Potential want me to stay at home all the time

AnonymousPoster

Anonymous
Messages
5,732
Reaction score
218
I got a propose from a man who is from different society than me ,that mean different customs and traditions ,different way of life ,I am not sure if I can fit with that or not.
He thinks that the wife must stay at home all the time ,can`t go even to attend Islamic course in the masjid,that`s not the way of life I used to have,my parents allow me to work,attend lessons ,visit my friends..........etc.
He isn`t an outdoor person ,so I can`t even go outdoors with him,he is from another city which make me unable to visit my family time to time.
I think if I got married to him I`ll stay at home all over my life:skeleton:
Do any of you have similar experience to advice me weather I`ll be able to live in this way or not:heated:.
I need to get married ,The last few years I was thinking a lot about marriage:embarrass ,I don`t want to reject a potential as I feel I really need to get married soon,but at the same time I don`t want to marry the wrong man then suffer and regret all over my life or may be get divorce,any advice?.
 
:sl:
one thing that is important to look at when considering a souse is your compatibility with one another. dont assume that since they are religious that you will get along without a worry this isnt the case at all. take into consideration how both of you were raised and how this will affect your marriage later on (by the sounds of things it looks like you are having doubts already), becuase these things WILL come up later on. you say he expects you to stay at home all the time? ask yourself can you handle that. what are the pros and cons.

in other words go into your marriage with a realistic and informed overview of the situation, making sure that you also consider what YOU will get by marrying him. we know unfortunatly in a lot of cultures, the wife comes second best and it is her that has to put up with the husbands bad qualities, whilst he is oblivious, lacks consideration and ignores her needs as well. so basically, you have to put up and shut up. so as i said, consider where it'll leave you.

dont ever kid yourself that all those bad qualities you can put up with...it is essential to deal with this stuff now...do NOT be hasty (especially in regards to marriage), take your time and do proper research and pray istikhara :)

i dont know, really and honestly it sounds like a disaster :hmm:
 
Last edited:
I got a propose from a man who is from different society than me ,that mean different customs and traditions ,different way of life ,I am not sure if I can fit with that or not.
He thinks that the wife must stay at home all the time ,can`t go even to attend Islamic course in the masjid,that`s not the way of life I used to have,my parents allow me to work,attend lessons ,visit my friends..........etc.
He isn`t an outdoor person ,so I can`t even go outdoors with him,he is from another city which make me unable to visit my family time to time.
I think if I got married to him I`ll stay at home all over my life:skeleton:
Do any of you have similar experience to advice me weather I`ll be able to live in this way or not:heated:.
I need to get married ,The last few years I was thinking a lot about marriage:embarrass ,I don`t want to reject a potential as I feel I really need to get married soon,but at the same time I don`t want to marry the wrong man then suffer and regret all over my life or may be get divorce,any advice?.


Asalaamu Alaikum Wr Wb, is he practising, pious and have a good character? Those are the qualities that matter most. I would sincerely advise you to do isthikhara until you recieve a sign. Have hope in Allah and whatever is best will happen inshallah.

Shaykh Saleh Al-Munajjid answered in response to a Muslim sister seeking advice about a husband:

We appreciate your eagerness to find out the attributes which will help you to choose a righteous husband, in shaa Allaah. There follows a description of the most important qualities which should be present in the man whom you choose or accept to be your husband and the father of your children, if Allaah decrees that you will have children.

Religious Commitment

This is the most important thing to look for in the man you want to marry. The husband should be a Muslim who adheres to all the laws and teachings of Islam in his daily life. The woman's guardian (wali) should strive to check out this matter and not rely only on outward appearances. One of the most important things to ask about is the man's prayer (salaah); the one who neglects the rights of Allaah is more likely to neglect the rights of others. The true believer does not oppress or mistreat his wife; if he loves her, he honours her, and if he does not love her, he does not mistreat or humiliate her. It is very rare to find this attitude among those who are not sincere Muslims. Allaah says:

'And verily, a believing slave is better than a (free) Mushrik (idolater), even though he pleases you' [al-Baqarah 2:221]

'Verily, the most honourable of you with Allaah is that (believer) who has At-Taqwaa [i.e. he is one of the Muttaqoon (the pious)]' [al-Hujuraat 49:13] 'Good statements are for good people (or good women for good men) and good people for good statements (or good men for good women)' [al-Noor 24:26]

The Prophet (sallallaaahu 'alaihi wa sallam) said:

'If there comes to you one whose religious commitment and attitude pleases you, then marry [your female relative who is under your care] to him, for if you do not do that, there will be tribulation on earth and much corruption.� (Narrated by al-Tirmidhi).

As well as being religiously committed, it is preferable that he should come from a good family and a known lineage. If two men come to propose marriage to one woman, and they are equal in terms of religious commitment, then preference should be given to the one who comes from a good family that is known for its adherence to the commands of Allaah, so long as the other person is not better than him in terms of religious commitment ' because the righteousness of the husband's close relatives could be passed on to his children and his good origins and lineage may make him refrain from many foolish and cheap actions. The righteousness of the father and grandfather are beneficial to the children and grandchildren. Allaah says:

"And as for the wall, it belonged to two orphan boys in the town; and there was under it a treasure belonging to them; and their father was a righteous man, and your Lord intended that they should attain their age of full strength and take out their treasure as a mercy from your Lord" [al-Kahf 18:82].

See how Allaah protected their father's wealth for the two boys after the father died, as an honour to him because of his righteousness and taqwaa. By the same token, if the husband comes from a righteous family and his parents are good, Allaah will make things easy for him and protect him as an honour to his parents.

It is good if he has sufficient wealth to keep him and his family from having to ask people for anything, because the Prophet (salawaatullaahi wa salaamuhu 'alaih) said to Faatimah bint Qays (may Allaah be pleased with her), when she came to consult him about three men who had proposed marriage to her, 'As for Mu'aawiyah, he is a poor man who has no wealth" (Narrated by Muslim, 1480).

It is not essential that he should be a businessman or rich, it is sufficient for him to have an income that will keep him and his family from having to ask people for anything. If there is a choice between a man who is religiously committed and a man who is wealthy, then the religious man should be given preference over the wealthy man.

It is preferable that he should be kind and gentle towards women, because the Prophet (sallallaahu 'alaihi wa sallam) said to Faatimah bint Qays, in the hadeeth quoted above, "As for Abu Jaham, his stick never leaves his shoulder", referring to the fact that he used to beat women a lot.

It is good if he is sound of body and healthy, free of faults, sickness, etc., and not disabled or sterile.

It is preferable that he should have knowledge of the Qur'aan and Sunnah ; if you find someone like this it is good, otherwise you should realize that this is something rare.

It is permissible for the woman to look at the man who comes to propose marriage, and for him to look at her. This should be in the presence of her mahram, and it is not permitted to look more than is necessary, or for him to see her alone, or for her to go out with him on her own, or to meet repeatedly for no reason.

According to Islam, the woman's wali (guardian) should check on the man who proposes marriage to the woman who is under his guardianship; he should ask those whom he trusts among those who mix with him and who know him, about his commitment to Islam and his trustworthiness. He should ask them for an honest opinion and sincere, sound advice.

Before and during all of this, you must turn towards Allaah and pray to Him to make it easy for you and help you to make a good choice and to grant you wisdom. Then after all these efforts, when you have decided on a particular person, you should pray Istikhaarah, asking Allaah for that which is good. Then after you have done your utmost, put your trust in Allaah, for He is the best of helpers, may He be glorified.

IslamQA
 
:sl: thats a really backward mentality... who knows what other beliefs he has.
I would seriously recommend you do istikharah. don't ruin your life by marrying into some type oppressed relationship where u can't even go to your local mosque thats very bad. shaytan would love that
 
:sl:

I don`t want to reject a potential as I feel I really need to get married

Don't see as rejecting a potential spouse, see it as rejecting a way of life you can't see yourself living.

I'm a true homebird. It takes a lot to drag me out. But despite that I'd stay away from someone who...

can`t go even to attend Islamic course in the masjid

^Has that kind of view..

Staying at home because Allah preferred women stay at home is one thing. Staying at home like a prisoner is totally another.


A wife of an imaan who lived a few doors away from my friend had a nervous breakdown because she was expected to live the kind of life your potential wants to you. It's not natural. Don't do it.

:wa:
 
if u feel uncomfortable with that now, i think you'l struggle alot once ur marriage.
its easier when you go from alot of boundaries to limited boundaries but to have the opposite can affect it a great deal.
Personal experience - before i got married my parents would allow me to go with friends and never called me to say ive been out too long etc, and was very independant.. when i was engaged my fiance said everythin was cool, would never stop me from anything.. when he became my husband, he started to check everything, call me when i was longer than a certain time period.. and a time limit to stay out.. not even choose me own car!
sorry i seem to have waffled about my own issues.. but what im tryin to say is i found it difficult to cope with.. now u really need to ask urself.. ur lucky u no what he's like beforehand and can decide before..
maybe ur potential has reasons for being like this.. decision is urs..but think abt it as it can cause major probs
 
Is he pakistani and is he knowledgable enough about islam?
 
dont jus go for it cos uve been thinkin abt marriage for a long time.. take the time u need to decide...
inshAllah the right decision will be made
x
 
:sl:

Don't set yourself up for disaster. If you feel you're not compatible with a person, move on. You don't want to marry someone because you really just want to get married and then realize 6 months later that you can't deal with them or their conditions. Believe me, you need to be compatible with the other person or the marriage will go no where because there's a lot more to marriage than just the first night or the first few months, you're entering into a relationship that you want to keep going all your life and as such, the person you choose to enter that relationship into with needs to be someone you can stand 5 or 10 years down the line. You also need to be practical when choosing a spouse and part of that is to make sure that you are ok and comfortable with the desires and conditions of the other side. If you feel like you can't compromise, move on - there are others out there, perhaps even better that person x or y. You don't have to settle with the first potential you meet. Just realize that you don't have to give up the rights given to you from Allaah, they are yours to keep.
 
people change after marriage and learn to compromise :)

Or they're stubborn, they don't change, and their life together is a living hell.

Do you think you would be happy staying home all the time? I know I wouldn't. Intercultural marriages are very hard anyways, and if you have something huge like this from the outset, then it will be even harder. If he wants a wife who will stay home and not even go to the masjid, then he needs to look for someone who has that same aspiration.
 
:sl:
Don't see as rejecting a potential spouse, see it as rejecting a way of life you can't see yourself living.
I really hope not to live this way of life,but at the same time it`s hard to say no to a potential spouse,no one knows if there will be another one someday or not,I can`t cope living without husband all my life .
 
I really hope not to live this way of life,but at the same time it`s hard to say no to a potential spouse,no one knows if there will be another one someday or not,I can`t cope living without husband all my life .

but what kinda life your going to live if he dosent even allow you out to study the deen of Allah??
Do you mind if i ask you sister, what age are you?:)
 
I really hope not to live this way of life,but at the same time it`s hard to say no to a potential spouse,no one knows if there will be another one someday or not,I can`t cope living without husband all my life .
well you can decide now. But Islamically, yes he is right. A muslimah must not go outside unless it is a matter of some significant importance. Some stricter interpretations even require a Wali for a woman to go out. So decide for yourself what do you want. A strictly righteous husband or someone who fits in with your desires.
 
well you can decide now. But Islamically, yes he is right. A muslimah must not go outside unless it is a matter of some significant importance. Some stricter interpretations even require a Wali for a woman to go out. So decide for yourself what do you want. A strictly righteous husband or someone who fits in with your desires.

you are right brother but hes forbidding her to go to the masjid. this plays no part in islam to not allow your wife to go to islamic studies and meet up with friends and family ete:hmm: islam is easy. it dose not say to trap your wife in the home all her life. how can u gain imaan sitting in the home?
 
you are right brother but hes forbidding her to go to the masjid. this plays no part in islam to not allow your wife to go to islamic studies and meet up with friends and family ete:hmm: islam is easy. it dose not say to trap your wife in the home all her life. how can u gain imaan sitting in the home?

ooh. It depends on this specific case. If hes forbidding going to the masjid because there are a lot of rapists around then the sister must obey him. Allah hu Aalim. It depends on the situation and we need to listen to his reasons why he is forbidding her to go to her friend's house or even masjid.

If I am not wrong, the Prophet pbuh encouraged women to pray at home and men in mosque? Correct me if I am wrong, cant get the source right now .
 
well you can decide now. But Islamically, yes he is right. A muslimah must not go outside unless it is a matter of some significant importance. Some stricter interpretations even require a Wali for a woman to go out. So decide for yourself what do you want. A strictly righteous husband or someone who fits in with your desires.

:sl:

With all due respect, I think you should think over your words before you advice someone with something that can potentially mess up their lives - there's a difference between reading a text or a fatwa and applying it on every person regardless of individual circumstances. The most strictest opinion/fatwa is not necessarily the best (or right) one.
 
:sl:
I really hope not to live this way of life,but at the same time it`s hard to say no to a potential spouse,no one knows if there will be another one someday or not,I can`t cope living without husband all my life .

exactly. so how do you know another isnt going to come either. be optimistic sis.
do potentials come often maybe this is why you are scared?
 
Um hello, you have doubts at the PROPOSAL what the sugarplum do you think your life will be like after you marry the guy?
If he doesnt fit you, than say NO. Allah swt will send another suitor your way, or not, only HE knows. Just because you may say yes to this guy does not mean you will even make it to the wedding day. NOTHING in this life is for certain except death.

Stop being a scaredy cat and say no, he was honest with you about what he expects, you dont like it, walk away!


P.S. This is meant to be a blunt response with no fluff however i am not trying to insult you or hurt your feelings, just giving it to you straight sista.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top