Part 19
In Surat Al 'Imran, v.144, Allah said: {"And Muhammad is no more than a Messenger. Many Messengers passed before him. If he dies or is killed, will you then turn back on your heels?"}
There are a handful of verses in the Qur'an where the words in the verse were actually spoken by a Companion prior to being officially revealed and incorporated into the Qur'an by Allah. This is one of those verses. As Mus'ab bin 'Umayr stood on the day of Uhud surrounded by pagans, and as he looked over and saw that the Prophet himself was surrounded and in danger, he said to himself: "Muhammad is only a Messenger. Many Messengers passed before him." Mus'ab was then killed by the pagans, and the rumor spread that it was the Prophet who had been killed, rather than Mus'ab. Upon hearing this false report, the Companions became divided into three groups: Some were so sad & demoralized that they simply gave up; some went and joined the hypocrites; some said: "If Allah's Messenger has died, then let us fight for what he died for," and they stayed firm as they were. And later, these words that Mus'ab had uttered in the face of a siege by the pagans were completed and revealed by Allah as this verse from the Qur'an in order to confirm a crucial point for those who follow this da'wah…
A person can be motivated to believe in or follow something for any of a variety of reasons:
• Some simply like to follow the crowd, and will adopt a methodology that their friends accept;
• Some experiment with beliefs & methodologies, such that when they are tired of one, they exchange it for another, as if it's a flavor-of-the-month commodity;
• Some were sucked in in a moment of emotion, while perhaps hearing a moving lecture or presentation;
• Some might believe in or follow a methodology out of attachment to a particular personality.
It was due to this phenomenon that the mere rumor of the Prophet's death led to some of the Companions to lose heart and give up. The verse in turn came to address this human inclination and teach that by attaching our hearts to anything but the message itself, we will collapse under the slightest pressure and turn on our heels. Even though the Messenger (صلى الله عليه وسلم) is loved on account of being the one through whom the Message & methodology are delivered. This is why the Companions who stood firm at Uhud responded to the rumors of the Prophet's death with: "If he died, then fight for what he died for," i.e. 'So what if he died? We followed his message, not him as an individual. He is nothing more than a Messenger.' And this is why on the day that the Prophet actually did die seven years later, Abu Bakr stood and said: "Whoever of you worshipped Muhammad, then Muhammad has died. But whoever of you worshipped Allah, then Allah is Ever-Living and does not die," and he recited the verse in question. This was to emphasize that we are Muslims for Islam itself, and not because of any attachment to personalities.
Western society places great emphasis on personality worship, whether it be of music stars, movie stars, and other forms of celebrity. One notices that this phenomenon has afflicted even da'wah organizations in these societies, where there exists a sort of 'Superstar Shaykh' culture that appears to serve as a substitute celebrity culture in place of the jahili version that surrounds us. The danger in this is two-fold: first, the opinions & words of such celebrities are taken as absolute, undisputable truths that cannot be challenged, even though the truth is not exclusive to one particular group of scholars or instructors; and second, such veneration and undue attachment to any personality will inevitably lead to his blind followers dispersing & turning back on their heels the moment that Shaykh, leader, etc changes his beliefs, is arrested, or dies – just as some of the Companions did at Uhud when they thought the Prophet had died. The solution is to have an open, critical, analytical, and investigative mind that allows you to take the truth from wherever it comes, for the sake of it being the truth, regardless of who it comes from. And as al-Imam Ahmad said: "From the lack of a person's knowledge is that he believes in something out of blindly following another person." And perhaps it was for this reason that Imam Ahmad himself would limit his classes to the teaching of ahadith from his 'Musnad' and would strongly discourage that his own opinions be written down. He wanted to emphasize an attachment among his students to his sources – the Qur'an & Sunnah – rather than to his own person and opinions.
It is truly unfortunate that because many initially enthusiastic & energetic Muslims neglect to grasp the theme taught in this verse, they end up becoming manhaj chameleons – one day, they are Salafi, the next day Sufi/Ash'ari, another day they might leave the Din altogether. This all leads back to the fact that their entrance point into the da'wah was one of the fleeting, superficial motivations that I'd outlined early on. Such chameleons change so often because they at one time followed the truth for all reasons but the right one: conviction and deep understanding of the message itself.
So, beware of undue attachment to and veneration of personalities – people change, and they die. Rather, study, love, be sincerely motivated and inspired by the da'wah itself and its original pure source – the message never changes, and it never dies.
طارق مهنا
Tariq Mehanna
Plymouth Correctional Facility
Isolation Unit - Cell #108
In Surat Al 'Imran, v.144, Allah said: {"And Muhammad is no more than a Messenger. Many Messengers passed before him. If he dies or is killed, will you then turn back on your heels?"}
There are a handful of verses in the Qur'an where the words in the verse were actually spoken by a Companion prior to being officially revealed and incorporated into the Qur'an by Allah. This is one of those verses. As Mus'ab bin 'Umayr stood on the day of Uhud surrounded by pagans, and as he looked over and saw that the Prophet himself was surrounded and in danger, he said to himself: "Muhammad is only a Messenger. Many Messengers passed before him." Mus'ab was then killed by the pagans, and the rumor spread that it was the Prophet who had been killed, rather than Mus'ab. Upon hearing this false report, the Companions became divided into three groups: Some were so sad & demoralized that they simply gave up; some went and joined the hypocrites; some said: "If Allah's Messenger has died, then let us fight for what he died for," and they stayed firm as they were. And later, these words that Mus'ab had uttered in the face of a siege by the pagans were completed and revealed by Allah as this verse from the Qur'an in order to confirm a crucial point for those who follow this da'wah…
A person can be motivated to believe in or follow something for any of a variety of reasons:
• Some simply like to follow the crowd, and will adopt a methodology that their friends accept;
• Some experiment with beliefs & methodologies, such that when they are tired of one, they exchange it for another, as if it's a flavor-of-the-month commodity;
• Some were sucked in in a moment of emotion, while perhaps hearing a moving lecture or presentation;
• Some might believe in or follow a methodology out of attachment to a particular personality.
It was due to this phenomenon that the mere rumor of the Prophet's death led to some of the Companions to lose heart and give up. The verse in turn came to address this human inclination and teach that by attaching our hearts to anything but the message itself, we will collapse under the slightest pressure and turn on our heels. Even though the Messenger (صلى الله عليه وسلم) is loved on account of being the one through whom the Message & methodology are delivered. This is why the Companions who stood firm at Uhud responded to the rumors of the Prophet's death with: "If he died, then fight for what he died for," i.e. 'So what if he died? We followed his message, not him as an individual. He is nothing more than a Messenger.' And this is why on the day that the Prophet actually did die seven years later, Abu Bakr stood and said: "Whoever of you worshipped Muhammad, then Muhammad has died. But whoever of you worshipped Allah, then Allah is Ever-Living and does not die," and he recited the verse in question. This was to emphasize that we are Muslims for Islam itself, and not because of any attachment to personalities.
Western society places great emphasis on personality worship, whether it be of music stars, movie stars, and other forms of celebrity. One notices that this phenomenon has afflicted even da'wah organizations in these societies, where there exists a sort of 'Superstar Shaykh' culture that appears to serve as a substitute celebrity culture in place of the jahili version that surrounds us. The danger in this is two-fold: first, the opinions & words of such celebrities are taken as absolute, undisputable truths that cannot be challenged, even though the truth is not exclusive to one particular group of scholars or instructors; and second, such veneration and undue attachment to any personality will inevitably lead to his blind followers dispersing & turning back on their heels the moment that Shaykh, leader, etc changes his beliefs, is arrested, or dies – just as some of the Companions did at Uhud when they thought the Prophet had died. The solution is to have an open, critical, analytical, and investigative mind that allows you to take the truth from wherever it comes, for the sake of it being the truth, regardless of who it comes from. And as al-Imam Ahmad said: "From the lack of a person's knowledge is that he believes in something out of blindly following another person." And perhaps it was for this reason that Imam Ahmad himself would limit his classes to the teaching of ahadith from his 'Musnad' and would strongly discourage that his own opinions be written down. He wanted to emphasize an attachment among his students to his sources – the Qur'an & Sunnah – rather than to his own person and opinions.
It is truly unfortunate that because many initially enthusiastic & energetic Muslims neglect to grasp the theme taught in this verse, they end up becoming manhaj chameleons – one day, they are Salafi, the next day Sufi/Ash'ari, another day they might leave the Din altogether. This all leads back to the fact that their entrance point into the da'wah was one of the fleeting, superficial motivations that I'd outlined early on. Such chameleons change so often because they at one time followed the truth for all reasons but the right one: conviction and deep understanding of the message itself.
So, beware of undue attachment to and veneration of personalities – people change, and they die. Rather, study, love, be sincerely motivated and inspired by the da'wah itself and its original pure source – the message never changes, and it never dies.
طارق مهنا
Tariq Mehanna
Plymouth Correctional Facility
Isolation Unit - Cell #108