Re: "war against terror and its targets--A question for non-Muslims"
This boils down to the second important distinction I made in my post. I don't dispute that Iraqis or Afghans have the right to fight the occuption forces. What I do dispute is that:
1. They may attack civilian targets (which seems their primary tactic at the moment)
2. Any Muslim anywhere has the right to attack any Western country, which seems a popular enough sentiment as well.
What you see is that the French resistance did indeed accept these rules. They did not infiltrate into Germany to detonate car bombs on markets for example.
If we do not at least set up these restrictions Western civilians would be just as entitled to attack any Muslim in any country, especially their own. If indeed - as you seem to believe - this is a war between the West and Islam, then why would any American (or American militia, there are plenty) not be allowed to hunt down any Muslim they can find in America? Just like in fact the Muhajedeen are doing in Iraq and Afghanistan? Where no Western humanitarian worker, civilian contractor or journalist is in fact safe?
So, as a compromise, I would say them not wearing uniforms is not really an issue as far as resistance fighters IN IRAQ are concerned who attack the OCCUPATION FORCES. Anyone who does not feel bound by these rules (Mulims in American attacking Americans or Iraqis in Iraq targeting civilians) can I believe be identified as a terrorist and dealt with accordingly.
So in short, there are some limits. While I believe both the Iraqi and Afghan resistance are doing more harm than good, I do think they have a right to fight the occupation forces. But what is happening in Iraq now is something completely different. In Afghanistan the Taliban are fighting a bit more traditional war, but even here car bombings and suicide bombings on civilian targets are becoming more popular.
Hello KAding,
I do not understand the purpose of all Attack in Iraq or Afgan.
Some say some events are intentionally created by the western for to broke the unity.
Ask a question in your mind
Do you see picture or do you getting the news from both side. Answer is no.
So why anyone believe Israeli/american and their created media. It’s a
proven fact they are a big liar. They can do
anything to achieve their goal.
I believe they only provide news only that much what can not harm them. And I also want to believe many people know it.
Many countries fought their own Liberation War.
What felling do they have for those people who are from their own country but helping/fueling the enemy greatly?
What felling does u have for them who assist those destroyers who destroyed your thousand year’s culture and security?
We cannot /should not/ must not ………………… criticize those who are defending their own religion/dream/culture/security/home/family.
We should criticize the invader.
We should criticize those who’s pack of lie destroyed and destroying a entire civilization of Iraq and Afghan.
Their action creating and fueling the entire thing.
They are the
only responsible for any wrong doing of anywhere simply bcoz they stared/created and still doing the same massacre
for a pack of lie.
Do u how many people suffering by their action?
The entire Muslim Ummah.
A Muslim will feel the same feelings what a brother of Iraq or Afgan(it does not matter what the state is) is feeling.
.