" Islam an Arab religion” Do you agree or disagree?

A

arabianprincess

Elite Member
Messages
356
Reaction score
34
Gender
Female
Religion
Islam
salam wa 3lykom
im writing an essay about Islam and i just needed a second opinion and ur thoughts on it...

any websites etcccccccccccccccc can help me so thank u yall.

Consider the following statement: “Islam an “Arab” religion.” Do you agree or disagree? Please discuss this issue in detail, with sufficient examples and references to support your position as well as due attention to the opposing position as well.
 
wa alaykum us-Salaam

i would mention the fact that on every corner of the planet, so to speak, arab or non, there is a Muslim...back that up with the fact that the country with the most Muslims is Indonesia (i.e a non arab country), as far as i remember, anyway:D

is that what your after :? hmmm

:)
 
the prophet was arabic, the holy book is in arabic, but the teachings are not special to the arabs, like prayer and so on.
now to understand the qur'an 'correctly' you need to have an Arab's understanding of it, the same goes for the sunnah, since the prophet was addressing the Arabs.
so the religion does have a very strong undertone of 'Arab' in it, but it's forms of worship are universal.
I hope that helps
 
Greetings,

It's an interesting question, and I like alcurad's answer above.

I haven't got any figures on this, but I often hear it said that most Muslims are non-Arab, so that would be something to look into.

Peace
 
:w:
I dont think so what you are thinking mt brother islam for all universe I am from Pakistan & our country has been independent for the Islam.We asked that We Muslim Cannot Live our life freely in a non Muslim State(India) so there is a State namely Pakistan Which represent also Muslims in world.The Holy Prophet Hazrat Muhammad (S.A.W) is the prophet for all universe.:thumbs

Allah Hafiz:thumbs_up
 
NO! Islam is a universal religion. Apart from the only point that Muhammad S.A.W - the prophet of Islam, was from Arab there is nothing that can be taken as a proof for the point that "Islam is an Arab Religion".

If we closely look at the teachings of Islam we will find that these are for whole world (Universal) regardless of geographical location. Same goes for the number of muslims in Arab /Non-Arab world.
 
Disagree.

1) If Islam is an Arab religion, why it has so many similarities with Judaism? Are Jews ...Arabs too?

2) Islam reformed the Arabs....in fact it deArabized the Arabs... Islam introduced monotheism, banned infanticide, allowed divorce, banned wine, gave women rights to property, introduced almsgiving etc which were foreign to the Arabs.

3) Majority of Muslims are non-Arabs, and there are Arabs who are Christians, Jewish, Sabaeans, Atheists, Buddhists, Baha'is etc... Arabs themselves are multireligious people...
 
north_malaysian said:
3) Majority of Muslims are non-Arabs, and there are Arabs who are Christians, Jewish, Sabaeans, Atheists, Buddhists, Baha'is etc... Arabs themselves are multireligious people...
Click to expand...

The Sabaean term is controversial. It's still not know whether it refered to the Yemenites who worshiped stars or the Mandean gnostic Christians of Southern Iraq.

On topic;

There's nothing Arab in Islam except that the Qur'an is in classical Arabic (which is not spoken by Arabs anymore) and that the preferred language for Salah is in Arabic.

:w:
 
I once heard

everybody was born a muslim, but it was their choices that made them christian, jewish, hindu, buddhist etc?

I dont know how right that is, so that would explain something, just now sure what!!! :D
 
north_malaysian said:
1) If Islam is an Arab religion, why it has so many similarities with Judaism? Are Jews ...Arabs too?
Click to expand...
rather, Islam and Judaism influenced each other. not to mention both peoples share/d much culturally.

north_malaysian said:
2) Islam reformed the Arabs....in fact it de Arabized the Arabs... Islam introduced monotheism, banned infanticide, allowed divorce, banned wine, gave women rights to property, introduced alms giving etc which were foreign to the Arabs.
Click to expand...

infanticide was hardly wide spread, women could divorce before Islam, actually Islam doesn't allow women to 'divorce' rather to seek a settlement, and giving to the needy and travelers was considered quite a good trait much longer before islam and was incorporated within the religion.

north_malaysian said:
3) Majority of Muslims are non-Arabs, and there are Arabs who are Christians, Jewish, Sabaeans, Atheists, Buddhists, Baha'is etc... Arabs themselves are multireligious people...
Click to expand...

yes but Islam started amongst the arabs.
 
if islam is arab religion...No point Allah create a deen for humankind...there're no such thing ...islam is arab religion....only islam written in arabic....just the writting and pronounce the words in arabic....islam is universal..there're many kind race enter islam...some in malaysia, people think islam that enter malay...because malay mostly islam...if malay mostly christian so it will be like english..is it? there no such thing Arab religion..Arab is a race and islam is a religion...:coolious:
 
i disagree because it makes it sound like its meant for arabs only, or arabs understand it best.

You can excell islamically as a scholar and spiritual leader even if your not arabic by simply learning the language.



:sl:
 
:sl:

I disagree with this term "Islam an Arab religion"
Islam is for all Mankind and In Quran Allah said in some ayat (i don't remember the ayat)
that "I have made whole world a of prayer rag for you"
so how can we say that Islam an Arab religion
and it is also a duty of Muslims to Teach others about Islam

:w:
 
:sl:
alcurad said:
are you sure of that brother:?
true not as much as it used to be, but it is still contained within modern arabic.
Click to expand...

true say..and it depends on what part of the mid east your at...some dialects are more 'further' than the classical than others...
 
waji said:
:sl:

I disagree with this term "Islam an Arab religion"
Islam is for all Mankind and In Quran Allah said in some ayat (i don't remember the ayat)
that "I have made whole world a of prayer rag for you"
so how can we say that Islam an Arab religion
and it is also a duty of Muslims to Teach others about Islam

:w:
Click to expand...

I agree..
 
Hahahah considering only 20% of the world's Muslim population are Arabs, fact speaks for itself :)
 
Interesting topic. Islam as a religion is unique, because it evolved as a political, social, economic, religious and philosophical entity. It flourished in the Arabian peninsula (specifically the "hejaz" region), the homeland of the Masjid-Al-Haram and Masjid-Al-Nabawi. For this reason, the area has significant importance to muslims. However to say that Islam belongs to the people of this region (i.e. arabs) is wrong. To the OP, in your assignment use the quote of rasullullah (saws) "an Arab has no superiority over a non-Arab nor a non-Arab has any superiority over an Arab... except by piety and good action". This shows the Islam was a guidance for all humanity, and not a racial religion as Judaism is essentially (in orthodox judaism i think you can only be a jew is your mother is?).

And as the poster above said... use facts and figures to further back up your point. Stress Islam's position spiritually contradicts any suggestion that it is an "arab religion".
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top