MisterK
Esteemed Member
- Messages
- 110
- Reaction score
- 16
- Gender
- Male
- Religion
- Islam
Hello,
I'm not 100% sure this is the correct sub-forum for this, but it does seem the most fitting. Apologies if it isn't, and apologies on the length, I've included a brief synopsis for those less inclined to read the full thing.
TL;DR version:
Lacking faith in most of the Six Pillars of Iman, attracted to societal/cultural aspects of Islam, currently an agnostic atheist and sense of reason won't let me believe despite emotionally wanting to. How can one go about creating faith when head and heart are clashing?
Full version:
Recently I've read the Holy Quran in English, and have been reading a book entitled "The Lawful and the Prohibited in Islam" by Islamic scholar Yusuf al-Qaradawi, and another called "The Essentials of the Islamic Faith" by M. Fethullah Gülen.
As I read the Holy Quran, the further into I moved, I could feel a sort of emotional attraction to it, and found myself liking most of the cultural laws. This attraction to Islam and how it is designed for charity, family, community, health, and so on continues to grow as I read the book by Qatadawi (which tends to draw its conclusions from the Holy Quran and thw Haddiths). Gülen's book is more about the spiritual aspects of Islam, and it too has a certain appeal (some of it reads as things I previously believed, just with Islamic terminology).
So I have all of these reasons to become Muslim, but despite these attractions, I'm lacking in one very important thing; belief in the Six Pillars of Iman.
I'm an agnostic atheist, and as much as I would like to beleive, I find my head and heart will not synchronize on this.
Of the pillars, belief in Al-Qadar is the easiest to obtain, as everything does seem to be preordained in one way or another. By that I mean the events of now are determined reactions based on past events, all the way to the beginning of time. Things happen as they do because as a result of what came before. If things were to happen differently it would be because of different past events. If I could find faith in Allah, it would be a no-brainer that it is all as He willed.
The next easiest is belief in His books and Messenges as the Holy Quran does seem to have some scientific understandings beyond its time, and fixes some of the hard-to-believe aspects of the earlier books (such as Jesus being a prophet, and not both God and God's Son). I'm sure there are arguments against these things, but it isn't difficult to see how the Holy Quran could be divinely revealed, and Prophet Muhammad as one chosen by Allah to be a messenger given how many verses of Holy Quran can be seen as revealing scientific truths ahead of their time.
This leaves belief in the Last Day, angels, and of course, Allah Himself as the trouble spots (so to speak) for me. Of course, if I found faith in Allah, I feel the rest would fall into place. Despite wanting to believe (I recall I was happier, more at peace, before I became an atheist), I have all of these arguments in my head that won't allow for it.
So, once having faith in the concepts of God, angelic forces, the afterlife, and so on, the question is, once lost, how can one go about finding their faith again, even as every bit of their reasoning abilities says that such faith is illogical and wrong?
I'm not 100% sure this is the correct sub-forum for this, but it does seem the most fitting. Apologies if it isn't, and apologies on the length, I've included a brief synopsis for those less inclined to read the full thing.
TL;DR version:
Lacking faith in most of the Six Pillars of Iman, attracted to societal/cultural aspects of Islam, currently an agnostic atheist and sense of reason won't let me believe despite emotionally wanting to. How can one go about creating faith when head and heart are clashing?
Full version:
Recently I've read the Holy Quran in English, and have been reading a book entitled "The Lawful and the Prohibited in Islam" by Islamic scholar Yusuf al-Qaradawi, and another called "The Essentials of the Islamic Faith" by M. Fethullah Gülen.
As I read the Holy Quran, the further into I moved, I could feel a sort of emotional attraction to it, and found myself liking most of the cultural laws. This attraction to Islam and how it is designed for charity, family, community, health, and so on continues to grow as I read the book by Qatadawi (which tends to draw its conclusions from the Holy Quran and thw Haddiths). Gülen's book is more about the spiritual aspects of Islam, and it too has a certain appeal (some of it reads as things I previously believed, just with Islamic terminology).
So I have all of these reasons to become Muslim, but despite these attractions, I'm lacking in one very important thing; belief in the Six Pillars of Iman.
I'm an agnostic atheist, and as much as I would like to beleive, I find my head and heart will not synchronize on this.
Of the pillars, belief in Al-Qadar is the easiest to obtain, as everything does seem to be preordained in one way or another. By that I mean the events of now are determined reactions based on past events, all the way to the beginning of time. Things happen as they do because as a result of what came before. If things were to happen differently it would be because of different past events. If I could find faith in Allah, it would be a no-brainer that it is all as He willed.
The next easiest is belief in His books and Messenges as the Holy Quran does seem to have some scientific understandings beyond its time, and fixes some of the hard-to-believe aspects of the earlier books (such as Jesus being a prophet, and not both God and God's Son). I'm sure there are arguments against these things, but it isn't difficult to see how the Holy Quran could be divinely revealed, and Prophet Muhammad as one chosen by Allah to be a messenger given how many verses of Holy Quran can be seen as revealing scientific truths ahead of their time.
This leaves belief in the Last Day, angels, and of course, Allah Himself as the trouble spots (so to speak) for me. Of course, if I found faith in Allah, I feel the rest would fall into place. Despite wanting to believe (I recall I was happier, more at peace, before I became an atheist), I have all of these arguments in my head that won't allow for it.
So, once having faith in the concepts of God, angelic forces, the afterlife, and so on, the question is, once lost, how can one go about finding their faith again, even as every bit of their reasoning abilities says that such faith is illogical and wrong?