Muslim Woman
Super Moderator
- Messages
- 12,286
- Reaction score
- 1,449
- Gender
- Female
- Religion
- Islam
Salaam/peace ,
Iraq: Bush Failed, You Try
http://www.islamonline.net/livedialogue/english/Browse.asp?hGuestID=cRgSRA
Name Ameri -
Question As an expert in managing crises of this kind, what do you think is the best solution to this crisis? Do you agree that this US-led war has not ever been justifiable.
Answer First of all, I personally was against the war (despite my many Iraqi friends who wanted to be rid of that very brutal regime), because I don't think you can solve crises in the Middle East by sending in American troops.
The record of the last four years shows how true this was. To find a solution at this late stage will be very difficult, perhaps impossible. But we owe it, not to the US, but to the people of Iraq who have suffered for too long, and indeed for the safety of the people in the region, to find a solution.
My organisation is calling for a multilateral effort including members of the Security Council and Iraq's six neihgbouring states to convene a conference of all principal Iraqi actors regardless of their outlook and bring them to compromise on the key issues that divide them: the nature of federalism, how to share oil revenues, de-Baathification, etc.
If this is done, there could still be hope (although it will be extremely difficult even then to stabilise Iraq).
And we must have hope. (Sorry: just lost electricity for a couple of minutes; I'm writing this in Kirkuk.)
Name Naf -
Question Not to sound pessimistic, but it seems there is very little the ordinary person can do, we have marched, protested and lobbied but still those in power have chosen not to head our warnings or advice.
We can keep trying, but at the end of the day the decision has to be made from the top (until the next election that is) – is their another strategy we can take?
Answer Very good question, and I can understand your frustration. Coming at it from a different corner, we have provided analyses and recommendations concerning Iraq from day 1, and all for nothing....
But the American electorate has started to punish Bush for his failures in Iraq, and perhaps the same thing will happen in the UK. Meanwhile, I wouldn't give up the protests and demonstrations, because we could be close to reaching "critical mass".
The real problem is that it is already too late for the many Iraqis who have died (for example, four carbombs here in Kirkuk today), and whatever solution may be constructed, it is going to take time.....
Name A.Rashdan
Our reports on Iraq and other countries of the Middle East and North Africa are available in English and Arabic from http://www.crisisgroup.org.
Joost Hiltermann
Deputy Program Director, MENA
International Crisis Group
Last edited: