Indian preacher Zakir Naik is banned from UK

[Masuma]

In a lecture delivered on 31 July 2008 on Peace TV, Naik argued that 9/11 "it is a blatant, open secret that this attack on the Twin Towers was done by George Bush himself", to give Bush reason to attack and control oil-rich countries.[28

Come on! REALLY? Isn't he smarter than that???
Does he really believe that? I find this hard to believe. REALLY???

:wa:

Brother, from where did you take that quote? ITS TOTALLY OUT OF CONTEXT! AGAIN!!!

Dr. Zakir says that if we have to believe the media like CNN and BBC, then we have to accept that 9/11 was done by Osama Bin Ladin.

But as a muslim, we Muslims should check everything up before passing it on to others. We Muslims should investigate the matter properly before blaming anyone!

Dr. Zakir says that if we search a little, we'll find many documentaries made by NON-MUSLIMS in which THEY blame George Bush of this crime.

There was a group of AMERICAN SCIENTISTS, who were NON-MUSLIMS who claimed that 9/11 can't be done by Muslims. THEY said that THEY can offer us logical proofs of how exactly the twin tower was brought down.

[Wait, let me find his lecture.]
brb

 

[Masuma]

So WHO says 9/11 was an inside job? Dr. Zakir or the scientists?

 

[Rabi Mansur]

rother, from where did you take that quote? ITS TOTALLY OUT OF CONTEXT! AGAIN!!!
/QUOTE]

I think it was from Wikipedia. I'm just throwing it out there if someone can shed additional light on it.
Regardless of whether it is out of context or not, they still shouldn't be banning him. Whatever happened to free speech?

:wa:

 

[Masuma]

Asalamu Alikum Wr Wb!

I think it was from Wikipedia. I'm just throwing it out there if someone can shed additional light on it.

Hmmm okay! I'll try to explain because I try to hear as many of Dr. Zakir's lectures as possible.

Regardless of whether it is out of context or not, they still shouldn't be banning him. Whatever happened to free speech?

:wa:

Yeah totally! They are afraid that Islam is spreading at such a fast speed. So they plot and plan.

 

[Masuma]

Brother Rabimansur,

there was this same allegation against Dr. Zakir to which he responded in one of his tv shows. I'm trying to find it on Youtube but I think it's not there.

What Dr. Zakir says is that he HIMSELF don't criticize George Bush of the Twin Tower attack! These are the non-Muslims and American scientists who blame George Bush for it.

Dr. Zakir himself don't know who is responsible! But the evidences given by these scientists and other documentaries are far superior than what CNN and BBC shows!

If a logical person wants to judge something, he would look to the both sides of the picture and then derive his conclusion. That is what Dr.Zakir does. And he says that I find the scientists speaking in a more logical way than what CNN and BBC shows!

 

[Masuma]

[this is a part taken from Dr. Zakir's lecture above]

There was an article that came in the newspaper that "75 professors of US", they say THEY believe that 9/11 was an inside job. And in the article it was mentioned, it came in Times of India, probably on 7th of September, it says that 75 Professors and scientists, belonging to different parts of US, THEY believe that 9/11 was an inside job. And THEY say that there were some politicians in white house who have engineered the destruction of the twin Towers. And THEY say the main reason was so that they could attack and they could have control over the oil rich countries. Its an open secret. One of the professors by the name of Keith Jone, he says that "WE don't believe that 19 hijackers and a few men in the cave of Afghanistan could have done such a professional job alone! WE don't believe and by God we gonna come to the truth and we gonna expose. WE don't believe in the theory of the government! "

And brother you can yourself watch many documentaries of the NON-MUSLIMS where they present us a different picture of the whole 9/11 scene.

Here in this thread are the links...
http://www.islamicboard.com/general...eption-biased-broadcasting-truth-exposed.html

 

[piXie]

Any latest news abt the ban?

 

[Pygoscelis]

I think this thread should be read in conjunction with the Florida Church Quran Burning thread. Both are instances of speech that offends people and in my opinion both should be allowed. Free speech is really the best way. Let these views compete in the marketplace of ideas and more often than not they will collapse on themselves. Unless he was actually making strides towards violence or pushing others to it, this guy should not have been banned from the UK.

 

[Rabi Mansur]

I think this thread should be read in conjunction with the Florida Church Quran Burning thread. Both are instances of speech that offends people and in my opinion both should be allowed. Free speech is really the best way. Let these views compete in the marketplace of ideas and more often than not they will collapse on themselves. Unless he was actually making strides towards violence or pushing others to it, this guy should not have been banned from the UK.

Totally agree.