MinAhlilHadeeth
IB Legend
- Messages
- 7,888
- Reaction score
- 790
- Gender
- Female
- Religion
- Islam
Definitely not foolproof. (eg. plenty of cave dwellers who were nice to their mums)
Anyways, what happens if the bloke doesn't get along with his mum but gets along with his sister?![]()
I'm not familiar with the phrase cave dweller, but like I said... it may not apply to everyone.
The relationship between siblings and parents is different, but what do you mean 'not get along'? Does he disrespect his mother? If he does, then there really isn't any point in marrying such a person. If that's how he treats the woman whom he is bound to respect and treat kindly, even if she disbelieves in Allaah, then what can be said of how he will treat his wife? I couldn't respect such a person.
i agree, but only to an extent
i agree with the bit where if he knows how to treat his mum/sisters, then he'll know how to treat his wife...but also I've noticed that some men that are like that, also expect their wives to love their mothers and sisters as much as their own, and his family are her family,etc and basically she barely hears and sees of her family :rollseyes
i know someone who was married to someone like that lol, alhamdulillah it ended where it did :skeleton:
Hmmm, would he like his own sister to be prevented from being able to see their parents, siblings etc.? Some men may be like that (as I said, my example probably doesn't apply to everyone, it's just something I've witnessed around me), but from my own experience, it's the opposite. i.e., they are very hospitable with their in-laws too. Like you said, one of the hardest things for a sister is to leave her family. It would be pretty cruel to then prevent her from being able to see them whilst knowing this.
I don't know what you mean by loving his family, as no one can really love your mother the way you do, and it's a bit unfair to expect that, but she should treat her in-laws with as much respect as she'd treat her own, imho. Although, that's easy for me to say, as I've never had any trouble with my in-laws, but some people have serious problems with their in-laws. So I'm talking from a limited view point here.
Welll... I think my sisters would beg to differ on that.![]()
Why?
All in all, what I was trying to say was, looking at a man's relationship with his female relatives usually provides an insight to his character towards women. For example, my brother always used to help around the house when he could, so I think he'd be able to help his wife quite a lot as he has experience with this.
Whereas with one of my friends, her husband grew up in an environment where his mother did everything for him, and he was taught that it was a shame for the men to lift a finger to help around with anything, or do anything for themselves. She feels that was a major part to play in their marriage breaking down, as he had a pretty primitive view of women, and wasn't afraid to express it.
Whilst its really sweet and loving for a mother to express how much she cares for her sons, she should also teach them how to care for their wives, and be loving towards them. I know I'd want my own sons to be caring and thoughtful husbands, and not tyrants.