is lobster halal?

[ardianto]

those crabs which considered halal here are the blue crabs, orange crabs and flower crabs...

Those are orange crabs !
Alhamdulillah.

 

[north_malaysian]

Yes if the crab can survive more than 1 day without water than that is not the type of crab that live in the sea...we should be very careful. Especially those dark coloured crabs..

dark coloured crabs? like swampy or "lumpur" colour right?

 

[north_malaysian]

peace Bro,

The famous and authorized opinion in Shafie Mazhab is what I mentioned

Imam Al Nawawi wrote:

نقل النووي (27) أن الصحيح المعتمد عند الشافعية حل ميتة جميع ما في البحر إلا الضفدع .
قال أصحابنا أو بعضهم يحلي جميع ما فيه إلا الضفدع للنهي عن قتله أ.هـ .


The correct,authorized opinion in Shafie Mazhab that all what comes of the sea food is lawful except the frog.



Imam Ibn Qudama wrote in his book Al-Mughni:


وجاء في المغني لابن قدامة » كتاب الصيد والذبائح » مسألة حكم ما كان مأواه البحر وهو يعيش في البر » فصل حكم أكل ما لا يعيش إلا في الماء:
( 7829 ) فصل : وكل صيد البحر مباح , إلا الضفدع . وهذا قول الشافعي


Every sea food is lawful except the frog according to Imam Shafei....



peace
.

from our school textbooks .. they mentioned in Shafiite rite we cant eat turtles, crocs and frogs because they are not sea/water creatures..

 

[north_malaysian]

Those are orange crabs !
Alhamdulillah.

is it from the sea or they live on the trees?

My mum prefer to cook blue crabs...

 

[ardianto]

is it from the sea or they live on the trees?

My mum prefer to cook blue crabs...

I try to find some information about crabs in Indonesia.
Those orange crabs are sea crabs.
I found some Indonesian offered land crabs in web, and it price is expensive.

About lobster. I want to eat lobster, but lobster price is ..... wow !