Umm Yoosuf
Al-Athariyyah
- Messages
- 4,851
- Reaction score
- 596
- Gender
- Female
- Religion
- Islam
I was asking you personally. Scroll up and read your own entry. I know that br is the head of it and inshallah ill have my own discussion with him but right now im discussing this with you. Its interesting how you quoted his whole response to speak for yourself...indeed the first commandment is Iqra, READ LEARN EDUCATE YOURSELF!
Firstly, these sorts of discussion have been discussed a number of times. There is no need for me repeat myself again and again.
Secondly, I quoted brother Kadafis respond merely showing you the answer to your concerns.
Differentiating yourself isnt enough. Discussion should be allowed on this matter if you really claim to be otherwise. This is the beleif of Ahla Sunnah Wal Jamah.
This is the layout for you to backup your statments...
Quote the ayah, and then quote a Sahabi or Ijmaa’ or Shaykh that explains the ayah, if you are so intelligent and confident that you have the correct understanding and exegesis of Qur’an whereas all the other learned and qualified Scholars of Islam are not as correct as you; please do the following:
a. Quote the ayah or hadith
b. Quote the Prophet (sallallahu ‘alayhe wassallam) that explained the ayah or hadith explicitly or
c. Quote the consensus (Ijmaa‘) of the Muslim Scholars on this ayah or hadith or
d. Quote a Classical Islamic Scholar on this ayah or hadith.
If you cannot do at least TWO of these, then you need to take a hike because you are wasting all of our time.
You are looking for an argument and there is nothing for us to argue about understand? There is nothing to back up?