Will Sharia Law ever work in Britain?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cabdullahi
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 271
  • Views Views 27K

Will sharia law ever work in britain

  • Total voters
    0
Status
Not open for further replies.
Isambard said:
Argueing from ignorance doesnt make you right, especially when its agaisnt someone who understands the issues at hand.
Click to expand...
Right back atcha. ;)

Ah, lighten up people. Everyone should stop getting their knickers in a twist about hypotheticals, and start eating more candy floss.
 
Peace

I voted NO. The reason being is that then the British Law would have to accept laws of the other religions.

I really don't think that majority of the British citizens would agree and there would probably be riots or protests plus the media made had a field day with this issue and many people follow the media and as other Members have written before, this country needs to learn about Islam first. The TRUE concept of Islam.

Peace to all
 
Greetings,
aamirsaab said:
the Islamic population outnumbers all other religions by millions.
Click to expand...

Are you sure about this? There are more Christians than Muslims according to every statistic I've seen.

Like here, for example.

However, the only thing more slippery than a statistic is a religious statistic, of course.

Peace
 
^Ya Christians do outnumber Muslims at the time. But Islam is the fastest growing and A LOT of Christians do not even practice their religion at all. I kno there are plenty of Muslims like that, but I think the percentage of Muslims going to Mosque is higher that the percentage of Christians going to Church.
 
Guys;

When y'all take over Europe, from a strictly aesthetic standpoint, please do not put minarettes on St Paul's or Chartres.
 
Cognescenti said:
Guys;

When y'all take over Europe, from a strictly aesthetic standpoint, please do not put minarettes on St Paul's or Chartres.
Click to expand...

There is nothing to be scared of,You will live a peacful life,crime rates will drop,we will put clothing on the women so that sexaul assault will drop,we'll close night clubs and lessen the intermingling of of opp sexes and many other things to keep the west clean and wash of the dirt that they struggled to wash of in the years.

It may sound that we are restricting u but no! it is for the better the society will be better think of it being this way A mother wants the best for her child and she prevents her child from eating unhealthy food or candy that will rot their teeth the child is being told not to eat it! but the child is confused,why should i stop it ,it tastes good but the child doesnt know the consequences that will arise later
 
Ahmedjunior said:
There is nothing to be scared of,You will live a peacful life,crime rates will drop,we will put clothing on the women so that sexaul assault will drop,we'll close night clubs and lessen the intermingling of of opp sexes and many other things to keep the west clean and wash of the dirt that they struggled to wash of in the years.

It may sound that we are restricting u but no! it is for the better the society will be better think of it being this way A mother wants the best for her child and she prevents her child from eating unhealthy food or candy that will rot their teeth the child is being told not to eat it! but the child is confused,why should i stop it ,it tastes good but the child doesnt know the consequences that will arise later
Click to expand...

Ah.

A benevolent fascist! An all-loving totalitarian? Irrespectively, I can't help but feel completely patronised by all of the above. Your ideal society ignores human choice and lacks respect for able-minded adults capable of making their own decisions.

What if I want to intermingle with the opposite gender? What if I want to go to a nightclub?
 
Skavau said:
Ah.

A benevolent fascist! An all-loving totalitarian? Irrespectively, I can't help but feel completely patronised by all of the above. Your ideal society ignores human choice and lacks respect for able-minded adults capable of making their own decisions.

What if I want to intermingle with the opposite gender? What if I want to go to a nightclub?
Click to expand...
What if somebody wants to do the jiggy with a five year old? What if somebody wants to view pictures of others doing said jiggy with five year olds?

I don't want to do that as it's wrong and disgusting. On the other hand, I wouldn't call a society which bans it oppressive.

Decency depends on your point of view.
 
Muezzin said:
What if somebody wants to do the jiggy with a five year old? What if somebody wants to view pictures of others doing said jiggy with five year olds?

I don't want to do that as it's wrong and disgusting. On the other hand, I wouldn't call a society which bans it oppressive.

Decency depends on your point of view.
Click to expand...

Which would be illegal in any civilized society regardless of religious doctrine of course....

* I think the point is that a theocracy puts limits on personal freedoms that a non-theist(secular democrats included) would find restrictive and fascist.
 
Keltoi said:
Which would be illegal in any civilized society regardless of religious doctrine of course....

* I think the point is that a theocracy puts limits on personal freedoms that a non-theist(secular democrats included) would find restrictive and fascist.
Click to expand...
Point taken. I was just feeling a little twisted. I'm sure nudists (or 'naturists' or whatever the heck they call themselves :p) feel somewhat restricted in just about any civilised society. Again, point of view.
 
Muezzin said:
Point taken. I was just feeling a little twisted. I'm sure nudists (or 'naturists' or whatever the heck they call themselves :p) feel somewhat restricted in just about any civilised society. Again, point of view.
Click to expand...

Nudists also don't do that in public. They do that in enclosured areas far away from public curiosity. In that case, I see no harm on that. They don't offend anybody. Of course, if they would go public, they would be arrested immediately, sharia or not.
 
I asked in another thread and 'Amirsaab' kindly answered. I asked ''Would adulterers be stoned to death?'' and he said yes, this barbaric practice would take place here? and you'd feel at home with it would you? has anybody who agrees seen it take place? has anybody seen it on youtube? I have, and I have a strong stomach to endure it. I'd like to know those that gree if they can endure watching it??
 
I also wanna ask what happens with a child born from outside marriage affair,who is called often as "ba@#$%d" ?
 
AvarAllahNoor said:
I asked in another thread and 'Amirsaab' kindly answered. I asked ''Would adulterers be stoned to death?'' and he said yes, this barbaric practice would take place here? and you'd feel at home with it would you? has anybody who agrees seen it take place? has anybody seen it on youtube? I have, and I have a strong stomach to endure it. I'd like to know those that gree if they can endure watching it??
Click to expand...

The ruling for adultery is a lot more complex. First of all it requires 4 witnesses for it to even get into the courtroom (for some weird reason, certain muslim countries get this wrong and think adultery means rape....which makes everyone else think that muslims are prats).
Secondly, the matter has to be dealt with via the usual court proceedings - it cannot be carried out by police or martial law etc.
Thirdly, the stonning is maximum sentence - and because it carries such a harsh sentence, 4 witnesses are required. It's hard enough to get 1 witness for adultery, let alone 4!

Unfortunately, as I have stated on this thread before, many muslim countries do not impliment sharia law properly (probably because of the lack of a caliphate!) and so we get some really stupid cases.

I gave you a short (and hypothetical) answer in that other thread because I wouldn't have been able to explain it properly in that thread without derailing it. Since this one was still open I thought we might as well do it here.


Edit:
Aaron85 said:
I also wanna ask what happens with a child born from outside marriage affair,who is called often as "ba@#$%d" ?
Click to expand...
I don't know what you mean actually. The child should certainly not be outcasted (from the community) since we do not believe in original sin. If you are referring to custodial related stuff then I do not know. I haven't heard of a specific ruling on this actually but I guess it depends on what you mean. Could you clarify the question a bit, please?


p.s; Azy (and several others) and I previously had a conversation but the posts were lost during a forum crash. Just thought I'd let you people know.
 
Last edited:
aamirsaab said:
I don't know what you mean actually. The child should certainly not be outcasted (from the community) since we do not believe in original sin. If you are referring to custodial related stuff then I do not know. I haven't heard of a specific ruling on this actually but I guess it depends on what you mean. Could you clarify the question a bit, please?
Click to expand...

I was talking about this with my muslim friend some time ago. The imagined situation is like this- man has an affair with a woman. Both are in other marriages. And from this affair a child is born. Some people call it "b@#$%d" child. What would happen to this child in real islamic state?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Back
Top