Four Husbands

Status
Not open for further replies.
sexual needs can be fulfilled through many means, a partner is not required for all of them, in extreme cases the scholars have allowed masturbation and so on, thus the example sister cat eyes gave is resolved to an extent. otherwise a divorce is one valid solution. see life is coldly indifferent to human needs, only the practical solution prevails in the end however it might hurt/shock.

we have ideals, then we have reality, there's not so much overlap as to not require giving up ideals at times of necessity. for example even killing another is allowed if done for self-defense.

My main point though is, a healthy relationship between a man and a woman is the best medicine for all such needs, for those who require more, it shouldn't be too hard to hold themselves back, self-control is the main reason we're not like the rest of the animal kingdom. a sexual encounter lasts for no more than a little while, the consequences might be life changing.
then we should be careful of indulging and giving in to our primal desires to the point where society/religion are not important.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
in the margin:
women having multiple partners under law is problematic for society, there's an alternative, it's classed as adultery in Islam, although in the future that might not be so clearly the case. in today's society adultery is more acceptable, strangely even some 'scholars' allow a form of it, look at the shiite mut'a, or it's recently spreading-watered down-sunni version called misyar. both can be seen as 'prostitution', although there's only two people involved.

to note, research has shown that it's not that women are satisfied with just one man, while men are lustful and require man women; rather women prefer the best males, and those are in short supply, men simply seek to propagate their genes, hence they're not so selective.
thus, with more technological/medical advancements,cultural revolutions and more aggressive forms of feminism/women's rights; many women will call for the 'privilege' of multiple partners/promiscuity.
this is as anyone can see a dangerous trend, it should be stopped, first through more awareness of it I might add.
http://theoccidentalquarterly.com/archives/vol6no2/DevlinTOQV6N2.pdf
 
Last edited:
sexual needs can be fulfilled through many means, a partner is not required for all of them, in extreme cases the scholars have allowed masturbation and so on, thus the example sister cat eyes gave is resolved to an extent. otherwise a divorce is one valid solution. see life is coldly indifferent to human needs, only the practical solution prevails in the end however it might hurt/shock.

we have ideals, then we have reality, there's not so much overlap as to not require giving up ideals at times of necessity. for example even killing another is allowed if done for self-defense.

My main point though is, a healthy relationship between a man and a woman is the best medicine for all such needs, for those who require more, it shouldn't be too hard to hold themselves back, self-control is the main reason we're not like the rest of the animal kingdom. a sexual encounter lasts for no more than a little while, the consequences might be life changing.
then we should be careful of indulging and giving in to our primal desires to the point where society/religion are not important.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
in the margin:
women having multiple partners under law is problematic for society, there's an alternative, it's classed as adultery in Islam, although in the future that might not be so clearly the case. in today's society adultery is more acceptable, strangely even some 'scholars' allow a form of it, look at the shiite mut'a, or it's recently spreading-watered down-sunni version called misyar. both can be seen as 'prostitution', although there's only two people involved.

to note, research has shown that it's not that women are satisfied with just one man, while men are lustful and require man women; rather women prefer the best males, and those are in short supply, men simply seek to propagate their genes, hence they're not so selective.
thus, with more technological/medical advancements,cultural revolutions and more aggressive forms of feminism/women's rights; many women will call for the 'privilege' of multiple partners/promiscuity.
this is as anyone can see a dangerous trend, it should be stopped, first through more awareness of it I might add.
http://theoccidentalquarterly.com/archives/vol6no2/DevlinTOQV6N2.pdf

First Ive Heard Of This. Masturbation Is Not allowed under Any Circumstances.

Whatever is forbidden is forbidden. No exceptions. Allah SWT knows best
 
I'd like to take this opportunity to thank the TC for completely ignoring my post, failing to answer it, and continuing this ridiculous discussion. :statisfie
 
you seem to be very quick to judge others.. keep your kufir comments in your pocket and don't bring them on this forum

like how much is it you really know yourself because i found your post of no use and you had nothing to support your views

Im sorry but her postz were virging on making out i am a
Kufir and i dont believe on holy qur'an...by quoting my posts. I am not a fool. Jst becoz human has a desire that somethngz should b halal in some cases so it dosent mean now they will act on them aftr they have gotton proper knowledge they fear Allah! Thankz 4 responding to me in a correct manner...may ALLAH REWARD YOU

If I want, I can give as good as I get, so that you won't even find the words to reply again, and I had started to too.. but I had come online as I had been feeling bad worrying I'd hurt your feelings and it kept bothering me. I can read what you've said about me above and let the shaytaan get the better of me. But I'm gonna bite my lip fi sabilillah and I hope you do the same. I swear by Allah, I am asking you to forgive me as I can't bear to think I've displeased Allah by hurting your feelings. I forgive you too and may Allah forgive us both. Ameen

Peace :)


Edit: Oh and my apologies to Br. Woodrow also.
 
Last edited:
Asalaam,

Sister (Scents of Jannah) your post was one of the most constructive and helpful post in this thread.

I thank you and everyone who participated, I believe I have a good understanding or enough arguments to make my case in defense of Islam... or better understand the wisdom behind not allowing multiple husbands.

If everyone has come to an understanding of this subject. I'd like to request that this thread be locked or closed to avoid any further fitnah.

Or, possibly delete all the posts and create one big concise post with answers. Delete the rest. Whatever the moderators decide.

Jazak'llah khair
W'Salaam
 
Last edited:
JazakAllahu khayr brother : (

all good is from Allah
 
:sl:

This is a good time to close this thread. Jazakallajhu Khayran to all who contributed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Back
Top