If you ask any scholar who does not have Arab bias in him he/she will tell you what Palestinian government is doing is Treason in Islam. Agian, Akhi using big words does not make you right Communications 101. You do not state facts and either do you make any sense. All you do is fancy up your sentences so when others read it they assume you are right because of the vocabulary you use.
Ok, so if a Hamas delegation meets with representatives from Russia, that according to you is treason because of Russia's record in Chechnya? is this the crux of what you're saying? Id have to disagree with that because, again, you cannot tar every single conflict that the Muslim ummah has been embroiled in with a single brush. Do you not realise brother that what you're exhorting here will only lead to more isolationism?
Why do you not then propose a viable alternative since you're so swift to denigrate any idea of emancipation through co-operation?. Are you one of these people thats just going to bellow "Jihad" without making any reasonable assessment of the prevailing political climate? Enlighten us.
You're the one who's coming up with fancy but unsubstantiated claims about how Islamic scholarship has deemed anything to do with alliances made with non-Muslim nations as treason. Tell me brother, is it not true that the sahabah were dispatched by the prophet (pbuh) to Abysinnia, (present day Ethiopia) to seek sanctuary under a righteous Christian king when they were being persecuted in Makkah? I suppose your counter-arguement will now be that Abysinnia, unlike Russia did not massacre Muslims on the colossal scale such as that of Chechnya.
I can't see how you can accuse us all of having an Arab bias, when first of all, this thread is about the Israel/Palestine conflict, and the facts surrounding the conflict are like no other in the history of the Ummah. This is the land where Al Quds - the third holiest site in Islam - is located, it has been usurped by a zionist regime that has foisted itself with firm western backing on the Palestinians, consigned them to a life of abject poverty, privation and despair, and has thoroughly destroyed and hopes of a unified Muslim response by making peace treaties with the actual traitors; the likes of Anwar Sadat and King Hussein.
As for your question about the Kashmiris colluding with Israel, ofcourse i would object to that, but you cannot in all seriousness tell me that it is a reasonable analogy to compare Kashmiri/israeli collusion with a politically unbinding and tenuous alliance between the Palestinians and Russia. It just does not make any sense.
