I'm an agnostic now

  • Thread starter Thread starter The-Deist
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 363
  • Views Views 51K
Status
Not open for further replies.
One sign that Prophet Muhammad :saw1: was given was the Quran and it is proof of his prophethood. In Surah Al-Qalam, Allah swears on that which is being written down (the Quran) and so the Quran is evidence on the items stated in the verses that follow, including that the Prophet :saw1: was the best of mankind. So, if you look at all the proofs - from the Quran to the work and lifestyle of the Prophet to his excellent character - you'll see that he was the Prophet of God and the best of mankind and worthy of love and adoration.
The Quran doesn't move me
 
Why would you love anyone else more than the one :saws1: who went through so much trouble to make Islam available to you?
Why don't the other Prophets have "Hadiths". I am more interested in them because everything is about Muhammad. Honestly it gets a little boring. Variety. Variety. Variety. They should have had something like Gospels. Like Book of Jesus, Moses etc. A compilation of their life and disciples or followers. Also we don't know anything about companions of other Prophets or Messangers in great numbers.
 
i am sorry about that
the quran is the best way to know allah
say to yourself
if the muslims think that the quran is the book of allah i will read it to see what he want me to do
and read it to know him
he will guide you for sure
it's the best way to know him
I am not interested in The Quran. It doesn't make me feel anything. Not happiness nor sadness. Even music does that.
 
I got bored after 15 minutes.
You got bored?!

The Qur'an is the truth.
If it doesn't grab you, but other scriptures do, then there must be some sort of comprehension issue. It connected and still rings true to me with striking heart cords. A novel it is not. But if it doesn't reach you on any level then I can't understand how other scriptures are doing much better.

I hope sincerely that you find the truth within yourself that you might discern the word without bias. What proud thing is keeping you from accepting the Qur'an?

Peace
 
You got bored?!

The Qur'an is the truth.
If it doesn't grab you, but other scriptures do, then there must be some sort of comprehension issue. It connected and still rings true to me with striking heart cords. A novel it is not. But if it doesn't reach you on any level then I can't understand how other scriptures are doing much better.

I hope sincerely that you find the truth within yourself that you might discern the word without bias. What proud thing is keeping you from accepting the Qur'an?

Peace
There ain't no scripture that can capture me. Plus the lecture ain't about Quran.
 
You speak of emotion yet seem to dismiss the fact that emotion and the conscience are spoken of and relate to much of scripture in many religions.

What do you think is meant by things being placed on your heart?

Peace
 
You speak of emotion yet seem to dismiss the fact that emotion and the conscience are spoken of and relate to much of scripture in many religions.

What do you think is meant by things being placed on your heart?

Peace
People change.
 
Peace upon all of you. I am an agnostic now (former Muslim now Christian). So I believe in one God.

I feel like I left Islam too fast and just wanted to fill the emptiness in my heart. But then I realized I had followed somethings I don't agree witg because emotions.

Do you accept the Trinity Doctrine?

How is possible for you to be Agnostic and Christian at the same time?

Agnostic normally means a person who is open to the idea of a higher consciousness yet not interested in being part of an organized religion.
 
Do you accept the Trinity Doctrine?

How is possible for you to be Agnostic and Christian at the same time?

Agnostic normally means a person who is open to the idea of a higher consciousness yet not interested in being part of an organized religion.
As the thread has advanced it says I am a believer in one deity. Even the OP says (former Muslim now Christian).
 
As the thread has advanced it says I am a believer in one deity. Even the OP says (former Muslim now Christian).

Are you aware that the Bible was written by more than 40 unknown authors in a different language to what Jesus PBUH spoke?

Do you know that the titles of each books such as ''Book of John'' were given later by randomly picking which means John does not identify himself as the author neither does Luke, Mark, Mathew etc. So we dont know even know if John wrote book of John or Luke wrote book of Luke.

Do you know that each unknown author contradict each other?

Lets take Number of women at the tomb noted by each author:


Matthew – 2
Mark – 3
Luke – 5
John – 1


Women disciples visit the tomb and discover Christ missing (Matthew 28:1; Mark 16:1-4; Luke 24:1-3; John 20:1).


This indeed proves that all the unknown authors ''believed'' or ''heard'' the same oral tradition but its very clear that its unlikely to be ''inspired'' by God. In the ancient cultures when some popular or special figure died it was a norm that the people turned him/her in to a God like figure.


Most of these latter scriptures that were added to the bible were based on visions, well if things were based on vision then we know that virgin Mary has appeared to thousands of her followers, as numerous eye witnesses attest: well heck even the pagan cultures had such visions if you study the Roman history, Apollonius of Tyana came to one of his followers after he ascended to the skies/heaven. Dozens of Roman people and senators claimed that king Romulus was taken up-to heaven. People even thought Caesar was a God after he died.
 
Are you aware that the Bible was written by more than 40 unknown authors in a different language to what Jesus PBUH spoke?

Do you know that the titles of each books such as ''Book of John'' were given later by randomly picking which means John does not identify himself as the author neither does Luke, Mark, Mathew etc. So we dont know even know if John wrote book of John or Luke wrote book of Luke.

Do you know that each unknown author contradict each other?

Lets take Number of women at the tomb noted by each author:


Matthew – 2
Mark – 3
Luke – 5
John – 1


Women disciples visit the tomb and discover Christ missing (Matthew 28:1; Mark 16:1-4; Luke 24:1-3; John 20:1).


This indeed proves that all the unknown authors ''believed'' or ''heard'' the same oral tradition but its very clear that its unlikely to be ''inspired'' by God. In the ancient cultures when some popular or special figure died it was a norm that the people turned him/her in to a God like figure.


Most of these latter scriptures that were added to the bible were based on visions, well if things were based on vision then we know that virgin Mary has appeared to thousands of her followers, as numerous eye witnesses attest: well heck even the pagan cultures had such visions if you study the Roman history, Apollonius of Tyana came to one of his followers after he ascended to the skies/heaven. Dozens of Roman people and senators claimed that king Romulus was taken up-to heaven. People even thought Caesar was a God after he died.
Did you even read the thread?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Back
Top