Turk barber faces execution for swearing

[Umar001]

then ı can say..islam doesnt want to kill person who swears islam but saudi arabia does...?

No, I dont think you understand, the rulings change from time to time, i.e. for example, a woman has to pray, but not when she is having her period. Does that mean Islam has changed? No, it means that the rulings change sometimes and somtimes they do not.

Similarly Islam might teach x but only when the right circumstances are in place.

 

[abdil han]

if he said so by a healthy mind,i dont say anythng to saudi practice,but it should be proved certainly..

as a turk,i dont second someone just becoz of being from my nation,islam is over nations...

but the proves,witneses have to be trustable...

Allah knows the best n inshaAllah he didnt swear islam,,amin..

 

[S_87]

lets dont say it like that..does islamic rules change according to time? if islam commands to kill ppl swearing islam,it doesnt matter where the swearing person is..

as you see with the case the egyptian and saudi didnt kill him but the case itself had to go through a proper shariah court where proof and evidence had to be properly investigated.
if turkey implements shariah thered by shriah courts and so such cases could then be made.
cant just go chopping heads off...

 

[kirk]

If he is guilty of swearing at God and the prophet, what is the punishment under Islam law ( not the punishment under Saudi law!)

-

 

[ranma1/2]

one of these days god will come up and say... hey i can take care of myself leave the kid alone.

 

[anatolian]

I have listened to some people who lived in KSA for a while and they generally told some similar stories about the absurdities of the Saudi laws...they say that in KSA they don't take your advocacy so seriously if you're foreigner...

Are there any Saudi here?

 

[chacha_jalebi]

thread has gone more off then a old mans rottin teeth

:threadclo