Should Isreal Exist?

  • Thread starter Thread starter R_Mujahed
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 71
  • Views Views 10K

Does Israel have the Right to Exist?

  • Total voters
    0
R_Mujahed

R_Mujahed

Esteemed Member
Messages
168
Reaction score
29
Gender
Male
Religion
Islam
Aslamualikum Warahmatu ALLAH Wabarakatoh
BismALLAH Arhman Arheem
Dear Respected Brothers, Sisters, Men, and Women

Do you believe a Jewish State has the right to exist?... This thread has been made so that different thoughts and opinions can be shared, but not discussed, because it starts getting nasty... Taking into account how Israel came to existence, post a reply on why or why not Israel should exist! This is merely to see both sides of the issue, nothing more!

There are 3 rules that I kindly ask you to follow:

1- No articles, No news reports
2- One post per account
3- Do Not quote others, and Do Not reply to their posts

There are two rules you must follow:

1- Post your opinion on the question and that is it!
2- Post your reply first and then go and read the other posts!

May we all be Enlightened
Baraka ALLAH Feeman Itba Alhuda
Waslamualikum Warahmatu ALLAH Wabarakatoh
 
Last edited:
Assalamualaikum,

Well, if u asked me in 1950s... definitely my answered will be NO.

But, things are very much complicated now. Even I myself are not so sure about the answer anymore...:? Some of us will argue that the entity of Israel is illegal! Yes, from a historical point of view. If that the case, than the answer will be YES. But, one thing I do know for sure, the Zionists regime of Israel must definitely go...!
 
:sl:
I think Israel should not exist because:
1. It is occupying the palestinian land illegally.
2. It is the cause for the deaths of many innocent palestinians.

Short and sweet.:)
 
I think it should exist becuase Jews have lived on that before there was ever a such thing as a Muslim. The Romans named the land Palestine to remove any association of the Jews after they rebelled.
 
Actually to prove your stupidity, jews of the roman time were themselves muslims because they submitted to Allah swt. So to call the righteous muslims of the past jews nahhh sorry.

Remember Politics no religion
 
I think it should exist because no one owns the world so people of any faith should be allowed to live where ever they please.
 
mahdisoldier19 said:
Actually to prove your stupidity, jews of the roman time were themselves muslims because they submitted to Allah swt. So to call the righteous muslims of the past jews nahhh sorry.

Remember Politics no religion
Click to expand...


huh? How could they be Muslims before the final Prophet (pbuh) brought humanity to Islam?
 
Um, has anyone noticed that you can actually choose both options?

Edit-me-do! :p
 
Assalamu alaikum

Yes, Israel does have a right to exist as its own independant state, just like Palestine does but not on land which it is illegally occupying, presently.

Ma'assalama
 
LOL

Ok...Well, actually I took both options, Israel needs somewhere to go, but it shouldn't be acquired through illegal land grabs :)
 
imaad_udeen said:
huh? How could they be Muslims before the final Prophet (pbuh) brought humanity to Islam?
Click to expand...

Because they followed the word of God... and when Christianity came they became Christians following the word of God... then when our beloved final prophet came without all the human corruption, they did convert to Islam also... not all of them though as you can see. So you really can't say that Jews were there before Islam existed because when Islam did come, a lot of jews converted or "took a step up" knowing what is the true word of God and what has been distorted by humans after Musa (A.S.) or Isa (A.S) died.

Kavon
 
Israel as a state should never have happend jews have aright to live in that land as much as muslims that is not the issue the state know as israel is illegal and has murdered and existed illegaly for a long time under a outside pressure was it created and under a forigen oressure does it continue to exist...an injustice...

before the children of israel came to that land there were philistines lets goive it back to them if were using 2000years back history to decide who lives where...

and those who lived on those lands have always been following the religon of the one god therefore they were muslim long before they rejected prophet isa (jesus) peace be upon him and became jews...

otherwise today they would be muslims...so if it is to be judged on who was on that land 2000years back lets give it back to the muslims and USA back to the native americans...otherwise stop talking of what you know not...
 
Israel will always exist..God foretold it.
It doesn't really matter what we humans think or want...though we are entitled to our opinions..but at the end of the day.
It is Gods will and it will be done.

Gods choosen people will contintue to dwell in Israel until the end of time Then God then will build a new Jerusalem on a new earth. For his choosen Children.
Amen
 
Last edited:
Of course, Israel has a right to exist. It's a blessing for that region! They develop hightec. It's a witness, that also the middle east can evolute if only they want.
They were able to make this dry land fertile, and while Jews eat juicy oranges, mosts arabs around still bite the dust of the desert and run with AK47's around ! - Shameful -.
 
Why can the Palestinians not settle in a new home like the Israilis.

here is a great place that they can live without border disputes:

I just hope they don't burn the US flag that is on it ;-)

moon_ng020203e.gif
 
A reminder to follow the rules... or else!!! Is there not respect for the rules? Knuckles, Mahdisoldier19, Guyabano, Twelver and Rou please do not post any more, you have used your 1 post!

Choose only one choice, because only 1 will be taken... As I look at the results, no name is under both answers!
 
Last edited:
You need to consider the situation now, not two millenia, a century, or half a century ago. Israel is there, and it's people are there. They have as much right to stay where they want to be as anybody else...virtually every piece of real-estate on the planet has been "acquired" from somebody else in similar fashion at one time or another - how far back do you go?

The only way forward now is a peaceful, equitable two-state solution, with a Palestinian state in Gaza and (all of) the West Bank. The only way that will ever happen is if Israel's right to exist is recognised, terrorism ends and no threat to the existence of Israel exists. In that eventuality, the US no longer has an excuse to block UN demands that Israel withdraw completely from the occupied territories, and sanctions (if necessary) can be applied to ensure they do just that. Israeli "settlers" in the West Bank should be welcomed to stay if they wish, but in part of Palestine, not Israel.
 
No.
Do people really need an explanation for why not??
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top