Will Sharia Law ever work in Britain?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cabdullahi
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 271
  • Views Views 27K

Will sharia law ever work in britain

  • Total voters
    0
Status
Not open for further replies.
I dont think it would work in UK or America or any western country because not even Saudi Arabia is following Sharia the correct way so what would be the condition in a non-muslim country?
 
Short answer is no.

Long-answer, no, it wouldnt work ANYWHERE. Simply put, "Full Shariah law" maybe ordained by Allah, but that does you little good when your country explodes from inflation run amok.

This of course is not even addressing the political issues...
 
amani said:
shariah law is a fair system and one that does not discriminate between rich and poor, influential and not so influential, muslim and non muslim, or racially.
so long as there is bribery and corruption amongst the leaders and people in charge....
Click to expand...
Oh, so the answer is never.

Thanks.
 
krypton6 said:
^ Every single muslim wants his country to be ruled islamically and according to the sharia. Were it not for your country this wish would be the reality.
Click to expand...

There is almost nothing "very single muslim wants". :hmm:

It seams that every time you post, you make up stuff. :giggling::giggling:
 
krypton6 said:
^ Every single muslim wants his country to be ruled islamically and according to the sharia. Were it not for your country this wish would be the reality.
Click to expand...

Sorry to contradict you, but not EVERY Muslim want that. One of my good friends is an Muslim from Iran (and he make very tasty Kebabs btw.) and he would no way have sharia in our country.

You globalize too much and you would be surprised how few muslims will be with you on this one.

Peace
 
Re: It feels like life imprisonment

sur said:
agree.
BUT, instead of 100% i'd say "Majority".
Click to expand...
Saudi Arabia is 100% Muslim and it isn't Islamic enough. :hmm:
Can't you see the Queen in the latest fashion from Omar the tent maker? :hiding:
 
amani said:
the way britain is now- no

shariah law is a fair system and one that does not discriminate between rich and poor, influential and not so influential, muslim and non muslim, or racially.
so long as there is bribery and corruption amongst the leaders and people in charge....
Click to expand...
No discrimination between Muslim and non-Muslim? :skeleton:
Either you have taken far too many Blue Pills or you know very little about Sharia Law. :?
 
:sl:
wilberhum said:
Saudi Arabia is 100% Muslim and it isn't Islamic enough. :hmm:
Can't you see the Queen in the latest fashion from Omar the tent maker? :hiding:
Click to expand...
Saudi is run by a king. I'm sure you can see how that is not Islamic :) It's an example of irony though, and a funny one at that.

wilberhum said:
No place. It takes years if study to understand "god's laws". :playing:
Another proof that "Life is a Test". :hmm:
Click to expand...

Actually there is a place. You can start by a) reading the Quran and B) reading the sunnah and hadith of the Prophet. A bonus is common sense too.

Simple really.
 
wilberhum said:
No place. It takes years if study to understand "god's laws". :playing:
Another proof that "Life is a Test". :hmm:
Click to expand...
It takes years of study to understand man's laws.

Another proof that law degrees are crap?

Come on, don't argue using strawmen, it doesn't become you.
 
krypton6 said:
^ Every single muslim wants his country to be ruled islamically and according to the sharia. Were it not for your country this wish would be the reality.
Click to expand...

actually no they dont...

No discrimination between Muslim and non-Muslim?
Either you have taken far too many Blue Pills or you know very little about Sharia Law.
Click to expand...
it is you that know very little about shariah law wilberhum. under islamic law muslims and non muslims are treated equally. the ruler is equal to others. heres an example of shariah law. :)

Once, a dispute arouse between Ali bin Ali Talib, when he was the Caliph, and a Jewish man who went to Judge Shuray al-Kindi. Shuray tells the details of what happened:

“Ali found he was missing a suit of mail, so he went back to Kufa and found it in the hands of a Jewish man who was selling it in the market. He said, ‘O Jew! That suit of mail is mine! I did not give it away or sell it!’

The Jew responded ‘It is mine. It is in my possession.’

Ali said, ‘We will have the judge rule on this for us.’

So they came to me and Ali sat next to me and said, ‘That suit of mail is mine; I did not give it away or sell it.’

The Jew sat in front of me and said, ‘That is my suit of mail. It is in my possession.’

I asked, ‘O Commander of the Faithful, do you have any proof?’

‘Yes,’ Ali said. ‘My son Hasan and Qanbar can testify that it is my suit of mail.’

I said, ‘Commander of the Faithful, the testimony of a son in his father’s favor is not admissible in court.’

Ali exclaimed, ‘How Perfect is God! You cannot accept the testimony of a man who has been promised Paradise? I heard the Messenger of God saying that Hasan and Husain are the princes of the youth in Paradise.’

The Jewish man said, ‘The Commander of the Faithful takes me before his own judge and the judge rules in my favor against him! I bear witness that no one deserves worship except God and that Muhammad is His Messenger [the Jewish man accepted Islam], and that the suit of armor is yours, Commander of the Faithful. You dropped it at night and I found it.’
Tirmidhi
 
Re: It feels like life imprisonment

wilberhum said:
Saudi Arabia is 100% Muslim and it isn't Islamic enough. :hmm:
Click to expand...

It isnt ruled islamically because of your country who have removed the democratic leaders that they used to have and then replaced them with your own men who will do anything that you tell them to do.

Every muslim wants the sharia, if you dont want the sharia how can you call yourself a muslim? It seems that every post you make is pure bull****!
 
amani said:
actually no they dont...
Click to expand...

So living in a society with more than 90% muslims and where the leader is a responsible muslim, would you not want the sharia then? How can you see yourself as a muslim if you dont want the sharia?
 
krypton6 said:
So living in a society with more than 90% muslims and where the leader is a responsible muslim, would you not want the sharia then? How can you see yourself as a muslim if you dont want the sharia?
Click to expand...

She doesn't have to be talking about herself, brother. And even if she is, that's her opinion, it's not our place to judge.
 
krypton6 said:
So living in a society with more than 90% muslims and where the leader is a responsible muslim, would you not want the sharia then? How can you see yourself as a muslim if you dont want the sharia?
Click to expand...

good question. were you asking me or in general?

because if the majority of people wanted shariah they would be implementing what is fardh on them. society would not be corrupt because they themselves will be following what they want. but do we see that? no.

it no use saying shariah shariah when the kilaphate comes we'll implement shariah! lets fix ourselves first...
 
amani said:
it is you that know very little about shariah law wilberhum. under islamic law muslims and non muslims are treated equally. the ruler is equal to others. heres an example of shariah law. :)
Click to expand...

Is this why non-muslims have no political rights under a shariah system? I guess black American had nothing to complain then back in the day. Ditto for women.
 
amani said:
it no use saying shariah shariah when the kilaphate comes we'll implement shariah! lets fix ourselves first...
Click to expand...

i think you misunderstood the question

How can you see yourself as a muslim if you dont want the sharia?
Click to expand...
his saying how can you see yourself as a muslim if you DONT WANT the shariah. If you dont desire it, if you dont have that yearning inside to live in a state ruled by the rulings given by Allah subhana wa ta'ala.

now i know that everyone should fix up, but what kinda muslim dont want sharia? sounds like progressives to me...


Assalamu Alaikum
 
Isambard said:
Is this why non-muslims have no political rights under a shariah system? I guess black American had nothing to complain then back in the day. Ditto for women.
Click to expand...
you get what we get. You will be treated equally, commit a crime then expect punishment. Be good and we leave you alone and take care of you if your in need.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Back
Top