sister herb
IB Legend
- Messages
- 9,198
- Reaction score
- 1,026
- Gender
- Female
- Religion
- Islam
Not all women can get married.
Also not all women can get children. Or all men.
Not all women can get married.
I never get married as I am so ugly.
![]()
The concept of females working merely for economic independency has no basis in the Shari?ah. In fact, it is a root of many evils. It is this economic independency in a woman that gives her the courage to break her marital home. Consider the marital breakdown in the US (4-5) due to woman independency. If she was dependant, or her husband, she would exercise restraint and maintain her marriage. That is best in the interest of her family, husband and children. It does not mean that a woman should be dependant on men merely to maintain her marriage.
We have merely expressed the wisdom of a female being dependant. This also does not mean a female cannot be rich. She may earn an income but without violating the laws of the Shari?ah. Firstly, a wife must get the consent of her husband to work. If the husband refuses, she cannot work.
The best job for a woman is looking after the household, bringing up the children and being a dutiful wife to their husbands. Anthing else is competing with men.
ارجمند;1573703 said:Also, what I am saying is different from the definition of equality. I think equality is the source of corruption. It makes people go against their biological nature.
So ensuring marital stability by keeping women economically dependent on men is a good thing? Nevermind that a woman staying in a marriage only because of such dependence would likely be very miserable.
I wonder if the imam, or anyone endorsing this fatwa, would support the securing of marital stability by endorsing actions that rendered men economically dependent on staying married? How about imposing a catastropic economic penalty on any man seeking a divorce? How about it? If economic shackles are a valid way of preventing divorce, it should work both ways, right?
In short, men are the providers and protectors of women.
The status of women in Islam has been elevated to that of 'queens' in this dunya - there is no expectation on her to seek employment....and still fulfill the roles of mother and wife in the home.
This is not about being 'dependant' on men.
Rather, this is about understanding our roles as women, and the commands of Allah - that serve only for our benefit.
Much of our complaints stem from a lack of understanding of our deen.....and if we do possess this knowledge, then are we displeased with Allah's commands upon us?
As-salamu 3laikum sister,
I think the problem in a lot of cases is that many women are in a situation where they don't have any man to provide for and protect them. The fatwa that you posted looks like it was a brother who was asking about his wife working. That's completely different from a woman who has to meet her own needs. If I was married or had male relatives to support me, I wouldn't work, unless the women in the community needed a service that I had the skills to provide, and my husband agreed to it.
As it is, in certain countries it is almost impossible to fulfil all of the conditions for permissible work for women, especially the one about mixed workplaces. In my country I don't know of any all-female workplaces.
This is a serious problem and it feels very bad that people think working women are displeased with the commands of Allah. That is not at all the case, just that we can't seem to find a halal work situation. This is why I personally hope to make hijra as soon as I can in sha Allah, but in the meantime what can I do? We need advice from the scholars that takes into account this situation.
Brother, I sincerely hope that you would read up about the responsibilities of men and women in a marriage.
In short, men are the providers and protectors of women.
The status of women in Islam has been elevated to that of 'queens' in this dunya - there is no expectation on her to seek employment....and still fulfill the roles of mother and wife in the home.
This is not about being 'dependant' on men.
Rather, this is about understanding our roles as women, and the commands of Allah - that serve only for our benefit.
Much of our complaints stem from a lack of understanding of our deen.....and if we do possess this knowledge, then are we displeased with Allah's commands upon us?
:wasalamex
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.