why are these stuff haram?

[Sinbad]

Why does islam say that pigs are haram? Iv heard its cause the arabs used to have sheeps that can stand being slaughtered and then exploited under the sun. while pigs have to be in cooled areas or they will be bad for you.
And the arabs slaughtered them let them stand and they got bad and they made it haram.

Why is blood forbidden to drink or eat? I love blood, especially as pudding but sausage is good to!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_pudding

Black pudding or blood pudding is a sausage made by cooking blood with a filler until it is thick enough to congeal when cooled. Blood sausage is a more recent North American term for the same as well as a useful term for similar blood-based solid foods around the world.

Why does islam say that dogs are filthy and bad?
Iv heard that its cause they lick people, and the arabs didnt like that, thinking they made them filthy.

 

[NoName55]

this is more a statement (based on untruths) than questions. answers can be found by searching the forums, here.

 

[vpb]

Why does islam say that pigs are haram? Iv heard its cause the arabs used to have sheeps that can stand being slaughtered and then exploited under the sun. while pigs have to be in cooled areas or they will be bad for you.
And the arabs slaughtered them let them stand and they got bad and they made it haram.

Why is blood forbidden to drink or eat? I love blood, especially as pudding but sausage is good to!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_pudding

Black pudding or blood pudding is a sausage made by cooking blood with a filler until it is thick enough to congeal when cooled. Blood sausage is a more recent North American term for the same as well as a useful term for similar blood-based solid foods around the world.

Why does islam say that dogs are filthy and bad?
Iv heard that its cause they lick people, and the arabs didnt like that, thinking they made them filthy.

first, you're saying that arabs put these rules, but it's not arabs, but it's Allah swt who put these rules.


and pig is a complete dirty animal, meat, it's skin everything.
Dog is allowed to have only if you are a sheperd or if u hunt.

 

[Woodrow]

I do not see why I need to have any reason other than to know that Allah(swt) has said so.

Yes, throughout the centuries many people have found practical reasons as to why those things are haram, but personaly I do not see any need in even wanting to know why Allah(swt) has said anything. I have no reason to question his judgement.

 

[vpb]

Sinbad, if Arabs forbided only things which they didn't like, they how come alchool, which they would give up everything but alchool, why did they made alchool haram and a major sin?

 

[Sinbad]

Sinbad, if Arabs forbided only things which they didn't like, they how come alchool, which they would give up everything but alchool, why did they made alchool haram and a major sin?

This post might get deleted...

When Islam was created, the arabs united and started to counqer, they where far away from their water springs. The alcohol dehydrated it so they where told not to drink it,

 

[Woodrow]

This section is not for debate. This is becoming a debatable topic. I can understand the reason non-Muslims may wonder why some things are considered Haram so for that reason I am moving the thread rather than deleting it.

 

[carpetguy]

we should just accept that if allah says then so be it, all glory and praise be to allah. may he shower us with his blessings. ameen

 

[Umar001]

This post might get deleted...

When Islam was created, the arabs united and started to counqer, they where far away from their water springs. The alcohol dehydrated it so they where told not to drink it,

Surely then it would have only been made haram on those who were out fighting and conquering. Wouldn't make sense to make it haram all the time.

 

[Sinbad]

Surely then it would have only been made haram on those who were out fighting and conquering. Wouldn't make sense to make it haram all the time.

Nothing that is said to be haram makes any sence. Why should drinking be banned? It will only be replaced by stuff in the waterpipe, and the drug kat.

And why should you blindly obey god? I know God exist but I choose not to follow him.

If allah says its haram, why should you obey it?

I live a life that would make your imam cry, and I love it. Why should I bow to God? Why should anyone?

 

[Muezzin]

Nothing that is said to be haram makes any sence. Why should drinking be banned? It will only be replaced by stuff in the waterpipe, and the drug kat.

I don't drink. Or smoke anything, including water pipes. Or take illegal drugs such as kat.

Although I do like Kit Kats.

Delish.

 

[NoName55]

Nothing that is said to be haram makes any sence. Why should drinking be banned? It will only be replaced by stuff in the waterpipe, and the drug kat.

And why should you blindly obey god? I know God exist but I choose not to follow him.

If allah says its haram, why should you obey it?

I live a life that would make your imam cry, and I love it. Why should I bow to God? Why should anyone?

um.. what happend to that fire worship thingie? how come it change to agnostic?

 

[carpetguy]

im just glad mars didnt go ahead with the animal rennet things.

all thanks to the fuss we all kicked up

 

[Woodrow]

Nothing that is said to be haram makes any sence.

Why should drinking be banned? It will only be replaced by stuff in the waterpipe, and the drug kat.

The problem is you are looking for a reason. It is true that alcohol does have negative qualities that may be a reason for it to be Haram. But, it also has many beneficial qualities. so that means the reason for it being haram probably goes beyond it's harm or benefit to humans. remember, life is a trial, part of that trial is for us to obey Allah(swt) We need not question why Allah(swt) requests us to do things, we need only know that it is He doing the request.

And why should you blindly obey god? I know God exist but I choose not to follow him.

It is your own choice not to follow Him. If that gives you comfort and security in life than do so, but be certain you are fully aware of the outcome for your choices.

If allah says its haram, why should you obey it?

No reason is needed than because Allah(swt) has said so.

I live a life that would make your imam cry, and I love it. Why should I bow to God? Why should anyone?

No reason to, unless you know Allah(swt) exists and that is what He has told you.

 

[vpb]

When Islam was created, the arabs united and started to counqer, they where far away from their water springs. The alcohol dehydrated it so they where told not to drink it,

who said they where far away from their water springs?? not all asia is as in sahara

 

[Sinbad]

I just called myself a zoroastrian cause I was born one, I never realy lved with God. And for the last time zoroastrians do not worship the fire, its just a symbol, like saying muslims are stone worshippers cause all must face Kaaba stone in mecca et c.

I dont know of the councequences of not folllowing God. And I do not belive an old book or holy scriptures written down by Man has the answer to God. He is all that is and all that ever will be, he is the creator. Why should a book or scriptures hold the answer?

 

[vpb]

like saying muslims are stone worshippers cause all must face Kaaba stone in mecca et c.

who said muslims worship the stone? They don't.

Why should a book or scriptures hold the answer?

if there is no scripture, how do u know what type of life that creator wants u to live? please explain me.

 

[Ra`eesah]

Disclaimer: The following will be said with all due respect.

Wow, this thread is crazy. I just now realized that Agnosticism is worse then Atheism, you know there is a god but you refuse to worship him?! The same God that gave you life and can take your breath and leave you soul hanging in the middle of the skies and you still chose not to obey? You must be either Stupid or arrogant. Or both.

They gave you a reasonable answer, if its anyone you blindly follow its Allaah and his Prophet (s).

But since that didn’t quench your thirst I will give you “scientific answers” if you need them.

Just watch this clip here.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R6QN....com/watch?v=R6QNCZhI6yw&mode=related&search=

 

[wilberhum]

if there is no scripture, how do u know what type of life that creator wants u to live? please explain me.

You are operating on the assumption that the creator has a thousand rules for you to live by.

That is not an assumption shared by all.

 

[wilberhum]

I just now realized that Agnosticism is worse then Atheism, you know there is a god but you refuse to worship him?!

I just now realized that you operate on unfounded generalizations.