is it time for muslims in the west to leave?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dawud_uk
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 62
  • Views Views 10K
D

Dawud_uk

IB Expert
Messages
1,692
Reaction score
270
Gender
Male
Religion
Islam
assalaamu alaykum brothers and sisters,

i have been looking into the fataawah on hijra and when it is obligatory or just mustahaab but to me it looks to be obligatory at this moment.

what do others think?

i was looking at the following fatwah from islam q and a and is from sheikh Muhammad ibn ‘Uthaymeen, i cannot imagine a better explaination of my own situation but i also think the situation would be the same for many others here also who's countries are waging war against the muslims.

so should we all leave?

<<fatwah below>>

assalaamu alaykum,
Abu Abdullah

http://islamqa.com/index.php?ref=34687&ln=eng

Islam Questions & Answers

www.islam-qa.com

Question Reference Number:: 34687

Title: He has become Muslim but he does not want to leave his homeland

A man has become Muslim and he loves Islam and its people, and hates shirk and its people. But he has stayed in his country whose people hate Islam and wage war against it and fight the Muslims. It is too hard for him to leave his homeland so he has not migrated. What is the ruling on that?.

Answer:

Praise be to Allaah.

Shaykh Muhammad ibn ‘Uthaymeen (may Allaah have mercy on him) said:

It is haraam for this man to stay in this land, and he must migrate. If he does not do that then let him await the punishment of Allaah, as Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning):

“Verily, as for those whom the angels take (in death) while they are wronging themselves (as they stayed among the disbelievers even though emigration was obligatory for them), they (angels) say (to them): ‘In what (condition) were you?’ They reply: ‘We were weak and oppressed on the earth.’ They (angels) say: ‘Was not the earth of Allaah spacious enough for you to emigrate therein?’ Such men will find their abode in Hell — what an evil destination!

Except the weak ones among men, women and children who cannot devise a plan, nor are they able to direct their way”
[al-Nisa’ 4:97-98]

If this man is able to migrate, then he must migrate to a Muslim country, then the love of the country from which he migrated will disappear from him heart and he will come to love the Muslim land. But if he cannot leave a land that is fighting Islam and its people just because it is his first homeland, this is haraam and it is not permissible for him to stay there.

From Majmoo’ Fataawa Ibn ‘Uthaymeen (may Allaah have mercy on him), 3/32. (www.islam-qa.com)


©Copyright Islam Q&A 1997-2000
You are granted the right to use and display all the information on this site without any consent from the site maintainer(s). You may copy, distribute, print, link to any document, or translate to any language, as long as the information is quoted in its entirety, the source is mentioned, and without changing the contents.
Click to expand...
 
Last edited:
The main question I have is "Leave to Where?"

The next question is: "If a person is not a good practicing Muslim where they now live, what would make them any different where ever they live?"

We also have the example of the mass migrations of Muslims leaving the "Islamic" countries and moving to Western Countries. The reasons they are leaving need to be looked into.


We even have Bilal Phillips who is a strong role model for all of us. Yet He only chose to live in Saudi Arabia for 2 years and is now a US Citisen living in the Phillipines. (The Phillipines are an American Territory and the Residents are considered to be US Citisens with US Citisen rights except to vote in Federal Elections)

Where is a true Islamic Country? Is it a place or is it Making our own lives where ever we live, into our own Islamic Nation?
 
Woodrow said:
The main question I have is "Leave to Where?"

The next question is: "If a person is not a good practicing Muslim where they now live, what would make them any different where ever they live?"

We also have the example of the mass migrations of Muslims leaving the "Islamic" countries and moving to Western Countries. The reasons they are leaving need to be looked into.


We even have Bilal Phillips who is a strong role model for all of us. Yet He only chose to live in Saudi Arabia for 2 years and is now a US Citisen living in the Phillipines. (The Phillipines are an American Territory and the Residents are considered to be US Citisens with US Citisen rights except to vote in Federal Elections)

Where is a true Islamic Country? Is it a place or is it Making our own lives where ever we live, into our own Islamic Nation?
Click to expand...

assalaamu alaykum,

i am talking straight forward islamic rulings that as far as i am aware are agreed upon, if the muslims are attacked then those who live in those nations doing the attacking have an obligation to leave those nations and those who do not without valid excuses are sinning.

there are many muslims lands, i admit some better or worse than others but the obligation is still clear to you is it not?

assalaamu alaykum,
Abu Abdullah
 
SirZubair said:
Leave the west?

No way, we are just getting started.
Click to expand...

assalaamu alaykum sir zubair,

can you explain what you mean?

are you talking about dawah?
because if you are i understand the obligation of hijra takes more importance here though that wouldnt lift our obligation of doing dawah whilst preparing to make hijra i believe.

assalaamu alaykum,
Abu Abdullah
 
Last edited:
there are many muslims lands, i admit some better or worse than others but the obligation is still clear to you is it not?
Click to expand...

The obligation is clear. But the prospect of finding a Muslim Nation that a revert would be able to migrate to is very dim. For many of us it will never be an option. It would be very difficult for a revert to practice Islam in the Islamic Nations. Language barriers alone would make it difficult to gain citizenship. Without citizenship legal employment is often not possible, without employment, it would be difficult to to meet the Islamic requirements of being able to provide for a family.

Even without my heath problems, I think it would be difficult to find an Islamic Nation that would grant me citizenship. You don't see many if any Muslim Nations screaming for Muslims from other Nations to migrate to them.


For myself this is a moot point, as health concerns will not even allow me to leave much further then my Bedroom and then for only short periods of time.
 
:salamext:


Off topic posts have been removed. We don't need anti islamic posts here, and anyone can easily take anything out of context.


If anyone wants to truely understand these issues, they can refer to these links:


Terrorism:
http://www.load-islam.com/classified_list.php?topic_id=2&classified_id=13


Misconceptions - Commonly Misquoted Verses and Narrations
http://www.load-islam.com/artical_det.php?artical_id=414&section=wel_islam&subsection=Misconceptions


other than that, carry on insha'Allaah :)
 
The reality of the world is that the Countries that are considered the most Islamic are Arabic nations. Over 85% of the Worlds Muslims are not Arabic. If all One Billion plus Non-Arabic Muslim were to migrate to a tiny Arabic Nation, we would push out the Arabic heritage of Islam and change the total culture of the nation.

For most of us the only option is to stay where we are and do our best to live as Muslims and make Dua that our example will instill beneficial changes in the nation we live in.
 
:sl:

Woodrow said:
We even have Bilal Phillips who is a strong role model for all of us. Yet He only chose to live in Saudi Arabia for 2 years and is now a US Citisen living in the Phillipines.
Click to expand...

Bilal Philips use to live in UAE few years back and he was doing a program from ch33 of Dubai but due to the effects of 9/11 he was arrested for unknown reason and his program was also stopped and now i don't know either he left Saudi Arabia or ....................

:w:
 
wkas said:
:sl:



Bilal Philips use to live in UAE few years back and he was doing a program from ch33 of Dubai but due to the effects of 9/11 he was arrested for unknown reason and his program was also stopped and now i don't know either he left Saudi Arabia or ....................

:w:
Click to expand...

I just did a quick online check to see where he currently lives. Apparantly he is no longer in the Phillipines. It almost seems he does not have any permament residence and travels according to need. Lately he has been spending the Summers teaching in the US and Canada, but also spends time in the Southern Latin American Countries.

I still think of him as a good role model. To me it is as if he makes the space where he is, into an individual Islamic Nation.
 
I wouldn't have become muslim if it weren't for some pleasent american muslims I met that peaked my interest in Islam. Alhamduillah they're here, and inshaAllah while I am here, I can open others' hearts to Islam.

It is my husband and my intention to move to a muslim country in the future (either egypt, his home country, or the UAE), but it's difficult to just pick up and move, especially in modern times with government regulations, visas and whatnot.

edited to add - I don't believe it's fard to make hijra, husband would just like to raise our kids in a place with more muslims.
 
Last edited:
Janaan said:
I wouldn't have become muslim if it weren't for some pleasent american muslims I met that peaked my interest in Islam. Alhamduillah they're here, and inshaAllah while I am here, I can open others' hearts to Islam.

It is my husband and my intention to move to a muslim country in the future (either egypt, his home country, or the UAE), but it's difficult to just pick up and move, especially in modern times with government regulations, visas and whatnot.
Click to expand...

assalaamu alaykum,

being a revert i am in the same situation, but insha'allah with good preparation i will be ready to make hijra though i know it will be a matter of years not months until i am ready.

assalaamu alaykum,
Abu Abdullah
 
Whenever I discuss this topic I always encounter two extremes:

1. It is haraam to live in Dar al-Kufr and one must leave and move to a Muslim country.

2. There is no Dar al-Islam to make hijrah to.

An interesting discussion took place here.
 
Just one little question from me..

I'm referring to the verse in the Quran in which Allah swt says not to take the disbelievers as protectors.

Does that mean we should not live in lands that are governed by non muslims?
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top