If Islam is the right path, why have muslims been killing each other for 1400 years?

  • Thread starter Thread starter nifurebo
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 72
  • Views Views 27K
Status
Not open for further replies.
Jazaak Allah khayran bro, I knew about that site, but I never knew how to use the search :S

Anyways, I found the hadeeth al7amdulilah:

Narrated Abu Said:

The Prophet said, "Allah will say, 'O Adam!. Adam will reply, 'Labbaik and Sa'daik (I respond to Your Calls, I am obedient to Your orders), wal Khair fi Yadaik (and all the good is in Your Hands)!' Then Allah will say (to Adam), Bring out the people of the Fire.' Adam will say, 'What (how many) are the people of the Fire?' Allah will say, 'Out of every thousand (take out) nine-hundred and ninety-nine (persons).'

And that would be Bukhari Volume 8, Book 76, Number 537
 
nifurebo said:
If Islam is the right path, why have muslims been killing each other for 1400 years?
Click to expand...

a man would not die and go to war if he truly did not believe in his religion, called war insane crazys whatever u may but i called it nessecary what about them jews that killed all them musilms? muslims dont want war only the jews want war!
 
Ok i think i posted here already but where is the proof that the people who are killing real muslims real proberly they wear masks and say they are muslims to disgress islam and are you a muslim if you are what kind of nonsense are you talking(no offense) and if you aren't give me proof that they are real muslims the proof for the people who are killing
 
wilberhum said:
DELETED POST
Click to expand...

Spare us your sarcastic tongue. Keep in mind we always want a nice, clean discussion in these forums. Although it is not the case always, you and some others are not making it easier for any of us.

This is a last warning.

To NoName55, use the report-button and/or send us PMs with link to the particular post if you want faster action, inshaAllah.

Continue the discussion from now on, with good manners and no personal insults.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
:sl:
Al-Zaara said:
.....

To NoName55, use the report-button and/or send us PMs with link to the particular post if you want faster action, inshaAllah.
Click to expand...
Jazak illah khairan Ukhti, I am sorry for the outburst and I shall, inshaAllah, PM your goodself in future (if I see you in online user list as I used to do with Brothers who, sadly, are no longer here):w:
 
Last edited:
NoName55 said:
:sl:Jazak illah khairan Ukhti, I am sorry for the outburst and I shall, inshaAllah, PM your goodself in future (if I see you in online user list as I used to do with Brothers who, sadly, are no longer here):w:
Click to expand...

Salaamualaikum NoName55!

Don't feel bad about it... Allah will reward you for your efforts - twice or maybe 10 times. This is His promise... and woe to those who mock Allah, hi Prophets and the Believers... theirs is the curse of Allah SWT.... the worst of all curses.

You lose nothing by keeping your sabr... having and keeping sabr is like making an investment... you never know the rewards but it is definite and a joyful thing afterwards.

May Allah continue to increase you iman and deen and guide you always in your dawa.... Ameen!
 
Neelam92 said:
killing seems to have become a game these days
Click to expand...

Salaamualaikum!

It has been the game since time immemorial... the worst type has started in ealry 1950's to early 1960's... when the Birth Control Pill and abortion was introduced.

Human slaughter has been happening ina staggering millions.

And lately, Many countries are becoming an old population due to the culture of not wanting children. If you observe the western world.... even Japan for instance... or many 1st world countries which are non-muslim... they are adopting a culture where having a family is taboo.

Every individual is focused and fixated on their own careers... ego, status, security and welfare.... and - pet dogs or cats.

Many are deluded... they somehow think that this material world is forever... and if they somewhat have a realization that it is not, they would simply adopt the subliminal battelcry motto "****ed if you do, ****ed if you dont!" - a really stupid mental mantra. How are they deluded.

here I go again - getting carried away by one thought after another... sorry mods...

Salaam....

anyway, point is... The Devil wants many people killed as much as possible before they even get a chance to discover Islam.... therefore, it is our duty as real Muslims to spread the Message of Allah... "His Rememberance, the Tawheed, the Promise of Janah - Paradise... and the Reality and Warning of Hell.

This is the reason why - killing is so rampant... it's just a sign that Shaytan is desperate.



Salaam
 
believer said:
Salaamualaikum!

It has been the game since time immemorial... the worst type has started in ealry 1950's to early 1960's... when the Birth Control Pill and abortion was introduced.

Human slaughter has been happening ina staggering millions.

And lately, Many countries are becoming an old population due to the culture of not wanting children. If you observe the western world.... even Japan for instance... or many 1st world countries which are non-muslim... they are adopting a culture where having a family is taboo.

Every individual is focused and fixated on their own careers... ego, status, security and welfare.... and - pet dogs or cats.

Many are deluded... they somehow think that this material world is forever... and if they somewhat have a realization that it is not, they would simply adopt the subliminal battelcry motto "****ed if you do, ****ed if you dont!" - a really stupid mental mantra. How are they deluded.

here I go again - getting carried away by one thought after another... sorry mods...

Salaam....

anyway, point is... The Devil wants many people killed as much as possible before they even get a chance to discover Islam.... therefore, it is our duty as real Muslims to spread the Message of Allah... "His Rememberance, the Tawheed, the Promise of Janah - Paradise... and the Reality and Warning of Hell.

This is the reason why - killing is so rampant... it's just a sign that Shaytan is desperate.



Salaam
Click to expand...

yes i understand and everyword u sed is very true thanks
take care
peace
 
forgot about this thread.. but there are two flaws in the Question
1- I don't accept the premise that 'Muslims have been killing each other for 1400 years' let me just make the same accusations of why are you killing Muslims for 1400 yrs.?
and 2- assuming part I true it still has no bearing on the veracity of the religion.. how can you be a good person and chiseling into people's bones all day?.. If you are an orthopedist then surely you have a reason to be digging into bones all day, but your profession has no bearing on your moral grounds one way or the other..

funny people with non-questions can generate 6 pages of replies based on a flawed premise.. will wonders ever cease?!

:w:
 
After 4 years and 6 pages I believe it is time to let this thread get some sleep.

:threadclo:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Back
Top