim civilian casuality automatically goes to heaven. However, this is only one point of view...of many, and I never meant to imply that this was the only way of looking at things. It's not a sick remark by any standard I know of, unless you understood it as a lack of sympathy for the victims and their families, in which case... you misunderstood.
Click to expand...
I think it is sick that you are not distrubed by my sick statement.:grumbling
 
:sl:

Of course I voted with a BIG yes. I feel that any loss of innocent life in unacceptable. I feel that way if the U.S. takes an innocent life, Hamas, or by a drug dealer down the street. I despise war. But I understand that the way of the world is for military action in order to keep oneself save, by a threat or "perceived threat". But when military conflict takes the lives of the general population, it breaks my heart. Israeli, Palestinian, Iraqi, ect., it's just terrible period.
 
that would be a yes with a CAPITAL Y...

i agree...i think every muslim would agree...but to what extent we actually take part in the activation of this 'muslim duty'...im not sure...i think us muslims of today like to sit back and discuss how bad the other is and how against islam what theyre doing is...

i guess we jst dont know how to go about it...i mean...u have to define the practicality of "condemn"...how does he expect us to "condemn"?

in what way does islam want us to condemn...do we rally? do we chant? do we become agressive?do we become passive???

i think everyone sets their own standards....islam is and simultaneously isnt very clear on this...wat i mean is, interpretations are diverse.and we inevitably become confused...

here i am rambling again.

deeply apologetic.

that is all.

ws.
 
wilberhum said:
Skywalker
Well, isn't the US doing "them a favour in the next life by sending them to heaven"? :?
What a sick remark. Reminds me of the intellegance of the Inquisition. :(
Click to expand...

and sending themselves to hell i guess..

lol. very sick remark. i recommend that u not think in these terms.killing can never be favour...when its done by humans or any other beings than God.

cool observation though...its prone to debate...
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top