Questions about Judaism answered by a Jew!

  • Thread starter Thread starter lavikor201
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 2K
  • Views Views 217K
Status
Not open for further replies.
Salaam/peace ;


Um, YusufNoor. This thread is an educational thread, not a debate thread. Please don't debate here. If you disagree with anything that you read here please start a new thread for debate.

ok, i started a new thread follwoing related topics those needed more attention & detailed answers.

similarities between Muslims & Jewish Holy Books.

http://www.islamicboard.com/compara...rities-between-muslims-jewish-holy-books.html



Shalom Izak

nice to see you're in a pleasant mood today...


----yap , it's a good news :statisfie :)
 
IzakHalevas

You wrote this in another thread:

Yet, a man who kills 100 people will be forgiven if he repents and converts according to Islam.

Since you criticized the Islamic belief that even a murderer can be forgiven by God, does this mean that in Judaism a murderer cannot be forgiven by God?
 
Since you criticized the Islamic belief that even a murderer can be forgiven by God, does this mean that in Judaism a murderer cannot be forgiven by God?

One who murders, murders. We are not judges, but if one murders, converting to Judaism will do nothing for them. It will be between him and G-d, but organized religion will not help. Good deeds do not take away bad ones. You are judged for everything you do.

Chapter 32


7 And the LORD spoke unto Moses: 'Go, get thee down; for thy people, that thou broughtest up out of the land of Egypt, have dealt corruptly;

8 they have turned aside quickly out of the way which I commanded them; they have made them a molten calf, and have worshipped it, and have sacrificed unto it, and said: This is thy god, O Israel, which brought thee up out of the land of Egypt.

9 And the LORD said unto Moses: 'I have seen this people, and, behold, it is a stiffnecked people

How soon after they received the 10 commandments was this? Were they or weren’t they just old NOT to make idols?

What exactly is your point? These people never went into Israel because they had the minds of slaves who never knew or could understand freedom. Therefore, only their children were aloud to enter the land.

Do they seem appreciative to you?

No, which is why only there children, who were not born in bondage were aloud to enter the land.

11 And the LORD said unto Moses: 'How long will this people despise Me? and how long will they not believe in Me, for all the signs which I have wrought among them?

12 I will smite them with the pestilence, and destroy them, and will make of thee a nation greater and mightier than they.'

Who is it speaking in vv 11 & 12??

While the above events took place, was not there a presence from G-d among them?

so, you don't see a pattern here??

Alright? And your point?

11 And the LORD said unto Moses: 'How long will this people despise Me? and how long will they not believe in Me, for all the signs which I have wrought among them?

12 I will smite them with the pestilence, and destroy them, and will make of thee a nation greater and mightier than they.'

How about putting it in context? You seem very good taking it out of context!

11. The L-rd said to Moses, "How long will this people provoke Me? How much longer will they not believe in Me after all the signs I have performed in their midst?
12. I will strike them with a plague and annihilate them; then I will make you into a nation, greater and stronger than they."
13. Moses said to the L-rd, "But the Egyptians will hear that You have brought this nation out from its midst with great power.
14. They will say about the inhabitants of this land, who have heard that You, O L-rd, are in the midst of this people; that You, the L-rd, appear to them eye to eye and that Your cloud rests over them. And You go before them with a pillar of cloud by day and with a pillar of cloud by night,
15. and if You kill this nation like one man, the nations who have heard of Your reputation will say as follows:
16. 'Since the L-rd lacked the ability to bring this nation to the Land which He swore to them, He slaughtered them in the desert.'
17. Now, please, let the strength of the L-rd be increased, as You spoke, saying.
18. 'The L-rd is slow to anger and abundantly kind, forgiving iniquity and transgression, Who cleanses [some] and does not cleanse [others], Who visits the iniquities of parents on children, even to the third and fourth generations.'
19. Please forgive the iniquity of this nation in accordance with your abounding kindness, as You have borne this people from Egypt until now."
20. And the L-rd said, "I have forgiven them in accordance with your word."

_________________


What is amazing is that your arguments are proofs in my mind that the Torah has not been corrupted. If you look, for example, at the Egyptianm and Babylonian records of war, each side says they only had victory and would not record there defeats. You need to look at another nations records to see when they lost battles. If the Torah was corrupted, why leave all these quotes about G-d becoming angry with the Jewish people? Why leave these quotes about him being restless with us? It proves this is exactly what happend and is still the Torah from G-d uncorrupted!


Let me ask you however, what are you trying to prove by posting a verse where G-d is angry and not posting the verses a few later that say he has frogiven them?

I really don't understand your purpose for being in this thread here is.

what are the differences between kosher wine and non-kosher wine? And what's the significant of having wine in Seder celebration?

There is a misconception about Kosher wine, that it simply doesn’t ‘hold-up’, taste wise. However, one only has to taste some of Golan Heights Winery’s wines (just as an example), to know that is simply not true. Kosher wine used to mean a sweet dark-red liquid – since the mid 1980’s all that has changed.
With the emergence in recent years of so many boutique wineries in Israel, not all of the wine being produced locally is kosher. Many of the boutique wineries simply are unwilling or unable, (due to their growing and production methods) to produce kosher wines. For a wine to be kosher, strict regulations must be followed. It really all begins in the fields. Grapes from new vines may not be used for making wine, until after the fourth year. Every seventh year the fields must be left fallow and there is a prohibition on growing other fruits and vegetables between the vines.

All the equipment, tools and winemaking storage facilities must be kosher. During the harvest, only Sabbath observant male Jews are allowed to work on the production of the wines. Since most of the experienced winemakers in Israel are not observant, this means that they can’t touch the wine or the equipment, during the winemaking process.

During the production of kosher wine, no animal products may be used. Gelatin or egg whites are sometimes used by non-kosher wine makers, to clarify the wine, while kosher wine makers use a clay material, called bentonite, which pulls suspended particles to the bottom of the barrel.

For wine to be kosher one percent of the wine must be discarded, a symbolic remnant of the 10% tithe, paid to the Temple in Jerusalem in days gone by. Additionally, barrels must be cleaned three times.

There are really two levels of kosher wine. The first includes the restrictions outlined above, while the second, known as “mevushal” utilizes an additional process. This is important since Kashrut law stipulates that in order for a wine to retain its ‘kosherness’ once opened and poured by a non-Jew, (such as a waiter, for instance) the wine must be "mevushal."

Bringing the liquid to a boiling point makes this type of wine, causing air bubbles to be brought to the surface and the loss of some wine, due to evaporation. A wine that is produced in this manner retains its religious purity, regardless of who opens or pours it. A study at the University of California at Davis, has proven that it is not possible to consistently taste the difference between non- mevushal and mevushal wine.

To ensure wine’s purity, the codification of koshering wine began in the days of Maimonides. Today, a quick glance at the bottle’s label will clearly indicate whether the wine is kosher or not. Some truly wonderful kosher wine is being produced in Israel.
 
Last edited:
a "Muslim" would be defined as one who believes in the One True G-d, His Angels and Messengers, His revealed Scriptures, the Day of Resurrection and in Divine Preordainment! i'm pretty sure the Patriarchs fit the classification!


the Talmud WASN'T in existance until AFTER the Babylonian captivity! at THAT time, the "folks of Judeae" were the ONLY ones still following the Torah, so OF COURSE they would use that term in describing a Jew. i'll wager that term was NEVER used to describe BOTH the nation of Israel & the nation of Judah, EVER!

by YOUR definition, which i don't agree with by the way, the Patriarchs COULDN'T have been Jews because the didn't follow the revealed, uncorrupted Torah! ergo, a Muslim, in it's TRUE sense, is a better term!

That's fine Yusuf, if we were asking for what Muslims believe about Jews, then your point would be well taken. Apparently I was amiss in regard to the definition of Judaism as understood by Jews in my thinking that it came from the sons of Judah. Based on what Rav and Izak have presented here, who I am sure have a better understanding of Judaism than either of us, I would have to say that a Jewish understanding of the Patriachs is that they were indeed Jewish, just as described above. It may not be the Muslim opinion. Muslims believe Jesus to be Muslim too, I suppose. I think that some of those who Muslims have claimed to be Muslim would be surprised to learn it, but that is really irrelevant to this thread which is not about Muslim beliefs, but Judaism.

How about I take the description of Judaism which Izak shared with us: "Judaism in Hebrew means to acknowledge one true G-d" and say that since Muhammad acknowledged one true G-d that Muhammad was a Jew? Posting that idea in a thread devoted to Questions about Islam answered by Muslims would be out of place, would it not? Likewise, trying to say something is true because it is believed by non-Jews is really out of place here in a thread devoted to better understanding Judaism. Whether the view is right or wrong isn't the point. The important thing to consider is does it accurately reflect Jewish beliefs?
 
I notice some similarity between Islamic and Jewish dietary laws -- I'm thinking specificaly about not eating pork. Is this the only similarity or are there others?
 
I notice some similarity between Islamic and Jewish dietary laws -- I'm thinking specificaly about not eating pork. Is this the only similarity or are there others?


One of you correct me if I am wrong, but I believe them to be similar, but differ at Islam prohibts Alcohol, while Judaism allows wine, and Judaism prohibts mixing of meat and milk and the eating of a dairy product before 6 hours after eating a meat product.

:)
 
Salaam/peace ;


How about I take the description of Judaism which Izak shared with us: "Judaism in Hebrew means to acknowledge one true G-d" and say that since Muhammad acknowledged one true G-d that Muhammad was a Jew?


hehe , that's very funny :p

I don't think Jews will allow anybody to claim that s/he is a Jew just because s/he believes in One God.

U have to visit Rabbi minimum 4 times to convince him that really u want to be a Jew. Just believe in One God does not make anyone a Jew.......at least that what i understood from Izaak & rav's posts. Correct me if i m wrong.



...... The important thing to consider is does it accurately reflect Jewish beliefs?

---sadly i think , sometimes wrong answers are given here. I don't think they are willingly doing this. So , others need to correct them. Such as killing of the Prophets (p) is described in Jewish holy book that was not mentioned here earlier. So, i think , bro Yusuf was right to corrected that.

yap , for debate , may be we need to start many threads like as u asked regarding Izak's definition , was Prophet Muhammad (p) a Jew ? :giggling:
 
Last edited:
Izak, I understand you avoid writing the name of God (for reasons you've explained earlier)?

But the arabic word for God is written in your signature (in Maimonides full name).
 
Salaam;

Izak, I understand you avoid writing the name of God (for reasons you've explained earlier)?

But the arabic word for God is written in your signature (in Maimonides full name).

yap , i just noticed it today & was thinking of asking .
 
In the New Testament, Hebrews 9:22 says "without shedding of blood there is no remission". What is the Jewish belief on animal sacrifice as it relates to sin, and redemption?
 
yap , for debate , may be we need to start many threads like as u asked regarding Izak's definition , was Prophet Muhammad (p) a Jew ?

No, because he was not born into or converted into the Jewish people, the last requirement for being a Jew. I told you what the name means, but the name does not reflect all the requirements.

Izak, I understand you avoid writing the name of God (for reasons you've explained earlier)?

But the arabic word for God is written in your signature (in Maimonides full name).

His name is "Abu Imran Mussa bin Maimun ibn Abdallah al-Qurtubi al-Israili"

Although the name of G-d in arabic may be within a word, that does not mean that I cannot write it. For example, "Israel" the last two letters of that word mean "G-d" as it is written sometimes in the Torah. That doesn't mean I cannot write it however, because it is refering to somehing else and not completly to G-d.

In the New Testament, Hebrews 9:22 says "without shedding of blood there is no remission". What is the Jewish belief on animal sacrifice as it relates to sin, and redemption?

I suggest reading this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_sacrifices

And to look under "Orthodox Judaism" for the stances of sacrifice under traditional Judaism.
 
Although the name of G-d in arabic may be within a word, that does not mean that I cannot write it. For example, "Israel" the last two letters of that word mean "G-d" as it is written sometimes in the Torah. That doesn't mean I cannot write it however, because it is refering to somehing else and not completly to G-d.

Ah, okey. But just so you're aware, it is written "abd Allah" as two words. So the meaning in english is "the slave of God". It doesn't matter since it's a name?
 
Ah, okey. But just so you're aware, it is written "abd Allah" as two words. So the meaning in english is "the slave of God". It doesn't matter since it's a name?

I'm not completly fluent in Arabic, so I am not sure if it would constitute two seperate words or one name. What would be your opinion?

I will most likely remove it so if this message board were to be deleted the name of G-d would not be erased.
 
I will most likely remove it so if this message board were to be deleted the name of G-d would not be erased.

I will ask this before some body else does.

Do you mean you can delete something to avoid it from being deleted?

I think this needs a little clarifying, before it has a chance of becoming an issue.
 
I will ask this before some body else does.

Do you mean you can delete something to avoid it from being deleted?

I think this needs a little clarifying, before it has a chance of becoming an issue.

I think he means that by not actually spelling God on this forum or on paper it cannot be erased because he didn't actually write it. Am I missing something?

Oh okay, I see what you mean now. Missed a post. Good question actually.
 
I will ask this before some body else does.

Do you mean you can delete something to avoid it from being deleted?

I think this needs a little clarifying, before it has a chance of becoming an issue.

lol, yes there would probably be confusion after I wrote that post, and didn't explain. I decided to delete it because I assume it is part of the name, like "Israel" has G-d's name in the last two letters and also a Jew cannot have the name of G-d in his name by itself as just "G-d" it has to accompany something like "slave of G-d" ect. However, to avoid confusion I cutd and pasted it into a word document and saved in a special disk. (Very complicated rabbinical theory on the erasing of G-d's name and computers.) +o(

If you wish clarification, please ask, since it is tough to explain, but basically I cut and pasted the name in a word document and saved it on a disk fullof basically when I accidently write G-d's name, (a disk cannot crash), since we have to do our best to ensure G-d's name is not erased, and it is pretty complicated to go about that and to clarify how to do it on a computer.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Back
Top