hi brother how are you?
i will try to help you as soon as i can but before i start answering your questions i would ask you question do you believe that there is only one god and his angels ans his massengers including Adam ibrahim ...mohammed and his books torah gosbel quran and the day of judgment and qada w qadar?
then i would like to tell you that islam is not about your opinions
or desires because we know that anything that has been forbidden is from God s wisdom
I just thought I'd post a few things here about reverting and maybe someone can respond to them.
First of all, what I like about Islam-
It treats people equally, no racism or putting one ethnicity above another. I also like that it believes in ONE God and the whole idea of Shirk. God has no sons or daughters, is not a man, etc.
I also like that the Qur'an has not been altered. And I love the idea that it is a continuation of the message of the prophets. I also love that Muslims are to be hard-working and serve Allah. And they are modest people. I also like that it is easy to revert and you don't have to go through a bunch of steps to join Islam.
I can accept that there is no God but God. And I can accept that Muhammad(S) was a messenger of God.
So, based on the above, I could revert and say the Shahadah, but I wouldn't be a very good Muslim for the following reasons.
The things holding me back are:
I keep reading about little rules that seem to me not from God. For example, growing the beard. I can't believe God would really care about that one. That seems to me to be a man-made idea or relic from the past.
i am glad to answer your first question,regarding growing the beared is from authantic hadith not from God directly but we know that if we obey God then we have to obey his massenger by the way its not a big sin and you can ask forgiveness from God,
Not eating pork, not eating bacon seems like something that was a good idea hundreds of years ago but now is outdated.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EetZU4y44-k
islam is not about time
The hijab on women. That is fine if a woman wants to wear it, but if you don't, I wonder if it matters really to God. It seems to be another relic from the past.
brother let me tell you something i think you are living in an open society
am i right? if so i would like to tell you something take it as an advice
dont expect God thinking like humanbeing,the word in English for hijab is veil or covering.why is hijab?
do you know that the western society has one of the highest rates of rape for more informations go to http://www.islamicvoice.com/october.98/zakir.htm
Music. Is it really haram? Come on. How is that possible? Music to me seems to be a wonderful thing that God created. I love music, it brings me closer to God.
the short answer for this question is because it takes you away from the quran because you are not muslim yet so you cant imagine that by the way there are many sorts of music some are ok, There is considerable variation on this topic,and its not a big sin ,if you want to be a realy realy good muslim you have to avoid it
Another thing is Wudu. That also seems to be a man-made relic from the past. Why would God care about you rinsing your nose out, rubbing water through your hair, washing your feet, etc?
islam cares about a person to be clean,there are also several benefits from wdu as refreashing your self.try to do wudu then you will see it by your self
Praying five times a day. I don't see how I could faithfully do that one. Prayer seems to me to be a personal thing between me and God, not something that I should have to do like clock work and have to say in another language that I don't even understand what I am saying.
first of all you will know how to pray and understanding what are you saying,do you know the slat is to show whether you are a real believer or not,not just saying i believe this is islam ,as you know islam is about submitting to God and this life we as muslims we know its a test from God and we believe its the only way and its not easy but remember if you are sincere with God it will benefit you,and your duaa will be answered if you are sincere
Whenever I listen to some Sheikh on internet TV more rules are brought up. I hear Muslims call in with questions and worrying about whether they can do this or that.
these people how are asking questions do care about God by the way every thing is allowed in islam except which has been forbidden in quran or the teaching of prophet sunnah
Things like wearing gold, shaving your eyebrows, wearing make-up, whether women's ankles should show during prayer, etc. That seems to be a lot of nit-picking over nothing. I couldn't follow all those little rules.
actually you dont have to but its better unless if you believe that God knows better than you
Ramadan. I doubt I would be very good at fasting. It would probably harm me and my health would suffer and I would end up sick.
ramadan will teach you how to be patience and trust me brother if God knows that fasting will harm us actually its the opposite of that he will never make it an obligation for us
It also bothers me that there are Shias, Sunnis, Hannafis, extremists, etc.
But I guess that is man-made invention. Too bad all Muslims can't agree.
yes its man made and there is a verse and hadith talk about that but let us agree that hanfi has no problem with the teaching of prophet mohammed which is sunni by the way 85% of muslims are sunni
sunnah in arabic mens some thing that had been done ,but in this case some thing had been done by prophet mohammed.
so brother to conclude this i would suggest you to embrace islam even if you feel that you cant give up somethings,and dont forget to ask God that you are sincere and say to him show me the right path i am sure he will answer you ^^
Don't get me wrong, I have found a lot of things I like so far in learning about Islam, but there are still some things holding me back. If anyone wants to take a stab at some of the above it would be appreciated.
Would I be better off not reverting, or should I revert but be a "lousy" Muslim? Which is better? if you believe in God then its the only choice a trust me it will be hard at first then it will be much easier and it will benefit you
:wa: