WHATS your views on Sharia Laws
- Thread starter ck1986
- Start date
- Replies 91
- Views 8K
British Wholesales - Certified Wholesale Linen & Towels | Halal Food Gastronomy | PHP 8.4 patch for vBulletin 4.2.5
- Status
I find it really hard to understand and accept the fact that if and when a Muslim sins he or she is stoned to death for their sins. Isnt they fact on why Allah created Judgment Day, to judge people for their actions and if required to punish them. Didnt Allah told us not to murder anyone? Didnt Allah created us, isnt Allah the one who can only take our life way and punish us.
Then tell me why in most Muslim Country's it was Banned
Brother, this is NOT a fact. You really need to learn about Islam. This sounds like something someone who is an enemy to Islam wrote and you are taking it as the truth when it is far, far from the truth. Please educate yourself about your religion.
I am educated about my relgion, I do beilve Allah told my not to murder anyone and I shall listen to Allah alone and not do it. Allah has said on Judgment Day everybodys sins is their own, not even a parent and a child could share their sins. Its not up to Muslims to kill others for their sins, only Allah has this right to.
The premise of your post isn't quite right. All of us sin but Islam does not teach us to stone for sinning. That would mean anytime you miss a prayer, say a bad word, look at someone with lust, incorrectly make wudu, backbite, break a traffic law, make unlawful money, deal with interest, you would be stoned to death. Islam does not teach this.
You're right. Islam does teach us not to murder anyone for no just reason. So I'm confused where you're getting this teaching that Islam tells us to stone people for their sins. If that were the case then there would be no Muslims left on the earth.
You're right. Islam does teach us not to murder anyone for no just reason. So I'm confused where you're getting this teaching that Islam tells us to stone people for their sins. If that were the case then there would be no Muslims left on the earth.
Last edited:
Ohh. So you reject the hadith?
I didnt say I reject the hadit, I do follow the way our Prophet lived for praying to fasting and many more
Ohh OK. So you want to learn about the shariah laws for the punishments of people who commit adultery and are thieves. Well, it's not that straightforward. Not that black and white. First of all there have to be 4 witnesses who actually witnessed the adultery take place which is hard enough. And strange even to sit there and watch something like that as a believing Muslim. Then they have to testify in court. And beyond that there is a difference in punishment for one who is or has been married and one who is not married. I remember reading a hadith of a woman who admitted to this and the Prophet peace be upon him sent her away more than once hoping she would repent for the sin and live out her life with the intentions of not falling into again and doing better but she kept coming back. There are different judgements for these things and it's case specific. I've heard from scholars that if you are guilty of adultery or fornication then the best thing to do is to repent to Allah for it and never ever do it again. It's between you and your lord.
I actually like the way Shariah law works. You know, most of the laws that we have here in America are in compliance with Shariah law and I'll have you know that even here in America justice is not carried out in the least with most of the laws we have here. You could be drunk, get in a car and kill someone and only get 7 years in jail, whereas if you get caught with a bag of drugs in your pocket or hidden in your shoes you can go to jail for 25 years.
This is why I said that you need to learn more about your religion because this is one of those topics that people who hate Islam just love to take out of context to try and make Islam look bad.
I'm short on time now but in shaa Allah I can come back later or many other members can link you to some threads which explain this in greater detail. I'm no expert on Shariah Law but from what I've learned of it I like it better and I live here in the U.S.
Last edited:
I guess what I am tryin to say is that WHY does this law exist, I mean Allah alone can punish us for our sins and action. People who follow the law take the role of ALLAH.
its funny you should mention america.
its not every week you see a youtube video of an irate cop taking the law into his own hands...
oh wait.
if anything, it highlights what the law is.
and how it is actually used..
are two different things.
its like having a very big man with a stick..
you know what he wants to do.
or maybe he knows what he should be doing...
the law is there to protect you in both cases.
allah swt does protect and from him is harm also.
it is your test and the test of the big man with the stick.
...neither are allah swt.
but by our own deeds are our undoings.
maybe we should pray more? ...or become religious or something.
its not every week you see a youtube video of an irate cop taking the law into his own hands...
oh wait.
if anything, it highlights what the law is.
and how it is actually used..
are two different things.
its like having a very big man with a stick..
you know what he wants to do.
or maybe he knows what he should be doing...
the law is there to protect you in both cases.
allah swt does protect and from him is harm also.
it is your test and the test of the big man with the stick.
...neither are allah swt.
but by our own deeds are our undoings.
maybe we should pray more? ...or become religious or something.
Last edited:
Why do you think any laws exist at all? Secular laws. What is your opinion about why they are in place?
ALLAH told us not to murder or you will get punished, this is plain murder, whether it has a reason, or not.
What bothers me is the Sharia Law is a law that Muslim are playing the role of Allah
Please answer the question. Why do you think there are secular laws in place for people?
جوري
Soldier Through It!
- Messages
- 27,759
- Reaction score
- 6,095
- Gender
- Female
- Religion
- Islam
You need to produce four witnesses to be stoned and I find it a fair punishment for adultery.
The moral is don't screw around before four witnesses cheat and cheat on your husband or wife. The law is made so that it is virtually impossible to prove unless with a confession, since those who bear false witnesses are the subject of stoning themselves.
As for what we think of sharia law, that is an open ended question. You'd need some schooling in the matter the same way folks attend medical or secular law school or accounting etc.
So we know very little none of us are scholars here and you know even less!
best,
The moral is don't screw around before four witnesses cheat and cheat on your husband or wife. The law is made so that it is virtually impossible to prove unless with a confession, since those who bear false witnesses are the subject of stoning themselves.
As for what we think of sharia law, that is an open ended question. You'd need some schooling in the matter the same way folks attend medical or secular law school or accounting etc.
So we know very little none of us are scholars here and you know even less!
best,
There are plenty of Laws the exits, but none of them kill people for their sins.
A sin is between the person who committed a sin and GOD. IT is up to the person to forgiveness and it is up to GOD whether to forgive that person or punish them.
- Status