Hadith Challenge . . .

  • Thread starter Thread starter أحمد
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 267
  • Views Views 36K
zAk said:
from the list tht u gave - its just the "Al-Bidaayah wan-Nihaayah" tht starts wid Alif :brother:
:sl:

:sister: Halima meant "his" as in the writer's name. The writer's name does actually begin with an Alef, but that's definately not the book with that narration . . . :) :p Please try again; you might get the answer this time . . . Insha-Allah . . . :p

:w:
 
zAk said:
Tafsir ibn Kathir ??

if not then can v get the arabic text ?? :)
:sl:

:) The answer is wrong, but here's the Arabic . . . :p If you have some sort of search facility; please let others attempt this question; as you can easily find it anyway with a simple search. . . :)

غسل وجهه ويديه وذكر رأسه ورجليه

:w:
 
Ahmed Waheed said:
:sl:

:) The answer is wrong, but here's the Arabic . . . :p If you have some sort of search facility; please let others attempt this question; as you can easily find it anyway with a simple search. . . :)

غسل وجهه ويديه وذكر رأسه ورجليه

:w:

i treid googling it and al i got were more arabic links :(
 
ahmed687 said:
i treid googling it and al i got were more arabic links :(
:sl:

:D It might be in one of the Arabic links you found in google . . . :p keep looking . . . Insha-Allah . . . :p

:w:
 
zAk said:
yeah, there is the answer in those arabic links ;)
:sl:

:D I think :brother: zAK know's the answer; and furthermore; he know's how easy the question is . . . ;D Sub-haan-Allah . . .

:w:
 
zAk said:
yeah, there is the answer in those arabic links ;)
:sl:

:D You've got some time to answer this question, before :sister: Halima writes up the answer; so get going . . . :D Guess wisely . . . :p

:w:
 
:sl: i think its stainj dat ppls 'er avn't evn herd ov bukhari, or day nver red it. subhanalla. ;D ;D an' its abit sad dat ppl don't know much abou' hadith :omg: :( :( :( :( :( :( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( day don't know da basics :omg: :w:
 
Assalamu 'alaikum

Indeed it is quite saddening that I myself do not know much, but InshaAllah that is why we are here. :)

To benefit from eachother, may Allah accept all our efforts ..

Big or Small.

Ameen
 
khal_75 said:
:sl: i think its stainj dat ppls 'er avn't evn herd ov bukhari, or day nver red it. subhanalla. ;D ;D an' its abit sad dat ppl don't know much abou' hadith :omg: :( :( :( :( :( :( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( day don't know da basics :omg: :w:
:sl:

:( Yes, it is quite sad; that many people didn't get one of the easiest questions asked in this thread right. It is Bukhari, I answered quite alot of my own questions before also. It may just be that people need to be woken up, and told to do something constantly, before they get into it. Ahadith study is very important; as today you'll come across many mis-understandings and divisions and all sorts of other trouble regarding how one understands the Sunnah of the Prophet :arabic5:, the answer is a very few. The common excuse is; "I follow such and such" and "It's the scholars; that are to blame 100%", but one has to take some responsibility. Every second person talks about fighting and killing; when they don't understand the very basics of Islam; they go into their "scholar-mode" and end up making all sorts of fatwas and so the era of Jahiliyyah over-comes the Muslim Ummah . . . :'(

:w:
 
farhan247 said:
Assalamu 'alaikum

Indeed it is quite saddening that I myself do not know much, but InshaAllah that is why we are here. :)

To benefit from eachother, may Allah accept all our efforts ..

Big or Small.

Ameen
:sl:

:) Ameen . . .

:) The next question is: What is Hadith ath-Thaqalain?

:w:
 
Assalamu 'alaikum

Hadith of the two weighty things?

The Messenger of Allah (PBUH) said: I am leaving for you two precious and weighty things (ath-Thaqalayn) that if you adhere to BOTH of them you shall not go astray after me. They are the Book of Allah and my progeny (descendents), that is my Ahl al-Bayt (People of the House - Family of Mohammad). The Merciful has informed me that these two shall not separate from each other till they come to me by the Pool (of Paradise).
 
:sl:

Brother, I think you are trying to teach like an Alim course to kids. They will not pick up most of the information you throw at them anyway; so why bother. It is obviously very hard for people who are kept away from Hadith by their Imams and other so-called religious leaders and scholars. You do remember that I was in that position at one time. But online teaching isn't as effective as the classroom or one-to-one style.

I picked up what you used to teach in Islamic Societies quite fast compared to this, because I think it was just a different environment. I don't mean to disapoint anyone, but I see people go to forums just to spend a little bit of their time there; its a way of avoiding bordom, not to gain knowledge. That's another reason why you cannot really teach online. And at this day and age; no-one else even cares about guidence and unity. They each think they are upon the straight path and everyone else is fee dhalaalim-mubeen. You will get a very small amount of people; who are even very reluctantly willing to translate a small hadith you posted in the Arabic thread. Brother Ali posted it on another forum and got a stupid reply for it also.

:w:
 
farhan247 said:
Assalamu 'alaikum

Hadith of the two weighty things?

The Messenger of Allah (PBUH) said: I am leaving for you two precious and weighty things (ath-Thaqalayn) that if you adhere to BOTH of them you shall not go astray after me. They are the Book of Allah and my progeny (descendents), that is my Ahl al-Bayt (People of the House - Family of Mohammad). The Merciful has informed me that these two shall not separate from each other till they come to me by the Pool (of Paradise).
:sl:

:applaud: Maa-Shaa-Allah . . . :D Very good . . .

:) There's a narration; about when the Prophet :arabic5: was about to pass away; just a few days before He :arabic5: told people to get pen and paper; so that He :arabic5: can inform them of something. :zip: One of the companions of the Prophet
:arabic5: speaks at this point; saying that the Prophet :arabic5: is ill and (what he :arabic5: is saying) is being determined by his :arabic5: pain (of the illness) and that the book of Allah that we have will suffice; telling people that we don't need anything more.

:) Who was this companion?

:w:
 
Eddi said:
:sl:

Brother, I think you are trying to teach like an Alim course to kids. They will not pick up most of the information you throw at them anyway; so why bother. It is obviously very hard for people who are kept away from Hadith by their Imams and other so-called religious leaders and scholars. You do remember that I was in that position at one time. But online teaching isn't as effective as the classroom or one-to-one style.

I picked up what you used to teach in Islamic Societies quite fast compared to this, because I think it was just a different environment. I don't mean to disapoint anyone, but I see people go to forums just to spend a little bit of their time there; its a way of avoiding bordom, not to gain knowledge. That's another reason why you cannot really teach online. And at this day and age; no-one else even cares about guidence and unity. They each think they are upon the straight path and everyone else is fee dhalaalim-mubeen. You will get a very small amount of people; who are even very reluctantly willing to translate a small hadith you posted in the Arabic thread. Brother Ali posted it on another forum and got a stupid reply for it also.

:w:
:sl:

:brother: Ednan; I agree with what you're saying, but I'll continue nevertheless, as Insha-Allah the time may come when Muslims do care and can learn and other means may well exist Insha-Allah . . . :D

:w:
 
Assalamu 'alaikum

Jazakallah khair for sharing your thoughts, InshaAllah I will address a few points which you made.

but I see people go to forums just to spend a little bit of their time there; its a way of avoiding bordom, not to gain knowledge
If 100 people visit this forum, and only 1 benefits akhee..then Alhamdulillah. Ahmed is doing a good job of sharing what knowledge he has with us. You are right that it is not the same as teaching one to one, but does that mean he should stop?? No.

If anything he has pleased his lord and he will be rewarded for all his efforts. :)

And at this day and age; no-one else even cares about guidence and unity. They each think they are upon the straight path and everyone else is fee dhalaalim-mubeen.
You are right, may Allah guide us all. But that is no reasoon for those that do care about "guidance and unity" to stop teaching.

Forgive me my words seem harsh, as it was not in my intention to upset anyone..just sharing my thoughts. :)



 
zAk said:
wat for ? :brother:
wasn't prophet :arabic5: UMMI ???
:sl:

:) The Prophet :arabic5: was going to tell them something; that they could have then written down on paper, using a pen . . . :omg: But there was an interruption by one of the people present in the House of the Prophet :arabic5: at the time . . .

:w:
 
Assalamu alaikum

Ahmed Waheed said:
Ednan; I agree with what you're saying, but I'll continue nevertheless, as Insha-Allah the time may come when Muslims do care and can learn and other means may well exist Insha-Allah . . .
O Allah! We ask You for health, for integrity, for good character, and that we may be pleased with our portion.[font=&quot] :)

[/font]
There's a narration; about when the Prophet :arabic5: was about to pass away; just a few days before He :arabic5: told people to get pen and paper; so that He :arabic5: can inform them of something. :zip: One of the companions of the Prophet :arabic5: speaks at this point; saying that the Prophet :arabic5: is ill and (what he :arabic5: is saying) is being determined by his :arabic5: pain (of the illness) and that the book of Allah that we have will suffice; telling people that we don't need anything more.

:) Who was this companion?
U'mar-e-Farooq?
 
:sl:

:) Maa-Shaa-Allah . . .:applaud: This (the same one) hadith appear's about three times in Bukhari; who is the narrator?

:w:
 
zAk said:
Hazrat Ibn Abbas [r.a] ???
:sl:

:applaud: Very good; now we'll move one step forwards Insha-Allah . . . Is the narration authentic? :p (You can get help from earlier posts in this thread Insha-Allah . . . :p)

:w:
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top