Revision - Al-Mandhoomatul Bayqooniyyah

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mawaddah
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 220
  • Views Views 32K
Mawaddah said:
:sl:

Inside Bayqooniyyah it gives two types of Mubhamd :

1) Mubham al-Matn (Text) e.g. Hadeeth of Ibn Abbas : A man said to Rasulullah "Ya Rasullah! Is the Hajj prescribed every year?......"

2) Mubham as-Sanad e.g. Hadeeth of Raafi' bin Khadeej from his Uncle concerning the forbiddance of Mukhaabarah......

So here his uncle is unknown.

That's what you wanted Princess? :?
Click to expand...

:sl:

Naah that ain't what i wanted.. but this is something else, I think the types I stated are in Baa'ith al-hateeth. hmm! .. la ba's.
 
Mawaddah said:
You fine Umm Abdullah? :D

Okay next Question :

The next two verses are :

وكُلُّ مَا قَلَّتْ رِجَالُه عَـــــــــــــــــــــلا
وَضِدُّهُ ذَاكَ الذِي قدْ نَـــــــــــزَلا

I want to know, what is the Meaning when we say a Particular Hadeeth has an 'Aali (high) chain of narration?

And also, what does it mean when we say that a Hadeeth has a Naazil (lower) chain of narration?
Click to expand...

:sl:

These two took me a while to get when i was studyin them cause they're like the opposite of what they are? lol well anyways.. :D

The Isnaad that is 'Aali/ High in it's chain of narrators means that there are a few narrators in this chain so the number of the rijaal are closer to the prophet 'alayhis-salaam or to one of them Imaams.

and the Isnaad that is: Naazil/ lower in its chain of narrators. is the opposite of that ; meaning there are more narrators in its sanad.
 
Last edited:
:sl:

Next question:

Give an example of a chain that is 'aali/high in its chain of narrators & one that is Naazil/ low in its chain of narrators.

& it can't be one's that have been made up.. search for the real ones ;)
 
I didnt have time to do any revision :p

One comes to my mind, but nto from bayquniyyah tho. Isnad Aali :

from A'mash, From Abi Waaíl, From Ibn masúd.
As for naazil i remember anything atm :D
 
:sl:

Ahsanti. that's alright then, give the next question!

jus outside this: I was tryin to remember bukhari's silsilatud-dahab .. it's an isnad that is 'aali and of of the most authentic..

was it: Maalik 'an Naafi 'an ibn umar ? :?
 
^Yes thats right. You know they have it all in the Baa3ith haashiyah. In the first few pages. I was reading it last night but i cant seem to remmeber a thingggggggg now.
 
:sl:

Ok so its that!? Kool.. alhamdulillah.. :)

I see the bits in the commentary of the Baa'ith.. but it does'nt clearly say that that Isnaad is kadhaa wa kadhaa..
It just has : Asa77ul-asaaneed 'indal bukhaari / the most authentic chain with in Bukhari's opinion.. Maalik 'an Naafi 'an Ibn Umar.

I think it must've been given to us as one of the fawaa'id.

but anyways that's such a neat isnaad :shade:

like 'Amr ibn Shuaib 'an Abeehi 'an Jeddihii Or Hammaad ibn Zayd 'an Thaabit 'an Anas orrr Al-'amash 'an Ibraaheem 'an 'Alqamah 'an Qataadah :statisfie
 
Last edited:
:sl:

We are currently on:

و ما اضفته الي اﻻصحاب من *** قول او فعل فهو موقوف زكن​

Whatever you attribute to the companions regarding..

.. a statement or deed is Mau'quuf​
Click to expand...

So next question is:

What is the definiton of Al-Mau'quuf?
 
:salamext:

Finally, something I can answer.:mmokay:

Mawqoof is when the Hadith is related by the Sahabi, but the isnad does not reach Rasulullah (SAW). So it stops at the sahabi.:)
 
:sl:

Lol ..Corrrrrect!! :)

Next Question:

Give the different types of Al-Mau'quuf.
 
Last edited:
:wasalamex

This is a complete guess, and i'm going to try and answer this based on previous questions:p, but is it....

Mauqoof Qawliy, and Mauqoof Fi'li?:p

I can't be bothered to do my homework.:mmokay:
 
:sl:

MashaAllah ahasanti, Good guess Shaheedah!! :giggling:

but you forgot one more type and that is...

3) Mau'quuf Taqreeriy.

Next question:

Give an example for each type. :)
 
:salamext:

Ok... i'm guessing again.:-[

Qawliy:

Fulan ibn Fulan, said that Fulan ibn Fulan said that ...etc... said that Ibn 'Abbas said '.....'

So it it stops at the saying of a sahabi.:)

Fi'li:

Fulan ibn Fulan, said that Fulan ibn Fulan said that ...etc... said that Ibn 'Abbas did '....'

Similar to the saying of Ibraheem ibn Muhammad ibn al-Muntashir about Masrooq, except stopping at the action of a sahabi. I think.:?

Taqreeriy...:hmm:... I can't guess.:X
 
:sl:

Na'am , & Taqreeriy is: The saying of a Taa'biyy .. I done that & that in the presence of so & so RadiyaAllaahu 'anhu (a sahaabiy) and he did not reject it or denounce it.
 

Similar Threads

Back
Top