One Hundred Christian Proofs Of Islamic Falsehood

[Turin Turambar]

To Malsidab:
I tried to answer your message but I couldn't. I agree completely with you, but isn't the truth worth a little effort? And isn't the key to Christianity having Hope when the situation is hopeless?

 

[Denis Giron]

I just saw this now...

163.) ARGUMENT FROM PAX VOBIS (aka DENIS GIRON ARGUMENT)

Pax Vobis!
Therefore, Islam is false.

I know you meant this is sarcasm, but, really, what? For your information, "Pax Vobis" means "peace be with you". Is a greeting of peace grounds for attack in your opinion?

164.) ARGUMENT FROM FABRICATION OF ARTICLES (aka DENIS GIRON ARGUMENT #2)

I will fabricate articles about miraculous scientific facts related to Islam to see how fast they spread.
Hahaha, they're already on 3 Islamic websites!!
Therefore, I am a genius and have proven Islam to be false.
Therefore, Islam is false.

I never used any such argument. The point was to show the gullibility of some Muslims regarding the scientific-hermeneutic approach, and in that regard I was successful to some degree.

 

[Ansar Al-'Adl]

Greetings Denis,
Welcome to the forum.

Just in case you didn't know, the article was written by Demijan Omeragic, so he's the one to take your response up with.

Peace.

 

[Abdul-Raouf]

All arguments against islam posted in this thread are nonsense

we can write those stupid arguments for any religion.......... and make it false...

 

[Looking4Peace]

That was the most funny illiterate junk i ever read, is this a real argument that people go by?, wow, i think the human race is getting dummer by the day, not everyone, but too many

 

[searchingsoul]

I used to think it was a joke, but recently some christians took it upon themselves to prove that those really are their arguments.

pathetic.

I'm a Christian and I agree that this list of 100 arguments are pathetic and irrational. I want to point out that this list was not composed by a well known or respected Christian scholar. I just ask that Christianity not be judged by the actions of this particular person.

 

[mujahedeen2087]

based on those arguments im converting to christianity...lol

 

[Fishman]

Another argument used by non-Muslims:
1. No man can invent a highly sopisticated religion in 23 years.
2. Therfore Islam is false.

Here's another:
1. There are three biased external reports of Muhammad which contradict Islamic history.
2. There are thousands of possibly baised Muslim reports of Muhammad that conform with Islamic history.
3. The Muslim reports are biased.
4. The non-Muslim reports are also biased, but I'll ignore that.
5. Islam is false.

 

[DAWUD_adnan]

did they really say this?

its weird, and if it is a joke its FUNNY

 

[searchingsoul]

I'm finding that all religious arguments such as these are equally absurd in their allegations, yet brilliant in their explanations. I don't like to devote time to reading such arguments. I think it comes down to a matter of faith or coercion.

 

[Fishman]

did they really say this?

its weird, and if it is a joke its FUNNY

They really did use the arguments that I mentioned.

 

[Malaikah]

1) ARGUMENT FROM DISAGREEMENT

I believe that the Bible is the word of God.
The Qur'ân disagrees with the Bible.
Therefore, Islam is false.

Thats actually not a bad argument. :rollseyes As Muslims we believe things because its been stated in the Quran, and we believe in the Quran.. so anything that disagrees with it must be false.

I think its only fair that christians would make the same claim, even though we dont agree that the bible is true in the first place.

 

[Hijrah]

quite interesting my man, PROPS!

 

[Umar001]

I dont get if this is meanto be a joke or what.

Hmm, why aint this in like the general chat funny jokes or something.

I think I might do an Islamic one.

100 Muslim proofs that Christianity is False.

That would be interesting since I have quizzed some muslim as to why they believe in Islam and their answers were just as bad

 

[searchingsoul]

Thats actually not a bad argument. :rollseyes As Muslims we believe things because its been stated in the Quran, and we believe in the Quran.. so anything that disagrees with it must be false.

I think its only fair that christians would make the same claim, even though we dont agree that the bible is true in the first place.

Excellent point cheese. If we put ourselves in the shoes of the other person, arguments that seem silly to us seem more logical.

 

[Ansar Al-'Adl]

It's fine as a belief but it fails as a logical argument.

 

[wilberhum]

I liked 7 the best.

7) ARGUMENT FROM SIZE
1. Christianity is currently (12/15/03) larger than Islam.
2. Therefore, Islam is false.

Is this the same logic:
1. Islam is the fastest growing religion.
2. Therefor, Islam is true.

 

[snakelegs]

sometimes i just don't understand you muslims and christians.
faith is not something you can prove, with scientific and concrete examples.
it is faith.
for the believer, his religion is true. that seems simple enough to me - why do you feel the need to try to "prove" anything, when it cannot be done???

 

[snakelegs]

Faith should not be placed in unreasonable or illogical doctrines. Faith should be constructed upon logical and objective study of the truth. You may be interested to read the following by Dr. Laurence Brown:
http://www.leveltruth.com/documents/Appendix3.pdf

thanks ansar - looks like an interesting read. will do so later.

 

[Fishman]

115.) ARGUMENT FROM BIZARRE SCIENTIFIC FACTS

1. My dad says bees come from olives.
2. Islam doesn't teach that.
3. Therefore, Islam is false.

Uberlol!