Proof: Heaven and Hell in the words of a dead man

  • Thread starter Thread starter Hamayun
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 21
  • Views Views 4K
:sl:

{Shall I inform you upon whom the devils descend? They descend upon every sinful liar.}[ash-Shuaraa; 221-222]

I have a number of problems with this video:

  1. He says 'his soul came out like a glove comes off from a hand'. We know that this isn't the case with non-believer's according to our texts.
  2. There is no evidence he actually died. When one dies, they don't come back. There may be 'near-death' experiences, but they can't really hold any weight, especially when the one experiencing it is a clear cut mushrik.
  3. The above is in and of itself is enough of a reason to reject the authenticity of anything he says in regards to creed.
  4. Authentic texts. What the soul goes through after death has been explained to us by the Truthful Messenger (saw). Why then do we need these 'experiences' of someone who's initial lie is that Allaah has a son?! Far removed He is from such slander. When an individual is already lying against his Lord, how than can we assume he's going to be truthful in other aspects of belief??
  5. Allah says about the Messenger (saw): {And Muhammad is not a withholder of [knowledge of] the unseen.}[at-Takwir; 24]. Meaning that the Messenger (saw) is not stingy in informing us about the Unseen, for us to seek out sources from other than him (saw). His Sunnah is sufficient for us if we are interested in these and other matters, because it is coming out of the blessed mouth of the Truthful one (saw). There is nothing that will benefit us, except that he has informed us of it, and likewise there is nothing that is harmful for us, except that he has warned us from it.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top