Student gets life for stabbing to death lover's pregnant wife

Aziz said:
a very good reason not to associate yourself with lovers
Click to expand...
I agree.

especially Non Muslim ones.
Click to expand...
That sounds wrong. Like, intolerant wrong.

The guy shouldn't have been cheating on his wife in the first place. That's not very Islamic.

It's good that his murdering lover has been imprisoned.
 
If everyone followed the basic laws of gods these things just wouldnt happen..it is only when people think gods rules dont apply to them that they get into trouble.....
I did not like the comment about not getting involved with lovers.."especially non muslim ones"...lol what does that mean......
 
Aziz said:
it means you are doing extra haram stuff.
Click to expand...

I disagree. You are not doing extra haram by having an affair with a non-Muslim. You will be doing extra haram if you had done it with a muslim. How? well when you commit sin with a Muslim then you are dragging your brother/sister in Islam with you to the hellfire.

In either case, the guy should be stoned to death as punishment prescribed by Islam for those who do adultery. He wronged two women here, a non-muslim and a muslim. The fate of both is on his head.
 
OK..I am seriously confused. How can anyone deduce from that story the religious beliefs of the murderer?

I am pretty sure, if she "believed" in one of the major world relgions, there would have been some clause or rule somewhere stating that sexual relationships outside of marriage and murdering a preganant woman and her helpless fetus were not kosher.
 
How can anyone deduce from that story the religious beliefs of the murderer?
Click to expand...
the names dear;this article came up in another forum,we were discussing UK Muslim domestic issues(I had plans to immigrate there;I am scrapping them now).
 
I cant stop laughing..when you committ a sin with a muslim you are dragging him into the hellfire....okay so drag a non muslim into the hellfire thats much better....come on we are all humans and equal in the eyes of god.and trust me, no matter what religion you practice god does redeem if you sincerely repent.in other words a human being has no right to say who is going to hell and who isnt...That is between the person being judged (by god alone) and god himself..
 
chosen said:
I cant stop laughing..when you committ a sin with a muslim you are dragging him into the hellfire....okay so drag a non muslim into the hellfire thats much better....come on we are all humans and equal in the eyes of god.and trust me, no matter what religion you practice god does redeem if you sincerely repent.in other words a human being has no right to say who is going to hell and who isnt...That is between the person being judged (by god alone) and god himself..
Click to expand...

Which is worst, stealing money from your own family or from someone else? both are wrong since you are stealing but isn't it worst when you steal from your own family?

What i meant was that you would be dragging your fellow muslim down with you when you commit a sin with a muslim. So rather then helping him/her be a better person, you are doing the opposite. I'm in no way saying that it's ok to go do evil stuff with non-Muslims, its equally detestable and sinful and the person would be punished under islamic law with the same punishment in both cases.

You are right that if you repent sincerely then Allah does forgive and it is indeed He who decides who will go to heave or hell. But that doesn't mean we have not been informed/warned to stay away from certain things that could/would lead you to path of hell.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Suomipoika said:
So you are turning many (how many is many? 20? 50? 1000?) incidents with Hindus and what you have seen with your family to how most westeners behave?

Im sorry but isnt that exactly the sort of behaviour that is constantly complained about when unfairly judging islam/muslims based on the violent incidents we see some (self proclaimed) muslims do?
Click to expand...

How do you think statistics are done?

they take a sample of the population and test them and based on that they generalize it to the whole population. Woodrow's generalization maybe more true than you think.
 
fine fine we are deviating from the actual topic.I withdraw the statement.Fine???

so are such murders besides the honour killings really common?marriages seem to such a pain in the back in the UK for Muslims it seems to me.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top